Just Ice Cream and a bit more

What a charming place!
There were so many flavors that sounded amazing. The three flavors I tried were remarkably rich and creamy. This stuff is super premium ice cream. ♡♡♡

Staff were helpful, friendly, and quick! Well worth a drive.

We stopped as we drove through Brewster. Just Ice Cream is an adorable little shop on the main road through town. It was a gorgeous sunny day and we enjoyed our ice cream outside. It was SO good. I had one scoop of brownie something and another of peanut butter with pb cups. Loved it! My hub had a pb shake and it was phenomenal.
Definitely going back.

So many choices. The only thing they need to do is put the description of the ice cream flavors on their menu instead of just on the cases. It's hard to get in there to see what's in the ice cream before ordering because it's so busy in there, which is a good thing for them because that means they're making money. Maybe just put the description in a couple other areas at the end of the line. Friendly service always. Oh the peanut butter overload is the bomb diggity. 😉♥

My wife and I love taking our kids to get ice cream as a treat every few weeks. We had our standby ice cream shop clear over in Canal Fulton for several years (and we still think their ice cream is great!). Then a couple from our church recommended we try out Just Ice Cream and said they'd never had a bad flavor there. It's 20min closer than our other favorite shop, so we gave it a shot for the first time a month ago.

Man, what a treat. I couldn't get over just how intense all four flavors I got were, and my wife was thrilled that JIC offers multiple dairy-free options (other than just standard vanilla like the other shop) for her and my son who are both lactose-intolerant. We've been back once more since our first visit and have yet to try anything we wouldn't highly recommend to our friends. I've so far tried eight flavors from their large selection and plan to keep going back this summer until I've tried them all :).

That said, if you're into seriously gourmet-tasting, high-quality ice cream that beats anything you can get from a store, you can't go wrong with JICs!

Super cute little shop and open until 9 pm, which is really nice!!! I enjoyed "coal car" ice cream and the premium mint-something to go with it. Very tasty. Can't believe I haven't been here sooner!

Friendly staff too, which is always a bonus.

Absolutely a must while in Brewster! Great ice cream even better service! The girl with ice cream earrings made my day! Talk about service with a smile :) Best flippin milkshake I’ve ever had in my life! Can’t wait to come back and visit!!

Very good ice cream in the little town of Brewster. Small town ice cream shop with very good ice cream family all loved it.

Cute little shop. The girl who waited on us was sweet. Ice cream was amazing. Lots and lots of varieties!

Very good pineapple gluten free and dairy free ice cream with bananas and caramel sauce and pecans. Awesome milk shakes. Highly recommend this place.

Place is AMAZING!!! It's the best ice cream in a 5 county radius!! They don't charge enough for the quality and quantity they serve. Try the premium hard dip and experience a high butter fat ice cream that is brought in from Wisconsin! No kidding!! Visit it soon, you will not be sorry!

They have the best ice cream selection ever. Sugar free & dairy free options that actually taste good too! The owners are the sweetest (Mr & Mrs Connie as my son calls them. lol) and they have a cute shop next door too with some pretty unique items! Cannot recommend them enough.

The service and variety of flavors are beyond compare at Just Ice Cream. Lily was the server for my Dad and went above and beyond, her strawberry 🍓 sundae was excellent 👍.

This is a great little ice cream shop! They have sundaes, flurries, and probably 20 or more flavors of hand dipped ice cream as well as chocolate and vanilla soft serve. There is usually a line out the door when we go there because they have so many customers but it's worth the wait. Their servers are friendly. There is no indoor seating, but they have tables outside. Also they are only open seasonally, I'm not sure when they close down for winter or when they open again in the spring.

I would give them 6 stars. So good and so many choices it's hard to make up your mind. Outstanding Mom and Pop place. They have vegan and gluten free choices. It's a good thing I don't live here because I would probably gain weight.

1st time there. So many flavors to choose from. Definitely will go back !!

Had the pleasure of meeting the delightful owners yesterday as we visited to check out their ice cream while in Navarre staying at a very cool and modern tiny house. The Bourbon ice cream with the chocolate pieces was wonderful but I think the top choice had to be the Peanut Butter Overdose XL. Stop in and try a few scoops. We had to take a quart with us it was that good.

I love this place. It has an amazing variety of ice cream and different ways of surviving the ice cream such as milk shakes, ice cream sandwiches, banana splits, root beer floats, even smoothies, etc. You get a lot of ice cream with different kids of toppings, served in a cup or cone. The service is always good and I absolutely love the aesthetic of the store with colors. Just a minor detail I love, the color changing spoons.

Always proud to support local businesses like this one just right down the street from my car lot. And if you ever are in Brewster I highly recommend this establishment for a delicious scoop of ice cream. Especially the Pistachio Ice Cream <3 love that flavor. Excellent Service, Prices and overall the best ice cream place around!

I really appreciate the fact that they offer a gluten-free ice cream cone! The selection of ice creams is outstanding and the service is fantastic too. Always worth the drive.

Do you what a nice trip down memory lane? Then stop at Just Ice Cream In Brewster Ohio. All customers are greeted by super friendly staff. The decor is charming. But the homemade ice cream is the best!! Love the fun original names and creative ingredient combinations.I indulged with two different delicious scoopes ! First , coconut avalanche followed by muddy turtles. Enjoyed both very much!
My hubby had one of the many sugar free and fat free selections, fudge swirl.He was very impressed with the flavor and texture.No funny after taste.
We will definitely make the trip back.They serve shakes, sundaes,beautiful banana splits, and much more! Worth the trip!!