Vincenza’s Pizzeria

Best New York style pizza in the area hands down. Very delicious and generous portion sizes. The inside of the restaurant has a very comfortable feeling to it, the staff are very friendly and helpful. As far as taste and quality are concerned, I would recommend Vincenza's above all other pizzerias. A special thank you to G for the best customer service, and to the owner Mary for going above and beyond to make Vincenza's the best pizzeria in this area!

An Absolute must try if you have never eaten here! Pizza is delicious with high quality ingredients, sandwiches are awesome including home made paninis, and if you have an event make sure you ask about their catering menu....some amazing dishes including ziti, lasagna and more. I eat there several times a week and this is just a fantastic mom and pop Pizzeria that takes ride in their food and service. Must try!!!!

Pizza was just average, mediocre at best for a ‘New York pie’. The cheese pizza and the surpreme had completely were totally different crusts. The cheese pizza cheese slid all the way off with one bite. The supreme was ok, toppings were decent. There’s better pizza, at a better price in the area.

Incredible pizza! Fresh ingredients. Pizza (carry out) stayed hot until it reached our dinner table. Garlic knots were absolutely the best we’ve ever had. Fresh marinara was awesome. Pasta salad was light and refreshing with wonderful olive oil. Caprese salad was soooo good. No complaints. All good things. We will order again!

Very tasty and nice service. Pizza, garlic rolls, and stromboli are too good. The salad was fresh. Tomato soup was decent.

How great do you expect a neighborhood pizzeria to be? Well... When it comes to Vincenza’s they are just awesome. The large pizzas should be called HUGE. Their dough and toppings are excellent and their customer service is fantastic. I am a repeat customer and I plan on keep coming back for more. Do yourself a favor and order the garlic knots. They are delicious

it was worth the wait. the pizza reminded me of my Puerto Rico. Already with the smell I knew that the pizza was going to be super tasty and it was true. super but super rich. I recommend her 100000% they earned a client.

My son recommended Vincenza's and ... WOW!

You have to try it.

We did not dine in. We ordered take out and they had it ready to go when we got there to pick up.

FYI... the large pizza is REAL LARGE! Worth the $$!

Best pizze I've had south of the Mason Dixon line!

This place is amazing! Their calzones are the perfect balance of crispy dough and creamy ricotta and cheese. Their Buffalo chicken pizza was the best I’ve had so far - they do breaded chicken which adds an amazing crunch which I’ve never seen before. I love how their marinara sauce is a proper chunky tomato sauce where you can tell it’s made from scratch - not a throwaway condiment. Dunking their garlic knots into that sauce is delicious. For dessert I got their tiramisu which was a perfect end to the meal! Favourite new pizza spot!

If you're looking for real NY pizza, then you need to visit Vincenza's Pizza. I feel it's the best pizza I have eaten in a long time. You will not be disappointed.

This is the second time I have ordered from here and it doesn’t disappoint. Even though it’s a little pricy as my custom small pie with five toppings and tip was 32$, it was delicious. The staff is super friendly and welcoming. If you use the “slice” app, be sure to give it a little extra time as both separate orders said my it was ready but it was about five minutes off. No biggie.

Pizza is phenomenal...I tried the meatball sub once and the meatballs were dry like they had been sitting for awhile so I don't think I would order that again, but the pizza? Magnificenzo

Really wasn’t expecting it to be so amazing looking from the outside, you wouldn’t think so. Amazing little spot. My fiancé and I both got the Philly cheesesteak’s and fries. Soooo good. Really unique. Can’t wait to come back and try the pizza next time.

New Yorker: This place has lights out NY pizza. It is not easy to find pizza this good. Moved here 2 weeks ago and have been here 4 times. Best pepperoni pizza I’ve ever had down here.

They showed me kindness and of course great pizza so do yourself a big ol favor and head down there when you get the chance ^__^

Its truly was a wonderful experience. I was recommended this by a friend who had stayed in Alpharetta recently. She said it reminded her of New York pizza so my boyfriend and I tried it. It was delicious. We were not expecting a pizza that big. Well worth it for sure. We also got lemon pepper wings as well but I don't have those pictured. The pricing is a little high but the portions make up for it for sure. Also, don't forget dessert. The cheesecake melted in my mouth and the tiramisu was out of this world. Will definitely come again in the future.

Zach really made an impression. He was professional and very respectful during the whole process. Our pizza was delicious.

Customer Service is amazing! I ordered a pizza for my family for takeout on the way we stopped and my car battery died! I called them they said we will deliver to you and I was customer service amazidified! Wow this is what I’m talking about! And when we got home look at how good our pizza looked! It’s the small things that counts! I was quoted 120 minutes for a boost it came in 15 min and so did my delicious pizza!!! What a great night thank you so much!!

This place has the best pizza in North Atlanta and the service is great. I stop in and grab a slice for lunch regularly and it’s always great

They are super busy which is a testament to how great the food is. They go above and beyond to accommodate dietary restrictions and it is now my new favorite pizza place.