Timoti's Seafood Shak

This place was great. I looked for a place with quality seafood bites at affordable prices and Timoti’s delivered and exceeded expectations. The food was delicious. I have 4 kids and there was something for everyone on the menu. The service was excellent and the food came out fast. I had shrimp tacos that were vibrant in flavor. Go for the fried green tomatoes, but ask for peppers and sauce on the side unless you like them sweet.

We visit this place every time (multiple times!) we visit Amelia Island. Affordable food that is delicious, lovely staff, and a beautiful outdoor seating area.

If weather is poor, take your food to go - there are no indoor seating options. Outdoor seating is protected from overhead sun. Playground for the kids adjacent to the seating so kids can play while parents eat.

We recommend the fish sandwich, fish basket, and the impressively sizable caesar salad!

Very delicious food at an amazing price. Located in onbthe main strip on Amelia Island, this place is a must eat. We had the shrimp tacos and shrimp po boy. Fast and friendly service. Outdoor seating only so dress accordingly.

Heck yeah, absolutely melt in your mouth fried oysters! Delicious lobster roll. Market price lobster roll is $25 for two small rolls, really good tastin y’all!

This place is great. The food tastes great, is SUPER reasonable, and comes out super fast. Somehow, two lobster rolls is only 19 dollars! They also have metal souvenir cup with unlimited refills that’s only 1$ more than the plastic, non refillable cup. A great place to bring family and friends 👍

The food was reallllllly good. I had the coconut rice bowl with blackened shrimp. Phenomenal. We also had hush puppies (10/10), fried calamari (10/10) and fried green tomatoes (10/10). The staff was also super friendly and seemed like they were happy to be there.

Best of all there’s a fenced in, one way out, play area in the back of the outdoor patio which makes bringing kids a breeze.

Oh and we only paid $30 for 2 meals and 3 sides. Can’t say enough about how quality this place is.

This was our first stop in town, and it was the perfect light lunch. It was quite popular and difficult to find a seat. I opted for a salad as a wrap, and it was full of color and flavor. Check out the photo! I particularly enjoyed the hush puppies as a side. The only downside is that there are no mixed drinks. That's their other location.

Service was great, incredible tacos and hush puppies, but can live without the slaw. The playset was perfect for the kids while waiting for food!

Fish taco, shrimp taco, crab cake sandwich +
Kids shrimp + salad, kids chicken + oranges

Whenever I am in Fernandina, I always go to Timoti's. It never disappoints. Great seafood at reasonable prices! Blackened fish is delicious. Service is good. Love the casual atmosphere. Seating is limited, but you can always take your food to go and enjoy at your place. Highly recommend!

Wonderful lunch!! Loved the fried green tomatoes! Wish there was a bit more mango salsa on them though.
Fried Oysters were delish!! 😋
Will certainly return again!!

Delicious food and friendly service. We had the blackened shrimp chopped salad, a wrap, cucumber salad and hush puppies. All items exceeded expectations, especially the blackened seasoning on the shrimp.

Such good spot, we had so many options to eat and picked this gem, everything from the seating is perfect. And be respectful tip your staff

This place was so good that I got a second shrimp basket. I wish I was kidding because it’s a little embarrassing to have two meals. I had the blackened shrimp and the grilled shrimp and both were excellent. Fries were hot and fresh and the slaw was perfect. Hush puppies were amazing as well. I have a dairy allergy and the staff was helpful in knowing what I could and couldn’t have. I do wish there was indoor seating because we would go back tomorrow on our way out of town but it will be too cold for dining outside. We definitely will return when we visit again.

Everything was awesome! Good food. Quick service! Great hospitality! Only bummer was 2 kids running around shrieking! Ear piercing! Stay love the place

Really good food, but I wish they gave a little more shrimp for the price. Still would recommend though!

I don’t like fancy places. Good food, friendly people and reasonable prices make an excellent restaurant to me. So Timoti’s is one of my favorites. They have a great menu that even has tofu for the Vegan in family. The tacos, wraps and baskets are my favorites. The playground is great when you have kids.

The food was really good and prices are about what you would expect in a tourist area. The playground is a nice touch for the kids. Seating is outside and it’s hot at lunch in the summer, but there is shade.

Great place for lunch. Outdoor seating only, at communal picnic tables.

The best shrimp taco I've ever had, and hush puppies are pretty good too!

Awesome seafood off the town mainstream. Food is delicious outside seating only and great. Kids area to play. It is not huge, so seating may be challenging, especially on weekends. But it is so good you can take it to go and find a park to enjoy. Go during the week like I did.

I love Seafood Restaurants that are outdoors. The restaurant is so nice and clean. The cashier was excellent and suggested me the best. The food was amazing, specially the Fried Calamari. Next time I will go for more food. At Timothys you will find the best seafood in North Florida. Everything is delicious, but my favorite is the Poke Bowl, wonderful. The attention is very good, you request your food, they call you and you sit down. Everything is very organized and the clientele is very respectful. Go, you guys are going to have a great time.