HMC

The Prospect Tavern

American restaurant in Newark

Updated: March 29, 2024 01:24 AM

The Prospect Tavern is located in Newark (City in New Jersey), United States. It's address is 14 Prospect St, Madison, NJ 07940.

14 Prospect St, Madison, NJ 07940

QH4P+HG Madison, New Jersey

(973) 295-6255

www.theprospecttavern.com

theprospecttavern.com

Check Time Table for The Prospect Tavern


Monday12 PM to 12 AM
Tuesday12 PM to 12 AM
Wednesday12 PM to 12 AM
Thursday12 PM to 12 AM
Friday12 PM to 1 AM
Saturday12 PM to 1 AM
Sunday12 PM to 12 AM

Questions & Answers


Where is The Prospect Tavern?

The Prospect Tavern is located at: 14 Prospect St, Madison, NJ 07940.

What is the phone number of The Prospect Tavern?

You can try to calling this number: (973) 295-6255

What are the coordinates of The Prospect Tavern?

Coordinates: 40.7564888, -74.413681

The Prospect Tavern Reviews

J
2023-02-03 01:55:56 GMT

I've always passed this place when in the area, and I finally had some time to go inside and enjoy an early dinner with my wife. It's a nice pub inside, nothing fancy but it was comfortable and relaxing. We were there during off hours, so it wasn't crowded. I had the chicken cordon bleu, fried dumpling, and my wife had the salmon dish. Everything was top-notch, and we left happy knowing this place is an option.

Karan Sethi
2024-03-03 07:16:23 GMT

Fun environment and good service. The Cajun sandwich is a good try.

Jennifer Hapke
2024-03-24 21:13:08 GMT

I used to come to the Tavern almost every weekend! We had some great food there and even better party nights :)
Sadly i moved back to germany so i wont be able to go there as much as I used to :D

Davey Anthony
2019-03-17 22:17:57 GMT

Don't listen to the one star reviews. This place is very warm and great for conversing. It's not so loud like the other bars around the area. The food is amazing and happy hour prices are great and affordable (you are in a bar after all where drinks are always expensive, but it is very affordable during happy hour). The bartenders are great people and always attend you when you need them. The food is just great! The family are amazing people. No disrespect is tolerated in this location so if you are planning to get drunk and be reckless, well, good luck. It is a great place to eat outside. I have been on a few dates here and always have had a good time. This is a place where you never feel pressure to order right away as some other bars do to customers. This is a peaceful bar/restaurant with a family who deeply cares about their customers. Anthony is a great person who works very very hard, he is the head bartender and will always try his best to help (It can get very busy). Overall, great place for a date, by yourself, or just to hangout with friends. Great atmosphere. I completely 100% recommend it for anyone who wants to get a quick drink or bite, or even relax. Happy hour is 3-6 and prices are amazing. Take my word for it, give it a try. Food is great.

Barry Morgenstein
2021-09-30 18:36:27 GMT

Perfect atmosphere! Looks like a quaint, cool pub, but the food happens to be excellent also! A must if you are in Chatham or live in the area. Better than just bar food! Inside and outside is very cozy and appealing!

George Rapciewicz
2023-05-18 01:34:09 GMT

4 of us had dinner . The food was outstanding. Service was outstanding. Roast beef sandwiches, prime rib cheese steak , chicken wrap, and I had prime rib. The 4 of us were VERY Satisfied with our meals. You will not be disappointed! Great Food!

N A
2023-08-06 11:52:29 GMT

loooooove this place. was here last night n the bartender was on it! food was great. drinks awesome. and service was quick n friendly. will def be back.

Rick Smeding
2021-12-13 03:05:58 GMT

Enjoyed the food and the friendly staff and patrons. Had excellent food including excellent fried dumplings and a new York strip steak that was absolutely top shelf. The people with me also loved their food which included the prime rib which they absolutely loved. Will definitely be back here!

Elaine McDonnell
2022-05-02 20:02:31 GMT

Friendly. Clean. Shrimp tacos were delicious!!! Will definitely order them again next time. Reuben sandwich Fry's coleslaw everything was really really good. Looking forward to my next visit

Dave S
2021-07-25 21:08:43 GMT

Honestly the food is decent and the drink menu is okay, but the reason they get 5 stars is that service is excellent. Greeted us at the door, sat us down immediately, took our drink order immediately and all with a smile. The drinks and food came out fast. I would go back and recommend just for the service and I’m sure people will probably be into their food more than me.

Celeste Fondaco
2022-12-31 22:18:41 GMT

As a vegetarian I can’t tell you how much I enjoyed the Portobello Mushroom Sandwich. SO highly recommend. Also loved sitting by the fireplace after a day long hike. I’ll be back soon

Michael McGuirk
2019-02-19 02:59:02 GMT

This review is a long time coming. I have been to the Prospect Tavern quite a few times over the past number of years and lately the food and hospitality has been above and beyond. While it has always been a great neighborhood spot to go to, I just feel as if the food has really hit its stride!

The prime rib is EXCELLENT! Worth every penny and as good as you can get in any steak house. Tender, tasty, succulent and enough to take home and have leftovers the next day.

The fish and chips are as good as any you can get on this side of the Atlantic. The batter is crispy and not too oily and the cod is plump, juicy, and cooked just right the chips are fresh and made to order as well! Couple that with the malt vinegar and you have sitting on your plate a traditional taste of England!

The beers poured by the bartenders are cold, fresh, and in the case of the Guinness poured correctly. Speaking of beers, their happy hour is the best in the area - plus it is EVERY DAY!

Whatever they are doing here at Prospect, they are doing the right way!

If you have not been here or if it has been a while that you have shown your face in this neighborhood staple, it is time that you revisit this old friend. I know that I was!

Paul Chung
2022-12-11 18:51:42 GMT

Unique horseshoe shaped bar. Made for fun banter with other patrons. Several TVs mounted throughout for proper viewing from anywhere. Friendly and prompt service from bartenders.

Anthony Franciosa
2021-06-19 03:08:42 GMT

My fiancée and I ate and drank at the bar here tonight and it was awesome. The drinks were on point. They also had a little cool jukebox that you can play music off of. It had an app you can use so you didn't have to keep getting up. Food was awesome. We had the turkey brie wrap and the cajun chicken sandwich. We asked for that on a wrap as well and they were fine with it. Loved them both. Then by the time we were leaving around 9 9:30, a karaoke guy was setting up for Friday night, and the bar was getting into it. Really fun. Definitely recommend this place to others

Steph B
2013-08-27 20:24:58 GMT

Prospect Tavern is a great place for upscale food served at an affordable price. Last week I stopped in for happy hour and all the appetizers were half off. I was informed that happy hour prices were only available at the bar which was ok with me. I ordered steak and shrimp kebabs and the crab cake combo and they were both delicious. I asked if I could eat on the outdoor patio and the bartender kindly informed me that there was no table side service on the patio, but he would be more than happy to set me up and deliver my food. Overall great experience and I will return.

Beth
2019-01-30 17:11:54 GMT

I LOVE this place!! It is the locals favorite place to go for meals or brunch. The staff is attentive and the food is consistantly GREAT! It's a place where everyone gets to know each other and not pretentious amongst the crowd. Everyone has a good time with good food. THE BEST

Kelsey Hubsch
2021-07-20 14:15:58 GMT

Always amazing food and service! This is my go to spot for drinks and a meal with my husband. The spinach artichoke dip is to die for, and if you order a mojito in the summer they pick the mint fresh right in front of you!

Jonathan V.
2018-11-19 00:56:57 GMT

Amazing food, amazing people! A+++ service. So comforting makes you feel like your on a sitcom at the local bar. Also, they play the best music! Every time I’m there the music is so great it’s everything I love! Tav 4-life

Susan Schott
2022-03-06 02:57:41 GMT

Love the Mediterranean Salad, we add salmon. Lots of great choices. Nice atmosphere. Friendly servers. We go there a lot!

Todd Ovsiew
2021-02-04 13:00:04 GMT

One of my all time favorite places to go. The food is wonderful and it is a family run establishment and you feel like family when you walk in. Burgers are incredible and the food is always fresh. Service is wonderful as well.

Write a review of The Prospect Tavern


The Prospect Tavern Directions
About Newark
City in New Jersey

Newark is the most populous city in the U.S. state of New Jersey, the seat of Essex County, and a principal city of the New York metropolitan area. As of the 2020 census, the city's population was 311,549. source

Top Rated Addresses in Newark