Brothers Pizzeria

Visiting the area and Brothers was recommended by the hotel front desk. I've had a lot of pizza and I have to say this was AMAZING!!! I went back 3 time to make sure it wasn't a fluke. The crust, sauce, and toppings were perfect. My only regret is that I live in Seattle and will now spend my life in search of pizza that can match Brothers.

A simple pizzeria with an amazing pizza. We ordered their margarita 12” and I can tell you the crust was perfect. The sauce was just right and not overbearing. The cheese was delicious. If you are staying in the area feel free to grab some pizza from here.

Ordered my first pie from here based on a few reviews I saw on FB. I ordered the 18" Meat Lovers online and it was ready to pick up in about 15 min. Got home about ten min. later and it was still warm. The crust was one of the best things about it, it had that crispiness you only get from a properly cooked pizza in a pizza oven. The sauce was perfect and the toppings were just the right amount. I really liked the Italian sausage, most places use a crumbled sausage but theirs is a sliced kind with an awesome flavor, some of the best I have had. I can't wait to try a couple other pies such as the white pizza, will update when I do. From my brief meeting with the staff I get a strong sense that these folks care, really care about what they are doing. That needs to be rewarded.

My husband loves this place. We brought two pizzas and a salad home last night and everything was wonderful. But the reason I’m leaving the review is they go out of their way to remember my husband (he sticks out, 6’6) and converse with him and I think it’s incredible customer service to see him come out of your restaurant laughing and smiling after y’all’s interactions. Thank y’all for supper and for being great.

As someone who is from Jersey, it’s very hard to find good quality pizza but Brothers Pizza is the real deal and finally I’ve found a place with amazing NY style pizza!!!! And they’re open late through the weekend which is great when you’re craving late night pizza

Ordered pizza. 7 minutes later, great homemade style pizza. This place is the real deal. A must try in W.S.

The staff was very nice. It was a clean atmosphere and the pizza was delicious.

Great spot! About $3.50 a slice, and the slice is huge! Fantastic spot for lunch. The pizza had a nice crisp crunch which you just don't get at chains. The environment was nothing special but the kind staff and great food made up for it.

Very friendly people. Ordered 14" House Pizza and stuffed spinage and ricotta Pizza to go. Both were cooked perfect. Sauce cheese and topping were perfectly portioned. Hands down best Pizza since we moved here and we will continue to order here even though it is 25 minutes from our house. It is totally worth the drive. Thanks so much!

Best Authentic Italian Pazzaria in town. Great service and super cool owner.
The real deal👆🏼🙋🏻‍♂

Delicious find in downtown Winston-Salem! Just a quick walk from several hotels…and well worth the walk even with tropical storm conditions! Loved everything about my calzone— dough had a nice “chew” but not tough or too crunchy, great balance of cheese and toppings (I chose mushrooms, onions, and a pepper blend), and a fantastic side of marinara! This meal made me happy!

Husband & I stopped by tonight . We had cheese and a bacon pizza . They both were phenomenal ! 10/10 would recommend . Definitely our new go to spot

Man hands down one of the best pizza places in Winston-Salem, if you’re a pizza fan like I am, this is the place to come to, price wise and size, it’s worth every Penny

Sometimes, you don't have to get fancy in downtown. I will say, this is the closest you'll get to NY Pizza. The crust had the perfect crunch and didn't skimp out on the cheese

Look no further in Winston, I've had them all, this is it. Best slice in the area, best Sicilian in NC. The crust is so good, everything is so good. Regular cheese 8.2, Sicilian cheese 8.9, that's a review.

Super friendly customer service is only beaten by their pizza. Thin crispy bottom crust was very authentic. Will be back again for sure

Had the Sicilian chicken ala vodka and will be back to try more soon. Quick service, helpful staff, and great pizza!!

This is an honest pizzeria. Bare bones, no fancy atmosphere or frills. Paper plates and the pie is brought to the table in a to-go box. Personally I love that because when I want pizza I want that to be the establishment's primary product, not an afterthought.
The crust had a very good texture, but was a little too thick for my liking. There was a noticeable lack of grease which I didn't mind.
Slices are not available late at night which, once explained, made perfect sense.
I'll go back and see if the crust is more to my liking. I do recommend Brothers Pizzeria.

The brothers is always my go to place for some great quality pizzeria food!
From the fresh salads, to the steaming hot mozzarella sticks, and the largest chicken strips I’ve ever eaten… the food has yet to disappoint my family and I!!!
The employees of this establishment are always in good spirits especially the owner and the atmosphere is phenomenal!
I def will give this pizzeria five stars!!!!

The best pizza I have had! (Cheese Steak pizza pictured) Open very late. Super friendly staff. Clean!