Infinity Toys and Collectibles

I am super stoked I came across this shop via Facebook! I live in Tennessee, but that didn’t stop this cool shop owner on making a deal with me! I was able to score an action figure I had been looking for, and I got a super good deal on them both! Shop owner shipped out the next day, with a tracking number, and I received these cool gems within a couple days. Items were packaged very carefully- bubble wrapped and paper wrapped to ensure safety. I will definitely do business in the future to hopefully get the rest of this shop’s Resident Evil collection. Check them out you all, you won’t be disappointed!

My son and I stopped by the store today for the first time and we LOVED it! There was something for everyone, new and vintage. We will definitely be back the next time we are in Lafayette!

100th! Review. They had all the Kenner Batman toys I loved playing with as a kid

I’ve been coming here since 2020 and I’ve always had excellent service. Even coming from Indianapolis, this is my favorite toy store I’ve been to and Mikes knowledge sense of customer service is what keeps bringing me back. I recommend for any collector in the area.

This store has friendly staff, and an amazing selection of Ninja Turtles including this gem!

I adore this place! It feels like a little hidden gem down in downtown Lafayette. Plenty of awesome stock for reasonable and agreeable prices. Would encourage everyone to go check out this place!

Best collector’s shop in Lafayette!!!
Mike is one of the nicest store owners I have ever met!!! Definitely coming again!!

Lot of great stuff, modern as well as vintage. Friendly service, prices seem a bit high, but it's to be expected and the products are worth the price.

Amazing selection of toys and collectibles and the owner is knowledgeable and friendly!

Absolutely phenomenal store well worth the drive l. Thank you for the great experience and conversation. I look forward to doing business again.

A friend and I visited Infinity Toys a couple months back in June 2023. Experience was fantastic and the owner was incredibly personable, friendly and helpful. Selection was great and he worked with me as I sold him a bunch of loose figures and he gave me extra store credit so I could walk out of the store with a NECA 18" Batman and Catwoman. A great experience and I plan on going back real soon!

Pretty darnt good. Prices seem to be a bit under Ebay. Owner/Operator be wicked knowledgeable. Go check out FAM

Awesome selection and really good prices on their collectibles.

Excellent store with plenty of collectibles to choose from at reasonable pricing!! Super friendly and will work with you! Quick shipping as well!!!

Great place to rediscover your childhood. Always an exciting time at Infinity Toys!

Incredible selection in a small space. Prices are fantastic as well. Owner is a really nice guy and fun to chat with. I will definitely be coming back at some point.

I went into this store for the first time today. Such a treat of a store, I had no clue about it but I’ll definitely be back. Great collection of figures ranging from low priced items to high end collectibles. Great to see such a quality collectible store near Purdue.

I don't get to visit Infinity Toys and Collectibles as often as I'd like, but I've never had a bad experience here. The store is clean and the items are well organized and easy to view. Prices are reasonable. Owner is personable and always attentive to his customers. I appreciate the social media presence with business hour changes or any questions I may have about a particular item or availability. Great store. It's nice to have a local store of this type.

A must stop toy store for any collector in the area! Huge inventory and fun atmosphere! Definitely come check it out

Went and sold some items
Amazing selection of anything you could ever want in the collectible world!
Owner is very nice and friendly. Always a positive experience.