Bagelicious

Fresh bagels made daily. Taylor ham egg and cheese on an everything bagel is one of our weekly go-to’s and it consistently does not disappoint. The place is family run and busy in the mornings on the weekends!

Super nice staff and AMAZING Bagels!!! Didn't make it out of the parking lot without eating my bagel, it smells so good and taste like today will be a good day!

The bagels are the best I've had in the area. Super fresh and perfect bagel texture. There's a large variety of flavored cream cheeses and they are delicious. Staff is super friendly. Great bagel place.

Love the bagels the best. Keith rocks it always has my order going the second I walk in.

Bagelicious has the best bagels ever! The variety and the different flavors of cream cheese gives you so many wonderful options to try and all are delicious! I always order a few dozen to take with me whenever I go to visit family and friends out of town. And seriously, they have the best coffee I have ever tasted.

Keith is amazing he gave fire and speedy service and clearly enjoys his job.

Best bagel store in the area! Customer service and food are unrivaled. Right when you walk in you are greeted with a warm smile and makes you feel like you are at home. The bagels are also cooked fresh everyday and they are always stocked up with the most interesting and delicious types of cream cheeses.

The place bagelicious is honestly one of the best bagels in Jersey (super delicious 😋). I ordered a poppy seed bagel cream cheese toasted, the staff made sure my exact order and offered me some free samples for the new oreo cream cheese which was so amazing. I highly recommend this place to anyone who loves bagels like me!

Huge bagels with tons of cream cheese. Very good value and delicious bagels.

I got a lovely taylor ham egg and cheese here. It literally took them less than a minute to prepare, but was really good! See? Here's a picture!

This place had wide variety of bagels that looked very appealing. I especially enjoyed their sun dried tomato bagels which the leftovers are for pizza bagels. By far one of the courteous shops I’ve been to.

Hands down my favorite bagels. The sandwiches are excellent, they use the right proportions and good bacon. I always go here when I'm in the area

Decided to venture away from our usual go-to place, as they never have what I want, and what a great decision it was!
Bagelicious is, well, DELICIOUS!!
I ordered some bagels, and yes, they have a variety, as well as an egg/sausage/cheese on a roll.
Delicious!
I was so happy that they had rolls for the sandwich...some places don't.
And the bagels were the perfect blend of crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. We got a few different types and they all were all some of the best I've had anywhere!

I liked this bagel so much for breakfast, I went back for lunch. This is my first trip to this area. I’m glad I found this gem!

Just stopped in for a quick bite while my boyfriend was in UPS! I am going to be coming back for sure! The owner (I believe he was the owner) was SO kind and sweet. He allowed me to try some cream cheese flavors he just made. The caramel was to die for(I’m a huge caramel girl). Also the chocolate chip was amazing! Gave me ideas of what bagels to put them on! He said the caramel cream cheese sells out quick! So I’ll make sure to come early in the morning to get one. The caramel iced coffee is one of the best I’ve ever had! The bagels also look huge! A great bang for your buck! I’ll be back!

One of the best bagel places in Rockaway. Always get your order right and the bagels are delicious and always fresh often right out of the oven warm. Staff is always friendly and service is quick. Quality of the food here is to notch. I highly recommend you add then to your favorites as you'll be back again and again!

Taylor ham, egg and cheese on a everything bagel - AMAZING! I dont know why, but these bagels are different- - delicious, not chewy and can bit right into them, they are perfect and taste AWESOME. Never heard of this place but my co-worker grabbed me a bagel sandwich from here and now I'll always go back.

This is a wonderful mom and pop style breakfast spot. They make you feel right at home when you order and the food is unbelievable. Everything from breakfast to lunch, I attempt to eat here once a week. The owners take great pride in their quality and service. They make a constant effort to speak with their customers to ensure satisfaction. The Coffee is ridiculously delicious. Try for yourself!

When I first moved to town (from somewhere else in NJ), I was looking for a really good spot for bagels and breakfast sandwiches, and this place definitely fits the bill. Their bagels are great and the breakfast sandwiches are amazing! They also have all different flavors of homemade cream cheese for the sandwiches - even really unique flavors; my husband and I have tried several of them and have been more than pleased every time so far. Moreover, the owners are really great, friendly, caring and courteous people who will go the extra mile to make their customers happy.

Prices are average and on-par with the standard market prices for the products that are sold. They take credit cards and don't bother you with annoying credit card minimums. Physically, the inside of the store could afford to have some updates and isn't very large, but they do have a few small tables for anyone that plans to eat inside the store. Personally, I prefer to take my orders to-go and eat them at home though...this is probably the only negative aspect I can think of when it comes to Bagelicious, but again, the inside of the store isn't much different than what you'd expect from any average bagel shop/bakery/sandwich shop/donut shop, so I don't really hold this against them.

I would wholeheartedly recommend Bagelicious to anyone -- and if you're looking for a good bagel or sandwich in the Rockaway area, you should definitely check it out!

Absolutely amazing ! The food is delicious and I completely adore Joe and Fafa. The sweetest couple you’ll cross. They treat you like family! The different bagel and cream cheese creations are pretty assume too. Will always come here !