Toadally Frogs LLC

Visited toadally frogs for the first time today and really enjoyed my visit. Lots of frogs which is why I went. Lots of feeders which I never have enough of.I plan on going back even though I live in Milwaukee Wisconsin which is an hour away. I bought two frogs today and hope to buy more. Keep up the good work. Thank you for a pleasant visit.

Bought three froglets of fine spot dendrobates leucomelas from here. Very knowledgeable and helpful staff, and I could tell they care a lot that their animals are going to a fully prepared keeper. Attached are photos of two of the froglets in their new bio active enclosure at my place.

Toadally Frogs is an excellent pet store beyond reptiles/amphibians. The owners and other ladies that work there are extremely knowledgeable and accommodating. I come here a couple times a week — whether it’s to buy feeders for my snakes or to just say hey. There is always something new to see! And Crikey the kookaburra is always good for a laugh or two. Overall it’s a great store and I love to be able to support local as well.

What a gem of a store! Nestled in between the dollar store and Asian harbor is the most well executed amphibian/reptile focused pet shop. But it was so much more than this. They also had a great selection of fish, spiders, some exotic birds, and other small animals. The staff are extremely knowledgeable and kind, guiding my uninformed journey into frog care. Coming from a fish background it helped me to determine what will be needed for future frog care.

Kris at Toadally Frogs was absolutely FANTASTIC! I came in as soon as they opened and I was immediately helped by Kris. She showed me around the entire store and I was just blown away by how clean everything was and how much inventory they had. I mentioned I was shopping for a couple of dart frogs, and I ended up leaving with 6! 😆 I own a reptile company myself, and let me just say that you guys are rocking it. Great job everybody!

Very nice staff. Animals seem so much happier than other pet places. A very unique and charming experience, great place for any reptile lover!

Best pet store around. I have gotten a few of my reptiles from the shop now. All their reptiles are very healthy and happy. The selection is amazing. The staff is very helpful, nice and quick to answer all your questions as best as they can!

Love coming to this place! Pet stores are always my jam, and this place always brightens up my day when I go. I don't know what people are saying about the smell, it's a pet store. Pets live here? It's hella clean for any pet store I've been to.

Regardless, I love hearing the frogs sing and being able to feed Crikey their kookaburra! The staff is always friendly and knowledgeable.

A must place to go for all your small pet needs. Such a wide variety of creatures that you have to see to believe. The employees there are very helpful. Definitely recommend.

10/10 love my internship here that is paid by the state. I have never enjoyed a job in internship more than this one and is helping me for one day I will be a zookeeper. When the job money is able to be paid more to be able to hire I will apply. If I could I would work all day here but the owner says there is a shortage in money to pay workers or something. I love talking to other animal lovers too while working and share and learn new facts. I will also be taking the new toucan stuffed animal home with me in February when I get my next disability check. Also ignore the two star reviews they are all very nice but sometimes you cannot be nice when you are busy and stressed. It’s not because they don’t want to work with you, it’s just because Chris / Khris / Christine is doing everything by herself and you can tell by spending time with her she is very caring, smart, and tries her very best. And it’s not their fault that they can’t hire but people they are allowed to volunteer because it’s free. But whenever they are able to open jobs I would like more experience with exotic animals because I want to be a zookeeper. I will be the first to apply I will scidaddle there like it’s Black Friday at a Walmart and there is flat screen TVs for half off. Also you can’t put leopard geckos with snakes and this is a really good place because they won’t let you put leopard gecko with their snakes.

Have a lot of information for you. Can all different pets there. I just got my new snake at the expo but they helped me with feeding!

It was great! The tanks and enclosures were imaculate, staff was incredibly helpful and friendly. Got to see different animals I'd never seen before, bought a beta as well. Great expert and 10/10 recommend.

i went here in june and i got my red eyed tree frog, he’s the most adorable thing. the customer service was great, everyone was friendly and made you feel welcome 10/10 would recommend

I called looking a specific lizard, the woman who answered was very polite and professional, upon going into the store it was very clean and interesting enough that although I knew exactly what I wanted I stayed and just looked around for probably a half hour. Very fair prices.
5/5

Google is asking me to update this review. My opinion hasn't changed. I've only been there once since my last review because it's an hour drive.
They've got cool animals, are personable/professional, are clean, etc. It was worth the trip.
I got a couple toads and adopted the sweetest 3 legged bearded dragon.

Dan was super helpful and friendly, helped us from choosing a pet to having a proper setup. Definitely will be back because of him

Wonderful selection of creatures. The staff was super helpful and kind. We love this store.

We bought an Amazon Milk Frog in January and loved our experience; I’m not sure why it’s taken so long to write a review! The staff was so helpful and guided us in choosing an animal we could properly care for. This was our first frog, and Tido is still doing very well! Based on other pet stores we’ve visited since then, I can tell Toadally Frogs really cares for the animals and provides high quality food and materials for them. The staff was very knowledgeable and made sure we had a really good idea on how to care for Tido before we left. They looked at pictures of our enclosure to make sure it was well suited for the type of frog we were getting. We did not feel pressured into buying anything or that we were being upsold in any way. I wish it wasn’t over an hour from us or we would drop in to buy the gut-loaded crickets often. We’re debating getting a second frog, and will definitely make the drive to Toadally Frogs if we do!
Edited to add: as we were there in January, it was obviously quite cold. The staff provided us with a styrofoam cooler/container that they receive shipments in to keep our frog protected from the cold since we had a short walk to our car and a long drive home.

Fantastic pet store, cannot recommend enough. Very knowledgeable owners, animals are well cared for

This store is great! They have tons of different animals, a great selection of products. Staff is friendly; including the cat! :)

I really like this store because they are knowledgeable about their animals and protect them. Their habitats are nice for the animals and most people working there know what the animals need. This store is great for reptile lovers and anyone who is interested in learning more about pets. I buy crickets from here for my leopard gecko on a regular basis. Prices can be fair