Brooklyn Pizza

Ordered chicken parm but in a vodka sauce; it was delicious! Love that the chicken is crispy. Perfect sized cutlet. The garlic knots complemented the meal perfectly.

Food was delicious! Love the type of pizza they serve. It’s new york style. You can basically customize it however you like. Order came out on time and workers were prompt. The calamari had a great taste and the garlic knots were cooked just right. I would eat here again.

Best cashier and servers , best pizza , with a delicious taste and very fast service. I highly recommend this place to come and eat in with your family or even by yourself. Very nice and clean place . Wonderful customer service .

The best wings I have ever had...I am being 100% honest when I say I have not had a better wing at any other restaurant, pizzeria, and even Buffalo wild wings. They are breaded to perfection and cooked perfectly. The only spot I'm going to get wings from now on!

One of the best places to eat in, I had shrimp francese it was very delicious it had fresh vegetables and ver well done. The waitress was very friendly I loved her . Great to come in with family.

Moved here from Jersey City about a year ago and this is the best delivery pizza we’ve tried in the area. Crispy thin crust and the red sauce is amazing.

Fabulous! This is the best pizzeria hands down! Amazing food. Great prices. Phenomenal service. They really care about the quality of their food and service. They are owned by a veteran and they give back to the community.

I got a large cheese pizza tonight and it was excellent. I must say truly lives up to the Brooklyn name. They are in an odd location. It’s not the best but it’s worth going here my father, who is very picky had some of this pizza and had an extra slice because he said it was good and let me tell you something he never says it’s good and he’s hundred percent Italian.

The food from Brooklyn Pizza is among the best take-out in this area of NJ. We've lived in New Providence and Gillette for 26 years and Brooklyn Pizza's delicious Grandma's Pizza, hot heroes, pastas, and appetizers are great each time - and the kitchen & register/phone staff work hard and are super nice. We've lived in the 1980s and '90s in Brooklyn, Manhattan and Queens and we've never "experienced" a Grandma's Pizza until we found THIS Brooklyn. I tell my friends living in NY that Jersey pizza is as good if not better than anything you get in Manhattan, Queens and - aye, fuggedabout it- get on the Turnpike and check out Brooklyn Pizza in Sterling and you may be moving to the Garden State soon enough! Which exit??

Very solid pie. Thin with the perfect amount of crisp at the edges. It had a very good ratio cheese to sauce as well. The Sauce is on the tangier side vs sweet, but it tasted great!

This is definitely one of the better pies in the immediate area! It's refreshing to have pizza that is so thin and not totally overloaded with the too much cheese. Also reheats really well. Hopefully they maintain the quality.

The pizza was amazing. I ordered two regular slices and a calzone, which were huge, combined with friendly service, it doesn't get better than this.

Amazing food! Great place to go, vary nice and friendly staff. Highly recommend stopping by.😋🍕

Excellent neighborhood pizzeria! I’ve tried traditional and Sicilian pies, wings, and garlic knots and have only positive things to say.

The pizza is perfect! Nice, thin crust, great sauce/cheese/crust proportions, pleasant staff!

They have two location, Short Hills location make nice Thin Crust. Jose & Jose still in learning process. Advise to visit other location. Anyway good Thin Crust pizza. Very unique tomato’s sauce.

Absolutely love All American Pizza! Nick absolutely puts his all into this great little local pizza place. The patriotic decor is great and this place always impresses me with the upkeep! The only pizza place I will eat the crust and thats a rare thing. 100% stop by this great place and support your local businesses and veterans.

They make a great thin sliced pizza 🍕 ranking up there with a couple of famous places in North Jersey

Their pizzas are great, and knowing it’s veteran owned makes it taste even better! Tastes like freedom! Just sell 2 liter sodas, not just the can sodas. That way when I do pizza parties, it’s a one-stop deal for me. Other than that.. they’re amazing. Ooh Rah!

My husband, son and I have eaten here quite a few times since they opened and have had pizzas, salads and entrees. Everything is fresh, made to order and delicious. Can't wait to go back and try another of their gourmet pizzas!

Excellent pizza and very friendly atmosphere!