Fratello's Pizza Company

I have always gotten pizza from here as its always perfect and excellent.. today i got a sub, oh my goodness, above excellent. was a bit too big for me but was excellent. Im glad you guys are there and also that you deliver to my area! Great job!

Decided while visiting our son in Horseheads to have pizza. The customer service was amazing and the pizza was out of this world good!!!

Wings are still amazing!

We had gone down to Horseheads for our favorite Pudgies Pizza, but the parking lot was freshly paved and blocked off. It being just around 7pm, we were nervous that no other pizza places would be open much longer. My son suggested Fratello's, so we drove on over. What we experienced was THE BEST PIZZA we have ever had. (And we are big-time Pizza lover's.) The cheese was so delicious and plentiful, the sauce was perfect and that crust.... well, it knocked all our Sox off. Just the exact crispness to the bottom crust and the flavor at the end just made me sad that I was too full for another slice. Our server was very nice and efficient. We will always love Pudgies, but now we have another New Favorite to visit when we are in upstate NY. Highly Recommend Fratello's Pizza Company of Horseheads, NY.
A+++++

They are on my drive home from work. Every single time I get pizza for the family it's the exact same. Never misses a beat and is fairly quick.

My dad and I stopped in this week, he loved the pizza, my hot sub was top notch, and I was served the most perfectly pulled shot of espresso. If I only I could transplant the whole restaurant to Florida. We need some good pizza down south!

Or go-to place for pizza, wings, stuffed shells, some times subs, etc. That sauce they have, it makes all the difference. They are friendly, and accurate, they make sure your order is right before you leave if you're picking it up, which we always do. And if something is ever wrong, immediate fixing it with no arguments. They want to make you happy, and serve great food so it's easy. They deliver too, average delivery times for the area, possibly a little bit shorter.

Great tasting pizza..... whole family enjoyed
Very welcoming staff.....keep up the great work

Food is always great. They take pride in their work and it shows. Always our first choice for pizza.

Here with my husband Jay. We are very pleased tonight. The hot Italian Sausage peppers onions and mushrooms was excellent. This must visit place, it is off the beaten path so go find it!!¡ You will never go anywhere else. Thanks guys your service was excellent tonight. The fries were off but it could of been us. We didn't want a refund but you insisted. We will be back. Thank you.
Jay Ronda Rogers Breesport

The pizza is everything I have been searching for!! It truly is the perfect New York Style pizza that you can fold in half and have the pepperoni grease drip down your hand. Highly recommended and by far the best local pizza in the area! Thanks for satisfying all my cravings.

Tried the pasta this time, fettuccini Alfredo with chicken. Possibly the best Alfredo sauce I've had! Homemade from a real-deal Sicilian family recipe. Had some garlic knots with it, made for the best meal I've had all week I think. Love finding this much variety from a small pizza shop. If they had steaks I'd never need to go anywhere else!

Our office has ordered from you several times since you've opened and we love it! Pizza was good, wings were even better!!! Huge chicken wings! We order out a lot and you have never let us down!

When I found out Fratello's I thought it was any other pizza joint. Well they proved me wrong. There pizzas are the best. Especially the dough is like heaven. Let me tell you I'm lactose intolerance and I will yolo my stomach for this pizza. Seriously no regrets when I'm sitting in my throne for 30 minutes. They're specials are amazingly priced and wings are off the hook. So if you looking for a awesome pizza that will match Jerlando's Ristorante & Pizza Co, well this is the one!

Pizza may be their staple, and it is pretty good pizza, the real winners are the dinner dishes. Tasty ingredients, home cooked flavor, and the best Italian salad dressing in town. They're my go-to for Italian dining.

I can honestly say I have never been disappointed in the food here. The Alfredo sauce is incredible.

Pizza is absolutely delicious! Also, they have the best meatball subs I have ever had! I will definitely go back again and I highly recommend it to anyone else.

Really good place to get pizza, wings, salad. Perfect for delivery and pick up. Golden BBQ wings are awesome. Antipasto salad is fresh. Pizza is really good.

I lived in buffalo where the food is nearly impossible to beat. Fratellos barks with the big dogs when it comes to pizza pie. I love it and it's very filling with quality ingredients..like the pros

Was my first time there but it won't be the last.
This is authentic Italian Pizza. I would say it's the best in the area.
Give it a try.