Sal's Pizzeria of Cooperstown

Hi, it was second visit to Upstate New York for my and my friends. We we stopped
in Cooperstown for the first time for a quick bite to eat. We went to Sal's Pizzeria of Cooperstown. There were many visitors, it smelled delicious. We ordered several slices of pizza one bun with sausages. Sat down to eat on the veranda. All eas delicious!!!! I rarely praise pizzerias, but this one is really tasty. Some people are put off by the price, but trust me, thirs pizzas are worth it. Restrooms are clean.
I advise all my friends and acquaintances Sal's Pizzeria of Cooperstown. Thanks to its owners for their respect for people.

P.S. photos were taken in a hurry.

My experience was a quick dinner with a meatball & ricotta slice, accompanied by a local amber (beer). Both very enjoyable quality. Staffer kindly offered a taste test of the amber before I ordered it.

Quick, easy. Appropriate condiments and napkins on table. Order at counter; food brought to table. Clean (incl. the restroom). Simple booths with fun little baseball sayings and plaques on the wall.

$15 for a slice, a beer, and a tip. Good dinner for the cost.

Great food. The workers were friendly and the beer was delicious. Definitely stop by when your visiting.

Stopped in for a late lunch with my family after visiting the Hall for most of the day. The place was packed! Even so, the staff was holding their own, talkative and attentive. The pizza was great too! Often, at a new place we want to try out the basics to see how it holds up. So we did half a plain/half pepperoni pizza. I can proclaim it on par with better places to get a slice where we’re from in NJ, and the kids gave it “9 out of 10” on whatever scale they have for food (esp. when one eats like three things - pizza is his lifeblood). Totally worth grabbing a slice here if you’re in town for a visit!

Delicious NY pizza thats a short walk from the National Baseball Hall of Fame. You can buy a whole pie or choose from the large variety of pizza by the slice. They serve beer and an array of non-alcoholic beverages. There is currently indoor and outdoor seating available. The customer service was friendly and courteous.

Coming from Minnesota to check out b.ball hall of fame, I really wanted some real NY pizza.

My wife and daughter also was with me and all agreed authentic Sals NY pizza was damn good. Garlic knots you also to try out. The American lager was quality beer also made in Cooperstown.

Thanks for the memories!!!

Solid @ss pizza still. Very consistent and great service. Pizza has a great flavor and good crust.

Had good pizza enjoyed the atmosphere wasn't crazy expensive kids enjoyed eating there

Had a doctors appointment, stopped here after pizza and garlic knots were perfect. Great customer service

This is hands down the best pizza I’ve ever had. I’m 4 hours away from here, and I seriously would drive here just to get this pizza again.

Salsa is great. I have never been disappointed. The pizza Is always delicious. The atmosphere is simple, clean, and small just like an upstate pizza joint would be. Staff is friendly and patient. I brought a group of 12 students who ordered slices and it worked I out great everyone got what they wanted

Visiting the HOF, my wife and I were looking for a quick bite. I told her any place in NYS named Sals has a reputation to live up too and they did not disappoint. Shes from NYC so she can be picky but she put Sals in her top three places so that's good enough for me. I had the Sals special and was immediately impressed with the flavors and textures. It was a true New York experience and we will be going back on our next vacation since we love staying in the mountains

Came here yesterday with a big group before the Baseball Hall of Fame, and it was great! The outdoor seating is nice and shady with a hint of sunshine, the staff were very kind and friendly, and the pizza was delicious and filling. Pizza was a little greasy for my liking, yet the crust was nice and crisp and very delicious. I'm definitely coming back, it was worth the 4 hour trip from NYC!

The pizza was amazing! The staff is super friendly. Made the perfect evening to have a wonderful white pizza with spinach and tomato, a bottle of wine and a great view of the lake. You won’t be disappointed eating here. It quickly became our favorite :)

I love eating local when on trips to other parts of the country. My father and I stopped here for pizza after visiting the Baseball Hall of Fame. I enjoy trying new things and my dad sticks to what he knows, so we did a half Hawaiian for him and half lasagna (I think that is how it was described). It has meatball pieces and ricotta cheese. It was very delicious! I'd never had ricotta cheese on a pizza before this.

Delicious and affordable slices and garlic knots. Perfect after 4 hours at the HOF

Great little pizzeria on Main Street serving up a nice variety of slices. Prices are a bit high ($4.50 for one topping slices, $5.50 for specialty slices), though the slices are huge. Love the crust which is thick and doughy. I had a meatball ricotta slice which was delicious. Haven't tried the other pizza places in Cooperstown, but can't imagine them being better than Sal's.

Stopped in for a slice after visiting the hall. Got me a proper piece of pie that you can fold in half, just the way it's supposed to be! Delicioso!

While visiting the National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum, my grandson and I worked up an appetite. Of course, a 12 year old boy wants pizza! We were seated right away, with a smile. Our waitress, Minnie was the best. She was so polite and kind. My grandson got a slice of pepperoni pizza, which he loved, and two garlic knots. I should call them garlic rolls, as they were huge! He ate one, and saved one for a late night snack later. I had a turkey hoagie, with some special requests, and they accommodated me completely. When the bill arrived, I was shocked at how low it was. This was a pleasant dining experience for lunch, and if I am ever back in Cooperstown, I will eat there again!

If you love pizza you need to eat at Sal's. The crew are not the friendliest guys but they make a good pie.