Brooklyn Pizzeria

I go here just for the slice of pizza. It's so good. Perfect crust. When u can see grease dripping off and an awesome cheese pull, you know the pizza is good! Stop every chance I get. . .

Fast and friendly service in an old school, diner type of atmosphere. I loved the black and white checkered floor. The pizza was very good and very reasonably priced. The side salad was also great, with the house Italian dressing. The staff was helpful and really seemed to take their pizza-making craft seriously. Highly recommend!

This was the best slice of NYC pizza I’ve had since Joe’s pizza in NYC. Hands down its authentic style foldable slices. It’s all about the crust and the sauce. They do it just right! $11.90 for a slice the size of your face, a salad and drink. Can’t beat the price or the quality. What a gem in a small town.

The pizza is delicious, thin crispy just like NY pizza should be. We had pizza by the slice, calzone and garlic knots. The garlic knots are amazing with so much sauce and garlic. Will not disappoint. This is was our second time and we have loved it each time. Prices are very affordable.

I love Brooklyn Pizzeria. I've been going here for over 20 years! Carl, is the ABSOLUTE Best! The whole staff is really cool too. They always give me Garlic Powder in a little cup when I ask for it. Food is DELICIOUS!! Since I moved. I'll travel 30 mins just to get a slice or two.

This is honestly the best pizza I have ever had! You can't even get this quality if you went to Brooklyn, I swear!
If I were to sum up the whole excellent experience I'd say; Order a slice with just pepperoni and cheese. The slice is bigger than your face! Say hi to whoever's working. You'll get a friendly response.

Sit down with a cola and eat your Slice while it's piping hot. There's just the perfect amount of cheese, pepperoni and grease! 😋

Went here for lunch on a weekday. Got 2 slices of pizza and a drink for 7 dollars and something. The pizza was very good. Thin crust with just the right crispness. Will definitely come back here when I’m in Goldsboro.

Greeted by a young lady named McKinsey whom was very polite. Noteworthy is.. I walked out and came back in and the greeting was consistent. Food was takeout and excellent. Not many choices per slices but very tasty. Will visit again!

Easily the best pizza in town. They don't deliver themselves but Doordash is available.
The Garlic Knots are highly recommended with extra sauce.
Prices are very reasonable too...

Loving this place. This is the closest thing you will get to authentic up north pizza. The service is really good.

Prices - unbelievable! Great prices for people on a budget. Before you think of dominos come here to Brooklyn Pizza!!!

5 stars!!

Awesome food, great service, friendly atmosphere, clean environment, overall best pizza place around !

This place deserves to call themselves Brooklyn Pizzeria. I walked in and immediately did not feel like I was in Goldsboro. A guy with a New York accent took my order for some pepperoni slices and a drink. The slices they had were cheese or pepperoni. They hand you a cup to fill up at the soda dispenser and you sit down and wait for your order to be called. It’s a busy place and lunch time is kind of noisy(in a good way though). They yell out your order and you come pick it up. There is a counter top towards the back of the eating area that has Oregano, Parmesan cheese and crushed red pepper. Slices were great! Service was great!

Omg, the salad was awesome, without any dressing. Pizza is phenomenal. We had chicken & Pineapple. We got a Small, which is the size of other pizza place larges.
Great people, great service and very reasonable prices. 👍 we'll be back.

Best Pizza! During peak times you can wait up to an hour but for good reason, they are busy. They are busy because they are the best. Great prices and huge NY slices.

The pizza is always delicious and huge. The garlic sauce they use for the knots is a delicious compliment to the pies as well. The service is straightforward and pretty professional. I don’t dine in much, but the place is reasonably clean and the condiment shakers are usually full.

I love the place, but they need to be more scrutinizing in their hiring selections. Recently, a gentleman wearing a Brooklyn Pizza t-shirt was going up to mailboxes at random houses downtown in the middle of the night reaching inside them to take mail. It was caught on Ring by a neighbor of mine. Idk many folks that wear those t-shirts that don’t work for Brooklyn Pizza.

Great pizza, huge slices. Highly recommended this restaurant.

Great service, MILITARY DISCOUNT!, more pizza than regular pizza chains, amazing tasting crust and toppings. Way better than Upnorth!

Leave a tip, they deserve it. This place is fantastic. The food is great (try the manicotti or stuffed shells) but what makes this place the best are the people there. They're respectful and always make picking up food an enjoyable experience. I have yet to see someone working there take away from that positive experience. I highly recommend this place. Also, if you're short on time you can grab a quick slice of cheese or pepperoni which is almost always ready, yet still fresh.

Great pizza. I believe this plaze to be one of the best pizza places in Goldsboro

This place is amazing. To be honest I wasn’t so sure to eat there because the place is hiding a little.
Inside is surprisingly nice!
Everybody working there is very educate, kind and they always give you a free smile.
They are really nice and available to help offering you plates wares and box for unfinished pizzas.
Definitely pay a visit here because the pizza, beside everything else that’s already very good, is exquisite!!!
Icing on the cake is the price surprisingly low for the quality they offer!!!