Rusty Bucket Restaurant and Tavern

This place was the epitome of excellence.

I had the breaded buffalo chicken sandwich. It. Was. KILLER. I could not stop eating it, even when I was full.

There was not much of a wait at all, but that made it even better to top off the experience. I found the atmosphere to also be friendly. Dessert is a plus, with the strawberry cheesecake coming in clutch.

A wonderful experience here. Hidden gem, if you ask me. Great, great time. Will 10/10 return when I am in the Cincinnati area.

Mix reviews from my family and friends. 50/50 some loves it and other think it is the worse. We were here a bit after 1 PM, the place was not busy at all. My wife ordered the lunch trio and i ordered the Hoosier pork tenderloin. The pork tenderloin was a thick cut but surprisingly tender. The side salad for her trip could be a meal by itself. The turkey sandwich was shaved turkey but was hot and melted chesse. We really enjoy our foods. If there is a negative comment, the soup could be a bit hotter. Since it came be a bit nasty since there is cream in the tomato basil soup.

Sat down for dinner with my family of four and had a lovely meal. Our server was very tentative and friendly. Our food came out hot and was very delicious!!

They were great accommodating a large group of us. Although we waited an hour to eat, which is expected for a large group, the food was great once it arrived. Recommend the Blackened Salmon salad and chicken tenders with fries. Both delicious 😋. Service was great too as they tried to keep us happy with full drinks as we waited. This place had a side room which is great if you have a large group of friends to dine with.

Always a great experience at the Liberty location of Rusty Bucket! Best location! The service and food are consistently excellent, and on this visit our server Mara was terrific. This is probably Cincinnati heresy, but frankly I enjoy the 3 way chili here better than most anywhere else.

Best OG burger with sweet potatoe fries , with great service 😋 checked back on our table frequently to keep drinks full and make sure everything about food was alright. Felt welcome by all staff, for a wonderful dining experience.

We were just passing through town and found Rusty Bucket by Google search. I'm very glad we did. The atmosphere was great and the food was incredible! We ordered the Buffalo Chicken Sandwich and the Philly cheesesteak. We were so hungry and the food wa so good that I never even thought about pictures. But I promise they looked just as amazing as they tasted.

This place has amazing food, good waiters, and there is entertainment. This place is a great place to go to if your hungry.

Amazing fried pickles and a decent beer selection. The Philly cheese steak was mediocre. Great value though. Portions were good. We had great service from the host stand to server and other staff delivering our food.

Awesome !
Food is so good and well (big) portioned, could only eat half.
Staff is great ! Everyone is smiling and friendly. Hanna is the best, very ORIGINAL !!!

Wonderful place !

As a guy that loves a good burger, the Rusty Bucket has some delicious ones.

It's a nice restaurant, quiet during the afternoon around lunch time and a nice spot for a sandwich. Very affordable and tasty.

I recommend the Rusty Burger, which tastes much better than it sounds. I'll definitely be back here.

The salads are AMAZING the salmon was so tender seasoned just right 👍 I had a cocktail it was perfect great place to enjoy food and drinks

Our server was busy but very kind. The hostesses were nice. The food was great and the restaurant was clean.

The food, service and atmosphere were amazing. I can't wait to visit again.

Great place with really good service and atmosphere. Great for adults and kids. Food was great. Best fish and chips ever - from someone who hails from the land that invented fish and chips. 5000 miles away now but can’t wait to go back.

The food was great, same with service. The theming was great too!

Great place to grab a drink and something to eat Happy hour between 3 pm and 6 pm is the best time to go

We went late on a Saturday afternoon and were able to be seated immediately. We had a wonderful waitress who gave us great advice on selecting the special which was shrimp scampi and it was wonderful. My wife and I also got a burger to share and we're happy and full.

Mara was the BEST!!! Took care of all of our needs, punctual, attentive and a warm personality! 10 out of 10 would definitely recommend! I couldn’t post my food cause I ate it so fast. Food was delicious!

The food was good and I enjoyed my self