Rodeo New York

My fiancé presented me with an engagement ring that I initially liked but I didn't love. So, I asked my fiancé would he be terribly offended if he and I designed the engagement ring together and of course, he said no. Then he referred me to Rodeo Jewelers.
From the moment I stepped in the store, everyone was willing to listen and give advice needed to help me find the perfect engagement ring. I showed Shenul one picture of what I wanted and immediately she gave me a price, color, cut, clarity and carat of the diamond and also made suggestions on the band setting. At the end of the day, I was completely surprised. Even though I helped design the engagement ring, I was so surprised it turned out way more beautiful than I could have ever expected. The center stone is 2 carats and the side stones have to be at least .5 carats. I was set on a 3 carat but that wasn't quite in the budget. Shenul assured me the 2 carat would be just as beautiful and she was right. You guys custom made this ring just for me and exceeded EVERY expectation!!! I can't stop looking at it. Will definitely be calling you for the wedding bands!

I have been looking for another Herringbone necklace for years. I received a flyer in the mail from Rodeo Jewelers advertising one. I reached out and within minutes Jessica responded that she had exactly what I was looking for and followed up with pictures. Today I purchased my 14mm Herringbone necklace and was totally satisfied with my purchase. Please go check them out a tell them Shcharansky (Sha-ran-ski) sent you.

Great service and great quality. I was able to broker the deal of a lifetime for my brother's Rolex. JJ and Amun seemed honest and unbiased. I have dealt with other jewelers and been left with a sour taste in my mouth. NOT HERE! No pressure salesmanship approach hand willing to given excellent advice. My brother and I will be returning here first before we purchase elsewhere!

Shenul the assistance manager and Asher have a great personality and they provided a excellent services ,don't forget to always ask for that extra discount, you will enjoy the negotiations,

I had a great experience dealing with Shenul. She was very patient and worked with me generously on prices.

I first purchased here in 2014 but over the last 3-4 years this has become my home jeweler. The staff is always pleasant and attentive. They are very transparent and offer to provide the best options without compromising quality. I recently gave them a task to create a pendant using the materials from a damaged engagement ring and they did not let me down! Thank you guys so much for always treating me like a valued customer and providing me with the best quality jewelry.

Mr. Aman and Jessica were just a blessing to work with. My husband and I went looking to put a stone in a ring but the stone we had was "man made" which we knew. And Mr. Aman was telling us why he didn't feel comfortable to do it because he wanted us to get the best quality ring for the stone, so he showed us different stones for a setting that I was looking at. To make this short I'm so glad I choose this stone that I have in my ring. The top ring is the one we choose the second one I went back and ordered for my birthday. I will definitely be going back to Rodeo for any other jewelry purchases.

Had the best experience there for my first custom piece and plan on sending all of my friends and family there as well 10/10 experience. Shenul did a very great job taking care of me 👍🏽

I loved the service and the hospitality.. they seem like very genuine people 💯💯

Anoosha and Usher were amazing.! They helped me pick out an amazing gift for my best friend on her birthday. Please go see them and their manager Shenul.!!they are amazing.!!! Thank you.!

Updated review:
Flash forward to today 1/17/2022. I wanted to update my review because I went back to Rodeo Jewelers 12/2021 and was able to come out with a diamond flower necklace that the owner assisted me with getting for my 72 year old mother. And when she opened it on Christmas she absolutely loved it! As did I. Thank you again for helping my mother smile and this will be my jewelers for life 💯❤🥰 Lovely atmosphere and helpful staff 💯

Previous review:
Went in just to look and Mark helped me immensely! I found a great ring for my now husband and when we got married I gave it to him and he Loved it💯 Great experience and my husband is getting me another ring from them as well. Helped me with a great price as well.

Shenul has been taking great care of my family jewelry since 2016. We value her opinion and appreciate her expertise. Highly recommended!

Birthday items.... exotic cut necklace and bracelet.... prices were very reasonable... all around great experience. I'll be back again for a POSSIBLE engagement ring! ;)

Great location. Great staff. Great prices. Always enjoy visiting as I have always received the help I need. Whether I am buying a new piece or getting something fixed. I have never felt pressured to buy but they are always helpful finding what I'm looking for. Every visit is worthwhile.

They provided excellent customer service and was very helpful with assisting with us picking our jewelry. We'll definitely be shopping again soon.

Great customer service and shopping experience. The entire staff always made us feel welcomed even when they were busy. Thank you Shenul, A.J ,J.J and Mark for helping my family and I find the perfect wedding bands. I highly recommend them and consider them my lifetime jewlers.

The staff at Rodeo was very helpful and courteous and they made sure I was completely satisfied with everything before I left. They have a large inventory and fair prices, and i cant see mysefp shopping with anyone else for my jewerlry needs. Thanks again Mrs Shenul.

Shenul and sharron are amazing! I have been with Rodeo Jewelry for 6yrs. I buy all my jewelry from them. I am grateful! Thanks guys!!!

I been going here for all my jewelry for 5+ years. Never once have I felt pressured to spend more or less money. That's a huge bonus for me. Everyone of their employees are pleasant and friendly. And thank to them I will hopefully have a finance soon. Fingers crossed🤞.

Fantastic staff, extremely professional, not overly aggressive, helped understand all my options for the price range I was looking for, will most definitely returning to this store again.