Milky Way

Excellent service, excellent food, and compassionate staff that reintroduce a universally paramount ingredient that seems to be difficult to come across now a days - LOVE. They love what they do, and you can taste it in their food. 10/10 definitely recommend! You can even order online for delivery or take out through their website!

Pizza aficionados who find themselves in either Pittsburgh or Cleveland should definitely make a pit stop at Milky Way Pizza. Both locations offer distinct experiences, and here's a comparative review to guide your pizza journey.

Pittsburgh Location:
Milky Way Pizza in Pittsburgh is a haven for lovers of New York-style pizza. The crust is thin, allowing for that iconic fold, and strikes the right balance between crispy and soft. The tangy sauce, combined with generous toppings and perfectly melted cheese, makes for a delightful bite every time. The ambiance is lively, reminiscent of the bustling pizzerias in New York, and the staff is both friendly and efficient.

Cleveland Location:
The Cleveland branch of Milky Way Pizza offers a different take. The dough here is reminiscent of bread dough, which gives it a thicker and softer texture. However, there have been instances where the dough feels a tad undercooked, which might not appeal to everyone. That said, the toppings are fresh and abundant, ensuring a flavorful experience with each slice.

Best kosher pizza shop in town! The service here is great! Kevin and JJ were very helpful!

Good pizza. Great flavor. It was nice to see the kosher pizza in this town (place) is on par with quality and flavor of the national standard. Because of the taste and it's lack of proximity to large cities with more or potentially better options, it's 5 star all around. (unlike some "out of town" places that unfortunately have one or 2 pizza stores and neither are good).

I like that they make their own bread. That's never a bad thing. They call there fries spicy but they're just seasoned for people a little intimidated by the name they're good.I will try the pizza next time. I'll definitely be back.

Fantastic hidden gem. Expected a little pizza place. Found the most unique selection of pizza I've ever seen. The cheddar ranch was delicious as were the fries. The menu was huge and everything was delicious.

Very nice clean and friendly place!
Food was very good.
Recommend on going there

High quality kosher food. Staff was really friendly and food service was fast. A dank!

This kosher pizza restaurant has a wide selection of pizza, baked ziti, and other diary products. The people who work there are very friendly. It is definitely recommended.

Excellent Kosher option in Pittsburgh. I got the cod fish panini. One of the best I've ever tasted. Pizza was great too

The pizza is over the top. It is much different than the pizza one eats. When was the last time you ate the crust and really enjoyed it. When was the last time you ate left over pizza and it was enjoyable, and all you think about was getting another. I love their white cheese spinach pizza with olives.
The salad bar is nice also. They have every veggy you can think of. And they are large sizes. Enough for two.
The only down side to this business is finding somewhere to park.
You will not regret spending in The Milky Way.

Excellent food and great service every time! The white (Roma) pizza is the best around!

Had the cheese pizza. Which to me tastes exactly the same as the Sam's Club Cheese Pizza Combo for $2.49. With either, you get 8 minutes of pure greasy cheesy bliss, followed by 8 hours of regret where you won't feel hungry, but neither will you have the motivation to do anything other than sit and stare at the walls. Do not operate heavy machinery after eating the cheese pizza.

First time here- fast and delicious! I loved the falafel wrap. Huge menu - can’t wait to come back and try more!

Ordered from the road, was ready when we got there. Delicious and made all according to our requests!

My gf had a couple slices of Pepperoni pizza, i had a "small" calzone (definitely larger than small by my standards) with Pepperoni, mushrooms, mozzarella, ricotta and sauce, with sauce on the side. I had a margarita, she had a bottled cider. Grand total under $26. Amazing value for the amount of food/drinks. The music was a tad loud for my liking, made conversation tough, but great overall time, taste and value.

Really good meals. The entire family was very happy and thoroughly enjoyed there meals. Very helpful and large portions

Excellent service, very good food.

Had a wonderful experience at Milky Way. The food was delicious and prepared and served quickly. The staff were pleasant and held a wonderful conversation while we waited (which was not long at all!) Definitely recommend for some delicious vegetarian cuisine!

The people were really kind, and the food was good. We tried their vegetarian chicken parm hoagie, it was filling and the chicken had good texture and taste. It’s a bit pricey but we will be coming back.