Rahway Bagels

A friend wanted a really good sandwich and I said I can roll by Rahway Bagels. Although I've picked up orders for other people I had never had a sandwich. One bite from the Scrambled Egg and Turkey Bacon on a Croissant w/ Butter and Pepper and I was done. It is now my go-to morning sandwich when I have time to eat something. The staff is amazing. And yes, it can get crowded and crazy but definitely worth the wait.

Believe the hype!!! Best bagels around!

So this is a TO GO (pickup only) spot. There are no tables to sit and eat, but with the way the bagels are set up you won’t take long to finish it in your car 😂.

I highly recommend you taking a trip and giving them a try, I was in and out of the store in a matter of 10 minutes max. Will definitely be back soon!

They never disappoint! New owners are awesome and they know what they are doing. Every time I walk in the door I feel like I’m the first one there with there ecstatic greetings and sense of urgency to help me. They are very organized and I never have to wait too long. Their bagels are perfect too! The amount of cream cheese is perfect- not too much not too stingy. And the meat egg and cheese is exactly what you need to start your day. The many flavors offered for the bagels are so hard to choose from l, you might just order one of everything.

My favorite go-to order from here is their egg, bacon, avocado and cheese on everything bagel. They always seem to get the right quantity in the bagel without over spilling and the textures are always correct. The eggs are always fluffy, the avocado fresh and the bacon crispy. Just the way I like it. Highly recommend for a quick stop, take out when you are crunched for time!

Must try the food from the Rahway Begal if you’re Bagal lover. Delicious food with quick delivery and reasonable price. It had veg , ova veg and non veg options,I love it’s muffin and strawberry cheese bagel. Here you can select the Bagel type as well. Totally love this place. You can not dine there just pick up facilities are available.

The food is great and the staff is patient and courteous. I have never had an issue once at Rahway Bagel. Best bagels in Rahway.

Excellent staff--they are quick, efficient, and accurate with all the orders I have ever made here! Love the everything bagel with lox spread 🤤

Hands down, the best Bagel store in Rahway.

Quality food, Quick service, a lot of options, clean venue, friendly staff and good bagels!

These aw the best bagels I've ever had in my life. The atmosphere is welcoming and helpful. I love it!

Guess this place does not value customers who purchase at lunchtime. 24 minutes for two bagel toasted with butter. Really? 4 employees working, & 4 customers in the store. And no sense of urgency or appreciation of the people standing in front of them. When I said something because I was going to be late back to work, the lady just made and never apologized I go there every day. Very disappointing.

It was busy, but service was quick and I was out fast. Bagels are delicious, as good anywhere.

Moved to Rahway 2 years ago from Queens. The worst part has been the lack of decent bagels... Until this place! Rahway Bagels can legit go punch for punch with the best bagels anywhere in NYC. You’d be out of your head if you live nearby and get bagels anywhere else, honestly even if you’re not local it’s worth a trip out of the way.

Favorite is the french toast bagel, they are addicting.

By far Rahway Bagels have THE best bagels in town, they are my Go-To spot every morning before heading into work, I love the Turkey Bacon Egg & Cheese on an everything bagel with ketchup, all of their bagels are an excellent choice, you can tell the bagels are fresh and hand-rolled, the staff is quite respectful and kind!

This place is always packed, and for good reasons. Their bagels are amazing and the sandwiches they construct on said bagels are a work of art. Call ahead or walk in and order, you won't be disappointed.

Always served fresh daily. The store is clean. Good, well manned staff to handle the volume of business. It's best to call ahead to place your order! Prices are reasonable. Now that they've been open for a good while, the sandwich serve time is much faster! Great breakfast sandwiches! The best around town! They've recently updated their menu TV's and did some interior painting and upgrades.

If you’re looking for a hot egg & cheese bagel, this is the place. Delicious bagels, friendly & quick service.

Had to change my review today after having one of the best bagels I’ve had in my entire life. Got my order wrong last time but made up for it today with a masterpiece. Very delicious.

If the quality of the bagels alone aren't enough for you, this place is always clean, efficient, and friendly. But the Bagels are great too!

Great bagelspriced right, always fresh.
Fast service.
CROWEDED, that the sign of a good fresh bagel. Go in. Or order online or call the store to order.
Cashier does her job and very focused on customer service.
My visit was 2:30 pm on Sunday, place was busy, workers where moving along fast, cleaning, serving, restocking and in good spirit.
Will be back.

Very good bagels, sandwiches, and friendly service. Much better than prior owners!!!!!