Rutherford Coffee Co.

Revamped their menu with Latin pastries and other items like smoothies and toasts!!! I have been coming here on weekdays for the last year or so- it’s always cozy and the lattes are amazing. They used to have a couple breakfast items such as almond pastries. Hadn’t been here in several months and came on Easter to find the place packed and with several new items!!! Lots of Latin pastries such as chincharrons with guava paste, sweet corn bread, cheese and guava pastries, ham and cheese croissants. Line moved slow but we got out food fast!!! The espresso machine was down but the coffee was SO GOOD. They also had new smoothies and avocado toasts, etc. Overall a lot of changes but still 10/10 experience!! Can’t wait to come back and try more.

I have a deep passion for coffee, and this place is truly a haven for coffee lovers like me. Not only do they serve incredibly delicious coffee, but their pan de bono and ham/cheese croissant always a delightful treat that satisfies my cravings perfectly. The variety of pastries they offer is impressive, and I've heard that they are planning to introduce even more delectable food options in the future. One of the things I appreciate the most about this place is the availability of free wifi, which allows me to comfortably work here. The service is exceptional, and both the new owner and her son are incredibly kind and welcoming, the place is always clean and the atmosphere is quiet. In the past, I used to frequent Starbucks for work and coffee, but now I prefer to support local businesses, and this place has quickly become one of my favorite spots to unwind and be productive.

Amazing Colombian cafe! The palito de queso con guayaba and Milo chocolate Frappuccino is amazing. The customer service is great and so welcoming. My family and I truly enjoy coming here. 10/10!!

Visited for the first time recently, but definitely not the last! Best hot chocolate I’ve had in a while, and the guava and cheese pastry is not to be missed. Staff was friendly and the atmosphere was pleasant for quiet conversation with a friend. A lot of people were working on their laptops when we got there and it seemed quiet and the music wasn’t distracting. Looking forward to returning and trying more things off the menu.

Rutherford Coffee Company is a gem. We are all lucky for having such a beautiful cafe, with wonderful people and outstanding service. Their coffee is tops, and as if it couldn’t get any better, they sell some of the best Colombian pastries that I’ve had here in the U.S. Their selection is a perfect compliment to the nearby cafes and bakeries. I highly recommend this beautiful coffee shop 👌🏻

The new ownership is awesome! Great coffee. Friendly and helpful staff. Hours are finally accurate. Even the art on the walls are better! 😍

Our favorite coffee place in the town. It got even better after the ownership changed recently. The new owners do really take care of the place and make you feel like at home. We think coffee quality is better than the others in the neighborhood, they offer more pastry options now compared to previous management and I will tell you this; try those cheese pastries. They are Colombian and delicious. I realize that more classical music was used to be played which we always loved that but now it is more pop music. Overall it is a great place to chill. Recommended.

Tried It yesterday for the first time and it was so good!!! I had a hot cocoa with a shot of espresso. The coca had a hint of cayenne and it was so good!!! The espresso was nice and strong kept me awake and alert for hours. The shop is clean and very cute and well decorated, inviting and comfortable

Delicious coffee. Purchased a bag of the GUJI. I do pour over and as soon as I saw the bloom, I knew these beans were fresh! Thank you to Brandon for his exceptional knowledge and customer service. Was also a pleasure chatting with the owner-Juan. I’ll definitely be back and highly recommend folks that appreciate great beans to try them.
Thanks again guys!

This little place is so cute with excellent coffee and baked goods. If I can make it here in the mornings it's my first coffee choice.

What a great place atmosphere service food 05 stars

Enjoyed a nice cup of coffee in a peaceful environment. Great place to read a book, bring your computer and taste a good coffee . I would definitely come back again !

Rutherford Coffee Co is hands down the best coffee shop in the area. The atmosphere is cozy and inviting, Their coffee is amazing and their baristas are true artists. Don't miss their pastries – they're divine! The staff is friendly and knowledgeable, making every visit a delightful experience. If you're a coffee lover, this place is a must-visit.

I got the Carmel cold brew and the cheese guava croissant. The croissant definitely tasted fresh. My cold brew was also delicious. Probably one of my favorites. I can't wait to come back for more delicious stuff.

Found this amazing coffee shop after teaching an enrichment program in a daycare in Rutherford. I loved that atmosphere and the vibes. The espresso was super amazing . We will be coming with our team to have a meeting here

This new local coffee house needs our support! I ordered a decaf vanilla latte. It was smooth ,full of flavor and the absolute correct temperature! The staff was amazing, friendly and very professional. It is a definite go back whenever I am in Rutherford....which is almost everyday! Let's keep the coffee flowing!!!!

I think this place has improved so much since the new owners took over. Bakery items are delish, coffee has improved tremendously too! Service is also outstanding.

Way better coffee than the previous owners. Gotta get there Colombian pantries. New fav coffee spot.

Visited this place during a recent vacation. Coffee was excellent and tasted just like what I've had in my travels through Italy, France and Spain. So smooth, and not bitter like unlike StarB... which i cant stand.

I love trying local cafes when I travel and staying away from the big chains. If I find myself in this area again this will definitely be my go to place.

Ohh and the staff were super friendly. Keep up the good work.

Great local place that I think is better than Starbucks. Great espresso drinks, cool atmosphere, free internet, comfortable seating, and outdoor seating. Parking on the street and at multiple municipal lots, including Kipp ave. Come stroll Park ave and enjoy a cup of coffee!