Donny's Girl II Supper Club

We are avid “Supper Club” diners. We looked through our supper club book for some place new…. WOW our choice of Donny’s Girl II Supper Club was a FANTASTIC choice!
We arrived early Sunday to have a drink in the bar - we were greeted like family when we walked in (little did we know it was Fred, The Chef and Jen The Manager/Bartender!!

We had great conversation with Jen at the bar regarding the restaurant and its history along with travel and the area. She thoughtfully brought us to our table for dinner and introduced us to our server, Kim.

Again, had wonderful service and conversation with Kim. She was attentive, friendly and just all around a great server. After we raved about the fresh and wonderful salad bar, the amazing meal (I had the 16oz Prime Rib special and my husband had the Duck)

The food was so flavorful, hot and there was A LOT of it. Your dinner includes soup, salad bar, bread and your meal with veggie and a potato choice! It was more food than we could eat but happily brought home leftovers! My husband loved the pea soup so much he brought more home!

Kim let Chef Fred know how much we were enjoying our meal that he came out to say hello and we were able to tell him personally how much we enjoyed the food and service.

The ambiance is quaint and an “old school” Wisconsin bar/Supper Club - just how we like it!

We can will be back to enjoy another meal soon. We are thankful for the hard work, dedication and friendliness of this great establishment!

Janis John K

Donny's Girl II is a great little supper club in the Watertown area. The staff was more than welcoming as we entered to enjoy cocktails. The Old Fashioneds are muddled and quite generous. We enjoyed conversation at the bar until the rest of our party arrived. The food was very good! We enjoyed the stuffed salmon, breaded walleye, duck with cherry sauce, and prime rib. All the entrees were excellent! The salad bar was also a nice treat with delicious options. Service was attentive, and it was a great evening visiting and enjoying a great experience at Donny's Girl II!

This is a classic supper club and it doesn’t disappoint!! Salad bar is generously stocked & wait staff is friendly and efficient. Not fancy but great food. Also an excellent value

Updated Oct 2023 - new chef is fantastic. Wife got scallops, incredibly fresh, and I got walleye, amazingly light and tender. French onion and salad bar still the best compliment! Still miss seeing Jaci but a great place nonetheless.

OMG! What a Gem! We love eating here, the food is fantastic and you will never leave hungry. Excellent cocktails and the service is impeccable. If you’re looking for a great place to dine - this is it!

Later evening fish fry…, Great service from Jen. She attended to all of our service requests. It took longer to dine but offered extra services because of the additional requests just prior to us being served. Fred, the chef even introduced himself to our group. Greatly appreciated the special attention. Will be back,,,

2023- Tonight was our first visit since the new ownership, and it was absolutely fantastic. everything tasted amazing and fresh. We both had the cod fish dinner. I ordered the french onion soup, and he had the clam chowder. Both were very good. The fixings that they brought out before dinner (potato salad, cole slaw, baked beans, and bread) were also fresh and tasty. Our waitress, Maddy, was the best and gave very good service. The atmosphere made for a nice romantic date night. We will be back!

Friendly, family atmosphere with great variety and large portions. Salad bar with excellent pickled herring and hot spinach salad. Had the 1/2 roasted duck...excellent fare, all around!

Classic foods done right. Quality is superb price is very reasonable. Go in, have a drink, in the privacy of your party or ventuee out and make some new friends, before having dinner in a vintage setting.

I do a lot of travel with work and this is a place that I really miss being away. It's a local place you can walk into an "out of towner" and leave a "local yocal".

Give it a try, definitely worth the adventure.

The food and drinks were really great. The service was a bit slower than we would have liked it to be.

All of the adults at our table got the fish fry, and it was great. The other things (slaw, baked beans, and potato salad) were brought to our table after our food. That was a little disappointing but not a deal breaker.

I would recommend the establishment to others, and we will come back to visit again

We had Prime Rib and Beef Tenderloin. They were both great.

They hired a new chef 4 months ago, and he does a terrific job. Our entire meal was delicious. If you haven't gone here in the last few months, you should stop in for dinner sometime.

Prime Rib and Schaum Torte! Both excellent. Our waitress was great!

On 12/3/22 we celebrated my dad’s 90th birthday at Donny’s Girl II. We had a group of 25. We enjoyed delicious food and drinks! Stacey, was our only waitress! She never missed a beat! She even kept the four younger kids happy. I highly recommend Donny’s Girl II! They were very accommodating and we all had a fabulous time!!

Under new management it has drastically improved. Prices have gone up but it's worth it. Faster seating, faster food delivery, the wait staff is great. Always nice and friendly, and busting their butts to get work done. Tip them well, they deserve it.

Slam jam Home run Donnys girl hit it out of the park with all around great service and delicious food and really love the old school supper club feel a true Wisconsin tradition

Excellent food, great service, reasonable pricing. Also great old fashion. Had a chance to meet the owner, polite, friendly and you can see hard working. She's doing a great job.

Stopped after being in Watertown all day. We did not have reservations but they had room for us. Not only were the steak and salmon main dishes great, the choice of potatoes and soup and a great salad bar really topped off the Supper Club experience. Worth the beautiful country drive to enjoy a quality Wisconsin Supper Club.

Nice simple ol' style supper club with a great Friday fish fry and perfect old fashion's. The prices were very reasonable for the amount of food a person gets.

Great customer service. Food is delicious and very reasonable priced. Staff is very warm and welcoming.