Caldwell Seafood Market & Cafe

My Wife and I came here for the first time to celebrate my Birthday. We will be returning to try more greatness from their menu. Everything was delicious. The service was spot on. The owner is great. Try this little gem of a seafood restaurant, you will not be disappointed. Thank you for a great meal and experience. See you guys soon.

Came here for the first time today with my mother. The New England Clam and The PEI Oysters and Mussels were as fresh as could be. Our server was Anthony who is also the owner and he was extremely nice and took great pride in his establishment! The place was extremely clean! Everything looked brand new but he's been there for 5 years! The kitchen staff in the back were very nice when we were leaving and I could tell Anthony takes good care of his employees! Definitely going back!

Ive been living in cedar grove for five years and so mad i just found out about this place. Soooooo good. U know a seafood place will be good when they also sell the fish. Clams were amazing, oysters were meaty and delicious and the service was awesome. Thanks for an amazing lunch and will be back again and again

Really good and well prepared seafood. A cozy local place that has a fresh menu. Me and my wife enjoy coming here when we can .

The place is small and casual. The server was lovely and personable. The food was fresh and very tasty. It was worth the trip. Highly recommended.

Great restaurant - delicious food and wonderful family atmosphere. You need to make a reservation or will be hard to get a table. We have been back many times and every dish we order is delicious. We took few friends with us and now they are bringing their friends. Once you come here for seafood you won't be going anywhere else. Highly recommend it.

Excellent as usual. Deep fried barata was yummy. The grilled seafood platter was a great price and the Cod siciliano was delicious.

Very good food. On par with PF Seafood market down the way. Very limited seating. Call ahead.

I got salmon grilled with a caesar salad and it was absolutely delicious, the best I’ve had in a long time! Highly recommend getting it here!

Love this place. Food is excellent!

Owner is so great and friendly. Amazing food and top quality service. PLEASE go here! You won't find better seafood anywhere else!

Great overall seafood experience, we order takeout here all the time. But dining in is so much better, the food and service is spectacular. Highly recommend.

A perfect neighborhood joint.
Freash fish,well executed.
Feels like home.

What an amazing meal! We had the raw oysters best I ever had in the east cost. The New England clam chowder was made to perfection! The seafood fry had the most delicious scallops. The best part was everything was caught locally .. if your looking for quality food amazing service and food made with love this is the spot ❤

First time here. Excellent service and everyone was so friendly. I had Branzino. Very fresh.

Great food (lobster salad is awesome). Great service.

Best seafood in NJ. Owner is amazing and the food is always high quality. Best shrimp and oysters I've had. Also amazing fish and chips too

We ate here purely on reviews and so glad we did. Our server was very friendly and accommodating. We were a family of 4 adults and 2 kids. We had the fried calamari (both with diablo sauce and balsamic ginger sauce- they were both good but really enjoyed the balsamic ginger combo), shrimp stuffed jalapeños and coconut shrimp. The food was so fresh and delicious. The shrimp were so large and tasty. The pasta homemade. For dinner we had a shrimp parm, red snapper with a jalapeño crabmeat salsa- reminded me somewhat of a ceviche, risotto with seafood including pieces of salmon, clams, shrimp, lobster and halibut fish and a Chilean sea bass. They offered dessert and coffee. The cheesecake was creamy. The coffee was perfect! The restaurant was clean, in the back is a market where you can purchase already made seafood salad or raw seafood.

Recommended by a family member, we decided to drop by. A nice and intimate atmosphere, clean and personable. I ordered the lobster ravioli, my other family ordered the grilled salmon, fish and chips. Can you say delicious and fast service!! A true hidden gem in Caldwell. Didn;t even have room for dessert....We will definitely return!!

Excellent! Owner was very attentive to everyone in his restaurant. Came out and spoke to us. Food was very good. Our waitress: Jane, was a Doll. Very attentive with a happy disposition. Would definitely go back here. Can't recommend this place enough.