Pie Guys' Pizza

Let all you do be done for Pizza! -Cheese 24/7!

"Forget everything you think you know about Winston-Salem pizza! My recent visit to Pie Guys completely redefined this city's white pie pizza for me. The moment I took a bite, it was like a flavor explosion in my mouth. The tomatoes were bursting with juice and the spinach was marinated so well into the cheese you might accidentally forget you hate spinach. The crust was perfectly crispy and airy, yet held everything together beautifully. The toppings were incredibly fresh and bursting with flavor. But it wasn't just the individual components; it was the way everything came together in perfect harmony like the Backstreet Boys in the 90's! It was an experience that transcended mere pizza; it was a culinary masterpiece in a little nook and cranny that makes you feel like your eating a forest.

If you're looking for a pizza that will change your perspective on this classic food, Pie Guys is a must-try! You won't be disappointed."

Also try the cinnamon knots and cheese sticks you can taste an authentic and organic taste that is not matched anywhere else in Winston-Salem!

I was visiting the area and was looking for a local pizza place. I am glad I stumbled on this small family owned shop. The pizza was cheesy and delicious. The garlic bread was the best I have had. The crust was thin in the middle and fluffy on the edge with a very well balanced sauce. There is also this honey cream dip that is for the crust and that is the cherry on top. Joseph was a great server from the beginning and made great recommendations. I am only in town a couple days but I will be back.

Absolutely excellent pizza! Really blew me away. Although I didn't go in... the service provided was amazing. The taste of the pizza was fantastic. Best sauces! The only thing was that it was extra thin. We like a good thin pizza, but it was a tad super thin. Still 5/5! No doubt!

let me just say , you know the pizza in "a goofy movie " when it's all cheesy and you wonder what that taste like... This this is the place to find out 😂 used slice for delivery and it was super easy

This pizza is banging!!!! The thin crust…. I have no idea what they do to the crust. But it is delish!!!! Make sure to get honey cream sauce for your crust!!!! It will definitely be one that we order on the regular!!! And the s’mores crunch pie just makes my hairs stand up!!!

I had NY style pizza in NYC and Chicago. This is by far the best NY pizza I had. The taste is superb and the crust just right and not floppy at all. As for the facility itself, it is a small quaint place with a homey feeling. The owner pays attention to its customers in person to guarantee the best customer experience. Like they described it in their “quest”, this will be our go to for Friday nights pizza.

First time to Pie Guys and we will be back! We went in to place a to-go order and the employee at the register was very helpful with our questions. The wait wasn't long at all, but we were offered complimentary drinks while we waited. When our pizzas and sub were ready, they were brought over to where we were sitting - we weren't just a number called to the register to pick up. Great customer service! And the honey cream sauce, which I was somewhat skeptical of, was delicious!

Ordered a dessert pizza to share with some of my fiancé's coworkers, and it was really good! The price wasn't bad either. The frappe I got for myself while waiting for the pizza to cook was a little more pricey than I was used to, but since it was an orange cream one I was willing to shell out a little bit more change. Great looking interior, and reminded me of an upscale loft apartment.

I got the chicken cheese steak. Food and service was great. Drink machine wasn't working. It's has a small dining area. I'd definitely come back

Great place to eat. Garlic knots are fantastic pizza is NY style

Ok this is a place I will def be back - so cute! Everyone was super helpful making suggestions and I love it. Really unique with honey cream sauce. I have never had anything like it before!
I had a half white pie and half margharita. It was ready to go quickly, while I was waiting for a prescription to be filled around the corner.
I will be back to enjoy this adorable hidden gem in person!
Lots of options with a big menu. Family ran, dine in option with tables on patio, inside, or to go, delivery options.
I noticed their dessert options at the last minute, perhaps next time.

Huge menu!

Great food, wonderful staff & owners! Have been here twice in the past week since it opened and will be going more!!! Plus I always try to support small family owned and operated business whenever I can! Definitely worth a try if you haven’t yet!

Never had anything but great service and food from this location! We did try a small cheeseburger pizza without pickles and got meatball subs for my family. All were delicious! Employees were very welcoming and friendly.

The pizza is very good, I love your cheese and the experience on site is comfortable I would come back with my family

this place has by far the best pizza! the pizza itself has a very different taste from any others of i have tried. the pizza always looks perfect every time we get take out. and the honey cream that it comes with for the crust is amazing!!

I have read reviews mentioning new ownership, well this was our first ever experience eating their food, no matter who owned it. When ordering delivery online, I noticed they had a long delivery time but I thought, man their food looks so good, I am willing to wait. So we waited and it was delivered right around the time approximated. It was delivered hot and smelled delicious. I open my box and the cheese to my cheese pizza had taken a wild ride (no worries I dragged it back in place with a fork). I thought to myself "man this pizza better be good". WELL IT WAS!!! ABSOLUTELY YUMMY!!!! We will be back!!! thanks Pie-Guys

1/8: Instead of refund opted to have my order delivered today. Pizza is delicious! Loaded with topings and definitely quality ingredients!
—
1/1: Thank you for the quick response to this review even though you are closed. I do see that it shows you are closed now, but appears you still showed as accepting deliveries/open when I did my Google search of "Pizza delivery near me" since your online delivery system was still available which is what caused the frustration. Hopefully upon reopening for the new year you can figure out how to turn that off when closed to prevent future incidents like this.
—
I placed an order online at 5:20pm today for delivery. It said it was accepted by the restaurant but at about 6:40 I called the restaurant for an update since it was past the estimated delivery time and discovered it was closed. So I've paid for something and there's not even a way for me to get a refund or cancel the order right now.

When I couldn't get ahold of the restaurant, I followed up with Toast as this was the service that facilitated the delivery/order and while they could not help me directly they told me that this was due to the restaurant not turning off their online delivery service while they were closed, which means this was very disappointing and frustrating situation was entirely avoidable.

I will update again when I'm less hangry on the outcome once I've had the chance to contact the restaurant about my refund.

Original review from 7/2021: Fantastic local pizza shop! It reminds me of my uncle’s pizza place in my hometown! Delicious, fresh, fast pizza and yummy dipping sauce. The originally owner was super friendly and takes the time to get to know his customers. This will definitely be a regular place for my family now!

Note from 6/2022: I have not yet been since the new management has taken over and cannot speak to the quality/experience under them.

My husband and I tried this place for the first time last night and it was delicious. The ingredients were fresh and the presentation looked exactly like the pictures online. We were very pleased and will be ordering again!

We just found this gem this week and will definitely be returning frequently! The service is outstanding with a friendly and personable staff. Everyone went out of their way to check on us. The food came out fast. I got wings and a salad, but my husband got pizza. We tasted both and it was all devoured. That is definitely my new favorite pizza. Nice atmosphere too, clean and modern aesthetics.