Panatieri's Pizza & Pasta of Flemington

If you love a juicy pizza with extra cheese, then you will love Panatieri’s Pizza. I visited this location for the first time and was very pleased with their slices. My pizza was thin and crispy with lots of cheese and a good sauce. This is one of the best pizza slices I have had in Hunterdon County. Highly recommend trying this location when in the area. I will certainly be back! Great job 👏🏼

I took a pic of what was left of the works pizza. Always get a great meal here. The sauce is always balanced and slightly spicy, they don’t use a ton of cheese and the crust is perfectly cooked & slightly sweet.

Really enjoyed this pizza place! We were greeted as soon as we entered! The food was presentable and tasted delicious! Definitely returning in the future 👍🏼

Best italian food in Flemington with the nicest owners! Their vodka sauce is top notch! Will definitely return!

By far, the best pizza in the area! Need to give these guys credit for raising the bar. I've been to Panatieri's pizza four times now to get a slice or two on my way home from work and was pleasantly surprised each time.

Firet time there. It was fantastic!!! Delicious food great service and great atmosphere. We had pizza. Four slices of different kinds. Can not tell you what was the favorite bc they all were Delicious. But if I had to choose. It would be the one with pesto on it. Not sure the name. But that would be my go to pizza.

The food was good. My sister ordered a pie with appetizers and other sides. I had the calamari with the sweet sauce. I also grabbed a white/milk chocolate decorated pastry filled with chocolate mousse; very decadent. I could not ignore the woman behind the counter gossiping about me in Italian though. It made me feel a bit uncomfortable. I can’t speak on the atmosphere, as we ordered for pick up. The girl who checked me out was very friendly as well as the guy who educated me on the pastry. Nonetheless, I definitely recommend their food. I’m not sure how long they’ve been doing business in Flemington. I’d travel to Dominick’s if I wasn’t pressed for time.

I have to give a huge shoutout to Joe (owner) from Panatieri's. Not only does he make the best pie in town but he's also one of the nicest guys around. I'll come into his shop a few times a month and have dinner with my family. He has good food all around but I especially love his speciality pies. Chicken parm pie, Chicken bacon ranch pie, Margarita pie - all can't go wrong.

Great place, great food, great people. Thanks Joe!

Panatieri’s is our go-to for amazing pizza! The service is always great.

We mostly do take out, everyone is so friendly. And they talk to you and show you offers they have. Really lovely experience 😊

One of the best cheesesteaks that I ever had….and I have had a few.

I called twice about a black hair in the sandwich I bought, non ediable 14. 00? They put me on hold twice and never picked up
? THEY HAVE RESPONDED TO THIS REVIEW WHICH I am grateful for.
Yes , I know things happen, I managed a five diamond restaurant/piano bar for 23 yrs.
They have asked me to call, which I will tomorrow.

i'm not a 'big reviewer' per say - but this place is absolutely awesome. I literally can't drive by without stopping for a slice and or one of their awesome 'pre-made to-go' soups or dinners. Their pizza slice selection is like no other pizza place I have been to. Super friendly staff and absolutely awesome food. If i could give them more stars i would !!! Keep up the good work :)

Panatieri's has been providing top notch food for our company for the past couple of years. Joe and his team have been very accommodating to our corporate needs; but just as important...the food has been nothing short of tasting amazing! The presentation of the hoagie trays to the baked dishes, even down to the great tasting pizza. It's also nice to stop in for lunch to see Joe, say hello, and get some hot pizza slices. I would recommend Panatieri's Pizza to anyone in the Flemington area if you're looking for great service and even better tasting food.

Delicious food all around, plus a pleasant and friendly atmosphere, Joe the owner, his wife Isabella and his son Giovanni are fantastic chefs. Pizza is out of this world!! And dinners are reasonable and authentic home made with home made sauce... delicious all around. My family and I been going there for years. The staff is always friendly and courteous. Atmosphere is cozy and clean. We love it... You have to try to see.

My favorite 🍕 place around! The Frank has become my new favorite pie 😍

Why go anywhere else! You can't find a better resturant anywhere. Not only is the pizza the best around, but everything on the menue is outstanding. I can't wait to see the new remodeling once completed! Tell Joe, Reverend Harry sent you!

My husband and I ordered from here which we have quite a few times and there food was delicious. Well tonight we ordered the fried calamari for 2 our bill came out to over $70 dollars with everything.The fried calamari was disgusting. It was dry as hell and when you bit into it it was cold like it was frozen.I am very disappointed.Will never order this again from here.

The food here never disappoints. Since COVID hit they have adapt their dining space into a in house deli where they make homemade FRESH bread daily, and homemade cheeses. They also have a grab & go market with meals already made and some just have to be heated up at home. Their market section is where you can purchase authentic products to create your own meal at home. They still have the main part of the pizzeria with the wide arrange of food options from appetizers to desserts available for take-out or delivery! As well as still offering catering. If you have not tried them yet, you are surely missing out. Highly recommend :) My favorite is a Brooklyn Slice or the Tortellini Al Forno!

Really great pizza and really nice workers here. Some great atmosphere and good music!