Pancho and Lefty's

Haven't been in a Mexican restaurant like this since we lived in CA. The food and service was fantastic. Liked it so much we bought T-shirts. The only suggestion would be to refresh the Margherita offering on the menu. However, we learned they will make off the menu.

An amazing spot for absolutely incredible Tex Mex food. I had the Green Burrito last week and my mouth still waters just thinking about it!!! Great service, great value and even better food! 🌯🌵🇲🇽🇺🇸

Come to this place hungry and ready to eat! Their salsa is super fresh with fresh onions and chives. You have to order the Mexican pizza, it's covered in fresh veggies and the shell is nice and crispy!

If you love a good place to get Mexican food, come here!

Pancho & Lefty's is our neighborhood spot. We go here often and are never disappointed. The staff is always friendly and always hustle. The food is always on point and the owners have made some really lovely cosmetic improvements over the past few years that have not gone unnoticed by us frequent patrons.

Always delish! 👍

I just had the most authentic Mexican meal since leaving CA! Be prepared to loosen your belts and enjoy the party in your mouth. I know I did!

This was the best food yet for this homesick Texas boy. It's taken me six months of living in Ohio to find the cheese enchiladas at Pancho and Lefty's. Plus, the chips were fried onsite. We need authentic Mexican and Tex-Mex food in the mid-west. Some of the Texas foods I've tried in Ohio are just wack!

Can't say enough about this place. One of the top five favorite authentic Mexican restaurants I have ever visited. 🍻🥂🌮🌯🫘🍛🤤😋

Really enjoyed the food here. The chips were seasoned which I've never seen at a Mexican restaurant before. Food was good, menu wasn't ginormous and overbearing with options, and the price was good for the portion. The overall size of the building is kind of small, but it wasn't like the tables were too ontop of each other. Overall enjoyable experience.

My wife and I took a quick evening out invite to eat at Pancho and Lefty's. The food was really good, and the service by our waiter was excellent. We ended up sitting outside, which was a good choice for the evening, as it was pleasant outside, but the busy road was a bit noisy-- should have expected that. Ultimately I would go back. We enjoyed it!

Best Mexican food ever and also a great place to eat. Menu includes a good selection of classic American favorites. The service is wonderful with very pleasant staff. Prices are reasonable and the portions are large. A good value for the money.

I love this place! they have great lunch deals and very generous portions. The salads are so good.

First time coming here on my 21st birthday. Food was amazing and a great margarita for my first drink. Would recommend to anyone. Nice atmosphere and vibe and the service was great.

We were seating within ten minutes.
You get a basket of tortilla chips and salsa.
The restaurant is very family friendly, lots of people bring their little children there.
The food is pleasantly spiced, not hot.
The taco salad is huge, I had it with the seasoned ground beef, very good.
My husband had a a combo plate with rice refried beans and one chicken burrito and one beef, covered with melted cheese, which he really liked. They weren't too spicy for him.
They have a nice patio, also.

Great place. Free refills. Busy but still good service.

This is the best kept secret in town with “sabroso” margaritas and a “spicy” menú. Gracias René y Jennifer..

Our server was awesome and super helpful with the menu and a gluten allergy.

Awesomeness!!! The best Mexican restaurant in Stow. Been going here for 23+ years..

Passed by this place a million times and have never stopped in until tonight. Chips and salsa were excellent,even got some Togo. Queso Blanco is delicious. Had a cheese and a beef enchilada. Excellent. Margarita was good. Portions were great, and prices were good. Service was also excellent. I paid in cash, but seeing reviews, I see they charge for using a card. Guess what, you are paying for fast cash at an ATM that isn't your bank, and these businesses get ripped off with credit card fees for every single transaction. If you don't want to pay, use cash and chill out. It's a convenience you can use a card anywhere, the business shouldn't be penalized a bank fee for making it easy for you to use a card, especially a small place like this. Definitely will return, mad I've missed out for so long!

Always great eating here.
Tonight we had 12 in our party, and we were accommodated perfectly.
Food is always delicious, the service is always fantastic.

Best (American) Mexican food I've ever enjoyed! Start with the peach frozen margarita -- great taste, not at all bitter. Every Mexican restaurant brings you a basket of chips, but these were not just out of a bag -- thinker than most with grill marks on one side, light paprika on the other. My chimichanga was very good but my wife's grilled chicken burrito was wonderful and huge, plenty for a second meal for her. A great choice, with prompt seating and fine service!