Upper Crust Pizzeria

The Sicilians are 🔥 FIRE🔥 ! So beautifully cooked and flavorful and delicious! Not to mention the service was outstanding and had a very genuine nice and awesome waitress. Very quirky unique restaurant. Def give it a try! Wish I lived closer

I rarely give out 5 stars but this place deserved it. First time being there, place was nice, clean, peaceful. The food was awesome. We ordered a Chicken sandwich/fries it's was done to perfection. Ordered a Gyro and it didn't disappoint was load with meat(plus). Also ordered a cheeseburger/fries and a Bacon cheeseburger/fries, both were steak burgers.
Wait staff was nice and friendly, before she took our order she let us know that is CASH/CHECK only and that there was an ATM as we walked in. There are signs also posted about it.

Update 2 days later went back and had a Sicilian pizza and a Hawaiian pizza and both were the best I've had in a very long time.

I highly recommend checking it out.

Excellent Pizza and happy that they deliver. The Sicilian pizza crust is thick and delicious. As close as you can get to NY pizza. We will definitely be ordering again

All I can say is that pizza Is really good and customer service is great, take cash because that's all they' take

Lots of different pizza selections. Incredible atmosphere. The service is good. The restaurant is cash only but the also have an ATM in the restaurant. Definitely would recommend. I'm out of state but stop by every now and then. I love their pizza !

We relocated to the area from chicago several months ago. I was craving a beef and good pizza. Things sorely lacking up in this area! Was recommended by a friend so we figured let’s give it a try.

The phone ordering was easy, lady was super nice and repeated my order back to me and also let me know they are cash and check only.

Delivery was fast and super friendly and what impressed me most was the food was HOT AND FRESH!

Everything we ordered was good. Legit Sicilian style pizza. Beef was great, well seasoned and bread was fresh baked. Mozzarella sticks were good, fries great!

Will definitely be ordering again. So glad I found a place here that has good pizza and solid Italian beef!!

Well done guys!

It has been a long time since I had a pizza that impressed me. When we got there we saw all these pics of thick crust pizzas and were excited. We ordered and didn't know we had to ask for the thick crust and got a thin crust pizza instead. Instant disappointment! Then we grabbed a piece and started eating. That disappointment quickly changed to omg this is so good. We instantly knew we had to come back for the thick crust because if the thin crust was this good, the thick crust would be epic. Upon our next visit a week later, we found out we were right. This place was instantly my new favorite pizza spot.

Great Chicago tavern styles or Sicilian pizzas, especially for Wisconsin. All of the food is amazing. Leaving hungry is very difficult. I've been going for literal decades. Great place for family parties.

This is a well-preserved and operated American pizza parlor. The Chicago style Sicilian was excellent, as was the service. Very friendly, clean, and run just like a restaurant that has enjoyed over 60 years of success. Kudos!

Great place cool decrations.
Service is great also.
We had a family dinner order 5 pizza all where done to perfection.

I very rarely give 5 stars but it was very well deserved. From the moment we walked in to the check we felt like family, treated like it and the food was the best, we have been living here 12 years and I have not had a gyro this good since

Very nice place to eat. Great service,good food

The pizza is awesome. Paisano style. Comfortable and friendly!

Sicilian pizza is the best pizza around here and my wife is absolutely obsessed with their cheese curds.

Awesome atmosphere great pizza and wonderful staff….. cash or personal check only there is a atm

1st off all Cash or check only!
Just love the building itself. Tons of items on the walls and ceilings. The sevice was spot on and the pizza was very good. It was a very comfortable dining experience with all and they do have schlitz beer!

The best pizza in Wisconsin, no dought , great atmosphere, friendly people ,best pizza I've ever eaten. A must try

Everything is great. Food, price, people etc. But, they dont take credit or debit cards😮‍💨

The folks running the place we're totally overwhelmed with a high school reunion in the joint and a sizable after-lunch crowd, but you wouldn't know it. Food was pumping out of the kitchen and the wonderful two folks running the front of the house were keeping everything moving. Really impressive. The food was delicious and hot and we had a great time. Would definitely stop again if we are in this neck of the woods.

I’ve been going here since I was a little girl when we’d vacation in Lake Geneva from Chicago. I was terrified by the sharks hanging from the walls! But now I get to bring my kid here to spot all the deer and memorabilia while we wait for our pizza. If it’s your first time, get their classic sausage Sicilian style pizza. And don’t forget to bring cash. They don’t accept credit cards.