Marty's Pizza Pasta & Subs

Delicious!! So glad they reopened this location. The pizza is thin crust and LOADED with toppings. I got a large deluxe works and 4 cheesy bread. It was enough for 4 hungry people.
Staff are really nice too. Price is a little higher than neaby pizza places, but the quality here is amazing.

I've been going to Marty's for the longest time. I have never had a bad pizza or any other entrée. Only once did I get so-so service. That's rare today. This is now where others may not like this part but so be it. I'm so disgusted our government spawned over-entitled morons by paying them not to work. They got addicted to that and now believe they should get a high wage for entry-level employment or a side job for extra cash. Almost all have zero experience and put in minimal effort if they even show up. This has driven numerous businesses under. Almost all are small ones. Marty's almost become one but is still hanging on. If you want them to keep going, eat in, or order carryout. Otherwise " Oh, I wish they were still around that would taste good right now " is all you can mutter. We all eat pizza. Letting highly customized pizza, in many sizes, just disappear would be a serious crime. Help prevent pizza crime.
If you made it to the end I wanted to end on more of a high note. Plus now I'm hungry. And guess what sounds good? Is anyone shocked it's pizza? Didn't think so. Thanks for reading this if you did.

Alright lemme get to it! We were a party of four who chose to sit in a booth as we thought the chairs lacked some cushion. We're aging and like comfort, I must admit. Problem solved. While my husband thought the onions on the pizza were a bit large for his taste (we did get some chunky ends), I think overall, the pizza was delicious (we ordered CSO half M). Patty(i) was wonderful – she kept our beverages coming even before we were out, among other things such as guiding us on which size pizza to get. We're sooooo glad we didn't get the colossal or the one just below that one. We ended up ordering the family sized pizza, which was fine for four hungry adults. We had 8 slices leftover that my friend and I will be eating for lunch soon today. Yaaaaas 💅 I think the order of the sizing goes family, party, colossal, and super after the extra large! 😳 OKAY! Okay... okay... o...k... What else? I also need to emphasize how attentive Patty(i) was to our needs. She even had asked if we were going to have enough (pizza slices to fill us up). She was the only server (I saw), and she was moving! Thank you Patty(i) for taking care of us Wednesday night. We had a lovely time.

I've been going to Marty's for many years, and always considered it the best pizza in Milwaukee. I don't know if they've recently changed the cheese, but the pizza I ordered last night was one of the best I've ever had. Marty's has always had the best toppings, fresh vegetables, handmade sausage, and they don't skimp either. The crust has changed over the years but I think it's actually gotten closer to a traditional Milwaukee cracker crust, which I love since it doesn't just flop in your hand. Still my favorite pizza in Milwaukee and I'll always go out of my way to get it.

I placed an order on Thursday for a Friday lunch delivery, it turned out perfect!!!! The pizza was as delicious as always and I have to give a thumbs up about the garlic bread, its was Amazing. From the woman taking my order, the cooks, and the gentleman who delivered it I want to say Thank You and Merry Christmas.

I moved out of state and haven’t had Marty’s in five years. Finally got a chance to order deluxe works and the cheese bread and it was still fantastic as I remember loaded with toppings and simply fantastic. Thank you Marty for welcoming me home.😁

Great pizza. A good tasting and solid crust to support the heavy toppings. Don't let the height of the box throw you off, it is a heavy pizza. The veggies are fresh, the sauce ratio is good, and plenty of cheese. I would recommend to others and I will return again myself.

First time I ate Martys Pizza. Best pizza I ever had! I am 81 years old so ive had a lot of pizza. Will be ordering Martys whenever I crave pizza. I also ordered a antipasto salad. I came with no anchovies. Very disappointing.

My first time here today and we ordered the meat lovers. The pizza was delicious! The crust and sauce were excellent and being from Kenosha I'm a tough sell on a great pie! I'm hopeful that you will be able to staff this location full time soon and get the weekend football pizza etc. business!

‪Great local pizza spot. The decor is a bit dated, but the wait staff was friendly and attentive and the food was very good. The pizza crust isn’t too thick or thin (it’s just right) and they are quite generous with the toppings. We ordered an XL for 4 adults and barely finished half of it. All in all, great pizza at a very reasonable price. ‬

Very good pizza I’ve been eating it for years . Recommend the super colossal . That’s just a 14” in the picture

Great Ambiance, Great Service, Even better Food! The Mozzarella Sticks are to die for, and there Marinara Sauce is excellent..You can tell Fresh Mozzarella is used in EVERYTHING!! We will definitely be back soon.

I have not been here since college, that was a long time ago, I have some gray here now, and it was as good today as it was years ago, prices went up a bit, but that is a sign of the times. I highly recommend you try it if you have not already done so

Fantastic homemade square pizzas so people can get more pizza then from a round pie. Been in business since the 1950's and i have been ordering carryout pizza since 2001. Closed on Mondays but otherwise open the rest of the week. If you don't feel like driving to pick it up, their delivery people deliver it to you in their special trucks. During these COVID times, you call ahead, drive to their restaurant when the pizza is ready and they will bring it out to you while you are in the car. My whole family loves Marty's!!!

I love this pizza. Marty's has been my all time favorite since childhood. The sauce has great flavor, crust is cooked perfectly, and the toppings are fresh.

Amazing service fun waitress and delicious food!! So good!!

We have been getting carry out from Marty’s Brookfield location for years. Excellent pizza and excellent staff.

Fresh tasting veggies cooked to perfection. Delicious, flavorful tomato sauce. Perfect hot temperature from delivery

Great place amazing bartenders it's a feel at home type bar

Every pizza I’ve ever had from Marty’s was outstanding! Top 3 in the region for sure. It’s very hearty so a single pizza goes a long way. Glad they didn’t permanently close. Thanks