Caraglio's Pizza

Order here weekly. Never have a problem with my order. I've never arrived when i was told to and had it not be ready. Can't speak for the other dishes, but the pizza and wings here are very good. Staff is friendly.

The service was incredible! They were super friendly, and even called me back after I forgot to pick up my wings!! I had the chicken bacon ranch pizza, and it was delicious! Strongly recommend!!

Stopped in for a quick lunch. The pizza was great and the service was fantastic!

We only order from here since the opening.. amazing staff amazing food, and have never had a single issue.

I do not normally leave reviews but after stopping after work at caraglios (the one in Ontario) I just had to. The Pizza and wings were great, and the service was wonderful the three ladies working tonight were extremely outgoing and welcoming. Great experience definitely coming back !

Don't know much about the atmosphere? The food I do get is really good!!! The first time I had their pizza. I fell in love with it!! A great sauce and dough. Not to skimpy on toppings either.

I have had their pizza in Webster and was unexpectedly given just one slice of their cheese pizza from their location in Ontario, NY the other day…… it was amazing.
Sometimes you get a chance to have a pizza that really reminds you of an Italian bakery style…. this is the place. The dough used in their pizzas has a taste I remember from my favorite bakery in Niagara Falls, NY many years ago.
I could eat pizza from here every day !!!
Thank you for giving me the chance to have delicious pizza again !!

This message is for Tony. Thank you for the two large pizzas we received on Tuesday night. It fed 3 different families as I believe in sharing the wealth! Had a horrible migraine that day so it was such a blessing. Thank you again.

We called in an obnoxiously large order right at lunch time this Sunday and were not disappointed. Working in the industry, I understand how difficult it is right now being understaffed and overworked so I was very apologetic while ordering. The guy working was there alone with his delivery driver and was still able to keep his composure and was extremely friendly while taking my order. Every single thing we ordered was hot and absolutely delicious! This guy didn't miss a beat. We were all thoroughly impressed, even my kids didn't complain 😅 Thank you for a great meal! We will be back for football season! I forgot to catch his name but it was the manager with glasses. What a Rockstar 😎

Actually comes as ordered! Not all mushy and wings cooked to order as well! Staff and drivers always friendly from the Ontario site. Keep up the good work!

Since they're new to the area, they were REALLY BUSY for a friday night 10/ 23. But, they all hustled and remained friendly and courteous. Bravo to the staff! I've heard good things about Cariglio's on the west side. 1st time having their pizza. We will definitely be ordering our pizza from them for now on. DELICIOUS!

Great pizza! Gotta pepperoni and cheese sheet pizza and added meatballs and onions to half the pizza. Used a code I got from from and saved 10% off. They also offer a plan for $12.99 a month and you get a slice of pizza a day.

Great Pizza! Responsive owners!

Moved to the area over 6 years ago from Buffalo and haven't found good pizza or wings until now!!! I will start making the hour round trip to get their pizza and wings.

Staff are very friendly. Pizza was perfect. Prices are very good. Would never order from anyone else again but here. Thanks for coming to Ontario's NY!!!

This place is new but amazing. They do not skimp on anything and cater to your request excellently! I believe they use real fresh mozzarella either that or magic for cheese lol. Give em try!

Awesome. Got a pulled pork pizza with the guys on Wed. Went back that Fri and bought a large one to bring home. Excellent hit at home!!

Just picked up dinner from here tonight the food was made perfect plates are awesome and the steak sub my wife got was made just the way she likes it your grill cook tonight really did a awesome job tonight and as always you guys have the best pizza in ontario thankfull for u all

Awesome doughy pizza! They have a $10 large pickup pizza on Mondays and Tuesdays. Cannot beat the price and taste!

We've ordered a few times since they opened! Never had a bad experience or a bad meal! They have great deals too!!