The Milk Pail

Very cute place. Great sandwiches for lunch. Good selection of ice cream and desserts. They also have fudge, meat sticks, and cheeses. Our BLT sandwich was great!!

Went in to get some food at 2:10. Unfortunately when we got there we were told they quit serving food at 2. If you’re wanting to come here for food make sure you show up between 11-2. We were disappointed but we still got some yummy ice cream.

The owner was so accommodating and the food was so good! I had the turkey club grilled sandwich and it was perfect. The ice cream was great too. Such a cute place!

This place was always a great place to visit when I was a young boy. Now I take my kids for an awesome treat.
The staff is amazing. Always kind and smiling. There's chalk outside for the kids to draw and color the sidewalk with. The lunch menu is fantastic and not to forgot, the best ice cream in town!

Great atmosphere and they even offer vegan ice cream.

Delightfully fun atmosphere. The owners are focused on quality and a great experience. We had grilled sandwiches, soup, lattes and ice cream. Everything was wonderful 👏

After dinner we got desert here. Boyfriend got a Turtle Sunday and I got a Dirt Sunday. Also bought caramels and a T-shirt. Always love Cedar Crest ice cream. Very cute shop. We shop local when ever we can and would recommend this place to anyone going to Rice Lake.

Excellent place to cool down with delicious ice cream. Kid friendly love there sidewalk drawings.

Amazing!! Their ice cream is FANTASTIC and very reasonably priced. We've gotten lunch here in the past and it was also very good. The staff is great and we love that we can pick up a couple of packs of Louie's meat and cheese at the same time.

Awesome ice cream 🍦 and very nice workers and good food

Always have to get a rootbeer float! So good!

If you like ice cream this is the place to go. Great assortment of ice cream treats. You can also have lunch or early dinner there. The young people who served us were Great

Awesome ice cream shop! You name it...malts, shakes, splits & sundaes! Variety of grilled cheese Sammy's and definitely gotta try the BIG DIPPER

Best customer service I've experienced in years... Took longer to get my salad but they were genuinely apologetic. Definitely coming back!

Massive cones. The triple scoop was far too big to eat, but was worth the price in giggles me and my son got out of it. The caramel collision ice cream is absolutely amazing.

Cute diner style eatery! All our food was great, hot, and had great service!

A great stop for your ice cream needs! Cookie monster is the best!!!

Sad it took so long, but we went to the Milk Pail for lunch today and 💥💥💥💥💥.
Amazing! Cant wait to get back. The Reuben wrap was awesome

Best coffee shake - out of this world flavor from 2 shots of espresso and the smooth creamy thickness of the shake was excellent. Hubs loves coffee flavored ice cream and he was blown away by this shake. Great place to pop in while in the area.

This was our first visit here and it was a good one. Really cute place with a clever name. My wife loved it because she is lactose intolerant and they not only had a couple dairy free choices, but one of them was chocolate!! You rarely find dairy free chocolate at an ice cream store.

Apparently they have soups and sandwiches at an earlier time in the day but we were there earlier evening. I noticed there were also some deli items, cheeses and cold meats for those interested.

Very nice shop, inside and out.