On The Bay Boutique, Bar & Cafe

The food and drinks here are really good. The food menu is small, which is probably why it's great. We sat at a high top by the window, which was nice, and I'm sure it's even better in the summertime. The dining room is small and probably fills up fast when it's busy. The food is on the expensive side, but you get a good size amount for it. I wouldn't go all the time, but I will definitely go again.

My favorite place! Amazing food and service. Cute shop with great Xmas gift ideas. Back patio with gazebo's, cozy fires, blankets and amazing cocktails. Owners and staff go above and beyond!

Delicious 😋 food!!!! We stopped in from SC and NC!! We fell in love with the food 😍 the lobster flat bread was so delicious and that sweet delicious sauce just sets it off!
My friend had the Lobster Mac and it was outta this world she said! This will be a regular stop for us when we are in town.

Got a lobster roll and lemonade slush delivered by Door Dash. Everything was packaged extremely securely and was also very fresh. The lobster roll was delicious.. I can't wait to order again. 5+ stars

We had the most wonderful Woman in Business with The Anchor Bay Chamber yesterday! The food and service was top notch! The owner was so friendly! I absolutely LOVE the atmosphere! I cannot wait to go back:)

Absolutely fabulous hidden gem. We dined outdoors in the middle of winter here in Michigan. The service was second to none. They warmed our gazebo up perfectly. Our waitress was attentive and the food delivered to us was delicious 😎Drinks were on par too.

This establishment reminds me of places like Martha's Vineyard and Key West. The atmosphere is casual and fun. Their menu has a nice selection. The lobster mac n cheese was great! Have suggested friends pay a visit. I will be back.

Adding this place to my list of favorites. I have been looking for good fish tacos for years and theirs knocked it out of the park. The burger, bosco sticks and mac and cheese were all amazing too. The back outdoor patio was perfect atmosphere and service was quick and friendly. I highly recommend.

Service was prompt and polite. We got our food quickly and it was all delicious. Really love the atmosphere here and could see myself coming out with friends and family for some drinks. Can't wait to go back!!!

Like others have said, a hidden gem. Mahi Mahi tacos, lobster bowl, lobster roll, smoothy, bloody mary, cosmo and desserts all exceeded our expectations. Staff efficient and friendly, owner was kind, funny and visited with the guests while helping the staff. Four of us celebrating Mother's Day and well worth the 2 hour drive to get there. Thank you!

Great restaurant with a super cute little gift shop! The seating in the back is great, lots of fire tables and all sorts of table heights to make you extra comfy! The food was very good and the service was excellent.

Food was excellent! Awesome, kid friendly, outdoor patio! Great service!
Stopped here while camping in Algonac and will be back.

We absolutely love this place! The staff is always very friendly and accommodating and the food is outstanding! We love the lobster rolls, rice bowls, and just about everything. Every time we try something new it has been fantastic. We go on the weekends and sit in the outside cabanas. Joe the owner is awesome and always stops to talk to us and check on us. Keep up the great work! If you have not tried this place, you must!

Oh, wow! What a local gem! This is an unassuming shop front that has a nice patio area out back. They have a full service bar that makes specialty cocktails and smoothies. And the food... oh, the food! The menu is small and lobster focused, but what they do they do oh so well. The lobster flat bread is very tasty and the lobster roll is to die for! Large pieces of tender, sweet lobster are served in a super soft roll. An absolute must try!!!

One of my favorite places to eat! Everything I've eaten has been delicious...Brussel sprouts, steak tips, dill pickle pizza, cuban sandwich, and salads. They specialize in lobster. I'm told it's awesome. I'm just not a fan of seafood. The atmosphere is amazing any time of year. There's enclosed (or open) tents outside to accommodate all weather. The inside is super cute. They also have fun lake decor, clothing, and accessories.

Had a magnificent lunch here! The lobster room was excellent. The lobster Flatbread was also very good. Very eclectic and fun! Super friendly staff. Owner said hi. Nice and clean. Southall gift shop. Fabulous food and beverages. Will go back soon!!!

LOVE THE NEW updates and increased bar & cafe 'inside' now! Fun food and easy to have fun here!

Very comfortable space with great comfortable furniture to hang out and have a interesting bite to eat with a Tiki cocktail. They also have full Bourbon bar and just about anything you could come up with for a cocktail! Great new menu for summer - We had the mussels and I almost drank the broth out of the bottom when finished - excellent! NICE JOB on the remodel! See you soon!

ALSO - Fun place for group party outside - make a reservation!

Comfortable outdoor garden space to relax and take in the nice weather. Umbrella tables as well as several large gazebos for a chilly evening or the occasional rain day. Also open in the winter where you may sit inside heated areas and dine on interesting seasonal options for food and drinks - we started with a Rum Runner made with their own special ingredients…. Better than Florida!

They have an ever changing menu where Lobster is the highlight ingredient in many dishes. We tried the Lobster Shrimp Dip and had the new blackened Mahi with fresh Brussel sprouts. Lots of good flavor in both and was plenty for the two of us to share.

We took home a mini Lobster quiche and had a filling breakfast for two the next day - will order that again. Great crust, plenty of lobster chunks and roasted potatoes inside the quiche made it very filling for us to share.

If you have to wait for a table no problem! Boutique and tiki indoor bar too while you wait.

Very cute patio area with plenty of shaded options as well as spots in the sun. My server, Brooke, was very kind and attentive. I started with the bloody mary (they also offer a loaded option) and it was tasty. For lunch I ordered the lobster roll, which came with the option of pasta salad or pineapple coleslaw. The pasta salad was pretty generic, but nice as a cool side option. However, the lobster roll was delightful. The perfect amount of butter and the sweet Hawaiian roll was a perfect complement to the richness of the lobster. Finally, I ordered a Sunny Day smoothie to go (pineapple, peach, mango, piña colada and mango mix). The smoothie was fruity and tropical and very thick. Next time I would opt to have it made with coconut milk.

What an awesome spot! Cool place with so much in it I can't even tell you and then the food ,seriously it is awesome. Friends had the Lobster flatbed and I sampled the burnt ends over rice bowl and the chicken mac. Food was fresh and flavorful.Heated outdoor seating and the staff was pleasant . We will definitely be back and looking forward to seeing this place flourish!

That pretzel tho!!!! dude 😎

Downtown New Baltimore location.
This is somewhere to take the time to drive to. My boyfriend said the Lobster Bisque was the best he has ever had anywhere! Cute comfortable outdoor seating or curbside pick up. Lobster grilled cheese, Key lime pie and assorted desserts, A+smoothies, vegetarian options, salads, pulled pork, chicken and again the chunky Lobster bisque....
A really cute gift shop that was clean, bright with friendly happy employees. Very unique items from nautical to jewelry- clothing- sweaters & jackets to t-shirts, unique clocks, sun faces, assorted bottled sauces--- Lots of items nicely displayed. Higher end novelty shop.
This is a place that would be great to pick up a nice dinner and take it home to enjoy as the weather gets colder!
This owner is creative and detailed in making this unique with cozy seating areas in an open air area.
Yes I am enthusiastic- this is a fun place to check out!