Fin's Eatery & Spirits

We visited here after being turned down by three other establishments in the area for having a party size that was "too big."

We were all seated upstairs, and the atmosphere of this place is fabulous! It was so warm and comforting, and the service was wonderful!

We ordered a few different dishes and a couple drinks, and we literally ate ALL of it because it was all just absolutely delicious! We will definitely be returning!

Update- came to watch some football and loved the Wedge Salad - and the chicken tenders were fabulous. Would definitely recommend as they were also recommended to me by a friend! Prices are very reasonable and we had plenty to eat.

On a nice day we started off with cocktails outside on the upper 2nd level deck to enjoy the view, shade, and cool lake breeze.

We then proceeded down to the first floor where my husband enjoyed a special of the day - Snapper Piccata which he found very filling with a very good size portion and good price. I loved the deep fried firm shrimp which was lightly battered and crispy and was steaming hot when it arrived at the table.

We always enjoy Fin’s fresh salads which comes with dinner - served in a chilled steel bowl! If you don’t like a lot of dressing (the blue cheese was awesome), then ask for it on the side as it comes “dressed.”

Beautiful intimate environment and nice new bar on the first floor with great chairs!

I’ve been coming here for years now and this year they’ve finally opens up their rooftop patio. The interior has a great atmosphere, but being able to sit outside is a real plus on a. I’ve day. The beer menu on the roof is shorter than the full bar, but that’s the only drawback. The food here is always on point whether you’re in for an appetizer or a full dinner. Drinks are well made and service is always great.
Last weekend I had a burger in the patio and we had a few cold ones. Wonderful way to spend an hour or so. BTW.. if you’re into baked Brie, check out their appetizer. Always warmed just right and the blend of honey, and garnish is perfect. Personally I think it’s a great dessert.

We held a baby shower there recently. EVERYONE was extremely helpful. The food was amazing. Salmon was extremely popular. I have two more kids and I plan on having any big events there. Having a variety of food choices (not buffet, served by waitresses) was a hit. There were choices, even for picky eaters. The wait staff was perfect. For food out fast and almost at the same time. We had 55 guests. They were not in your face but my water never became empty. Mimosa and sangria bar were a big hit. One of our new spots!

This place was wonderful from the time I stepped my foot inside (as soon as) I entered I went upstairs Bob asked my name and took care of us we waited only 5 minutes to be seated to the best area overlooking the water. My waitress Jess was wonderful knowledgeable and quick the food was undeniably fantastic! For the first time I may grow old with this restaurant/relationship ♥🌹

I really enjoy the food and atmosphere. The calamari is a great appetizer - good portion and yummy. I love the Main Street chicken dish while my husband always orders the ahi tuna salad. Both are super tasty!

Food was excellent and so was the beautiful view of downtown New Baltimore and the waterfront park.

Great dinner/seafood/atmosphere. Decent Pricing. Good Service. The food is really good! Nice walk to the water. Cool little spot in New Baltimore.

Fins is definitely in my top 3 places to go out to eat. We always get the calamari and French onion soup. Fish & chips, ribs, walleye, chicken or shrimp Alfredo and shrimp scampi are my favorites. With a caesar salad as a side. I love a summer night on the upper patio with the live entertainment.

My mom moved down the road a few years ago and we come HERE every time we are in town. Oysters Rockefeller is bomb!!! Love the wallleye. Great service, fun bar.

Really nice Restaurant right next to the lake. Food was amazing and very generous in portions. It was a little bit packed but we got a table quick enough. Definitely worth eating in here. Pastas were great and the fried Calamari as well!

Great experience!!!! Waitress Ahley was friendly and attentive. Calamari was just right, it was delicious. The shrimp appetizer was marinated perfectly. Salmon Cesar salad was great!

Omgggg!! I got fish and chips, it was huge and hot and delicious. Friendly service. Came here for my friend to play music. Nice cozy place. Definitely will be back!

I've been to Fins now 3 times. Each time I've been so incredibly happy with their food. From the apps to the entrees, I've never been disappointed. This was the first time I was able to sit upstairs and the view was great. The staff is professional and polite. The draft beer selection is good, but could be expanded a little. I've lived in New Baltimore my entire life. It's nice to have such a great place so close to home to be able to visit and grab an excellent meal!

Pleasant surprise! We ended up here on a Friday night when the first place had a long wait. Great food (would definitely recommend the Po' Boy Shrimp Sandwich) and the clam chowder was very unique and tasty. Very laid back, fun atmosphere. Definitely check this place out!

Only a few of the downtown restaurants are open on Mondays and this is one of them. Had lunch with a colleague and thoroughly enjoyed the Finwich. They remodeled the inside, and it is absolutely gorgeous.

It was a really nice day, but the waitress sat us inside when we obviously should have gone to the roof. I wasn't in the mood to argue, so I just sat there by the bathroom and kitchen and ate my food. 50 bucks for walleye, french dip, fries, french onion soup, and iced teas. 60 with tip.

As always, an exceptional experience all around! Can't wait to return and experience their new outdoor deck with entertainment.

Came for dinner the other night and sat outside since the weather was nice. Our server was very attentive to us even though we were outside. I ordered the fish sandwich and it was tasty. The food came quickly and we were able to be on our way.

Great food and service. Very comfortable vibe, especially in the summer when the patio is open with a view of downtown and the water.