The Alumni Club Tavern & Eatery

We love the Alumni Club! During the summer (or warm days) they open the windows and there is a beautiful breeze. Not a large place, but worth the wait. Food is wonderful. Our favorites are the patty melt (my teenage daughter begs to go for this), pork totchos (amazing), pizzas, flatbreads, appetizers.

The staff is wonderful and so friendly. There is also a room downstairs available for private events. It reminds me of a basement Wisconsin bar in the most wonderful way. It's like hanging out with your friends, but you don't have to cook the food!

They recently hosted an after-show event for AOK. We had a gaggle of kids and adults decent on them at 10:30 at night. They were wonderful and the service was quick. Kids were able to eat and the adults has some much needed beverages! Our bartender/server Ally was the BEST.

My friend and I went for a quick lunch Saturday around 12:30. The server immediately told us food may take a longer than usual since she was the only one working. With that said, we received amazing service and the food came out quickly. Our server Christina was professional and very attentive despite being the only server. I highly recommend this restaurant.

Nice bar in "downtown" Menomonee Falls on Appleton Ave. Great bar food and a lot of drink options. I love that they open the front of the business and let in the fresh air. Extremely friendly server, immediately warned us that the kitchen was closing soon and and gave us a helpful countdown to ensure we got our food order in. Pictured is the patty melt.

Just moved to Menomonee Falls from Buffalo New York five days ago. I have been coming here to Menomonee F back-and-forth for the year and a half and have not found a place with buffalo chicken Wings like back home, I stopped in tonight and a very nice young lady, named Marie or Maria. I apologize I cannot remember, Excellent service ! I got a dozen of chicken wings hot to-go and they were spot on just like the wings back home. I will only go here now to get my fix of Buffalo NY wings. Thank You Alumni Club!

We went late on a Saturday night with a group of 20+ people! The staff was amazing. Shout out to Ally for taking great care of us!! The food was amazing as well!! Highly recommend the pizza!!!

Kristina was a great sever and very sweet! Salsa and chips was not great- salsa seemed old and chips were mainly broken little pieces. The onion rings were very good- crispy and great flavor.

It is a great casual eatery. They have a nice and extensive menu for food and beverages. Their servers and bartenders are also very upbeat and nice. It is very affordable, too!

This place was great
I got the cheese bread which is actually wisconsin pizza fries and they are great
Got a few Schlitzs and shot the bull with Bartender and played some fingers and pull tabs
Very friendly people and good food
Great place
If you are reading this review go there

Such a fun place like a little hidden gem in the Falls. The food and drinks were great and our server Christine as amazing and attentive, loved her!

Excellent food and service! Super clean and wait staff awesome!!

Friendly place with a few tables outside.
Finally ate here on Sunday morning. It was delicious and the price was reasonable. Had veggie Benedict and added a side of yummy sausage for 3 dollars.
The Bloodies were yummy as well.

Came in with my son on Friday for a fish fry, he is 4. It was busy but we sat at a small table and service was great. Same with food. We will be back! Excellent server!!!

We came with reservations for our large group and had a great experience. We all enjoyed our food from burgers to salads. We were provided with great service. The bar turned out very nice after all their hard work. We had the front overhead door open for our lunch.

Everything here is great, but Brian used to bartend on Tuesdays, and it hasn't been the same since his hours changed. Bring him back and you'll get a lot more customers on Tuesdays!

Excellent place. Bartenders were friendly and provided excellent service. Great atmosphere, nice place, clean bathroom (don't know about the ladies' bathrooms). Food was awesome and the price was right.

Excellent atmosphere from the first step inside. The aroma from the kitchen tickles your sense's.
Beverages are full flavored, food is very memorable, staff are professional, courteous and warm.
Amazing gathering place and always stop in when in town🤠

Had the best "bar" pizza ever!! Got the Meat lovers. The ham was 1/4 inch thick!! So was the pepperoni!! I don't care for thin crust, but this was really good!!

I had the *unforgettable* pleasure of stumbling into the Alumni Club Tavern and Eatery last week and lemme tell you, if Hogwarts taught bar food magic, this place would be the headmaster's office. First off, their $1 wings special? Unreal. I mean, where else can a dollar get you airborne? I half-expected to grow feathers and take flight after my fifth wing.

Now, let's chat about Ty. If there's a PhD in mixology, Ty's got it framed behind the bar. This guy flips bottles with the grace of a ballerina and the precision of a Swiss watch. Ordered a 'simple' gin and tonic? Expect Ty to present it with the flair of unveiling a long-lost work of art.

I asked Ty about the wings and he said, "We season them with magic dust and unicorn tears." Honestly, I believe him. And while you're there, let Ty recommend you a drink. It'll probably be named something like "Ty's Tantalizing Tonic" and will be an explosion of flavors you never even knew existed.

To sum up: If you've ever wanted to eat like a king on a pauper's budget, while watching a mixologist maestro at work, get thee to the Alumni Club Tavern and Eatery. Five stars, would get hypnotized by Ty's drink-mixing skills again.

The food was excellent, service was prompt & friendly and prices were very fair. We'll be back again!

1. Best wings in Southeast Wisconsin (probably 3rd best I've had anywhere).
2. Music has been weirdly loud each time we've been there. Turned it down when asked, so not a reason to not go there. But not sure why it's so loud to begin with.
3. Again the wings are awesome.