Pepino's

The food and the service were both excellent, but for party of 4, the table was a tad bit small.

I believe we have eaten in or gotten take out a combined 6 times since we moved to Menomonee Falls. The food has always been really good, solid pizza and great entrees. Service is good and the place has old school charm while being up beat and inviting. Glad to have this place as an option close to home.

The food is quite good here! The pizza was a bit heavy on the cheese but otherwise everything was delicious.
We waited a bit to see our waitress, and she didn't come to check on us very often (we ran out of drinks a couple times), but I think it's still worth going in. She was really nice and helpful when we did see her.

It has been over 30 years since I've had Pepino's pizza. Same great taste!

This restaurant was amazing! We tried pizza, meatballs subs, garlic bread and pasta. All of the food was great. Our waitress was quick, attentive and very friendly! The atmosphere was amazing with a family vibe, great music and decorations! Highly recommend.

I love this place! You really are family here and the staff and the regulars will make you feel right at home. The bar is a time capsule of Packers and other kitchen that just takes you back....what's not to like!!??

We had no problems with Pepino's. A party of five - fast service - friendly service - no one had a bad meal - Chicken Parmesan dinner was delicious. We will be back and recommend Pepino's for dinner.

The pizza is simply the best. They’ve been in business since the 70s and I’ve been enjoying it since then. Never disappointed, never had better.

This place is great. We periodically drive up from Lake county Illinois just to eat here. The Pizza is awesome. We went recently to have family style all you can eat fried cod. Comes w potato, bread basket, coleslaw. They also have a great full food menu and full bar for beers on tap, wines and spirits. So there's really something for everyone.

Very busy on a Friday night, so plan ahead, they do the best they can, it is as good as I remember last time I was there was 1996.

Garlic bread and pizza were both excellent. Waitress could have checked in a little more. Waited quite a while for soda refills.

Great authentic food, rich environment, friendly owners and staff. Definitely a must stop in the area.

It was my first time here, we orderd a MEAT LOVERS PIZZA it was really good and free refils on soda toped it off. I will rate this place 5 out of 5 stars the waitress was right on top of everything. The dining room was awesome from field stone walls to the open concept ceiling.

Great food. Exceptional service. I love that they have fresh mushrooms available for their pizza. (Make sure you request this if you prefer fresh mushrooms over canned). Great Old World decor. Fantastic experience! Very highly recommend. Looking forward to coming back often.

Great food I just love the pizza there can't wait to go back.

Had Sue as our Server, had her once before. She's awesome, fun & attentive!

Been coming here for Friday fish for years. Their Italian bread and tarter sauce are the best I have had anywhere. The mozzarella sticks are absolutely the best. Their pizza is super yummy too. Always great service with a smile. You won't be disappointed.

Family owned and operated; have always loved their pizzas both regular and gluten free, dining in or carry out. Friday we tried two fish fry options; regular cod and a baked cod with lemon butter Angelina sauce carry out. They both had options of French fries or baked potatoes with coleslaw and four slices of Italian bread. The regular fish fry looked a bit odd at first; fish wrapped and deep fried but fish was perfectly cooked and “breading” very light. The baked Angelina cod was a good lemon butter sauce but was swimming in it. Next time I’ll try just the lemon butter but will be back! Very reasonably priced and most affordable in the area and well packaged carry out.

Great food, great service awesome atmosphere.

Food was fantastic as always. Pepinos never lets us down.