Kincaid’s Country Inn

Great place to stop and have a relaxing dinner. My husband fell I love with the chicken and ribs, my son had the chicken Alfredo and my daughter had a burger. My favorite was the spinach and artichoke dip! So flavorful! My husband won’t stop talking about the chicken and ribs. I overheard someone tell the server that they had the best prime rib they had ever had when we were there.

The restaurant is family friendly, and the owners are always present which makes you feel good about being there. I’d much rather patronize a locally owned business than a corporation.

Amazing food and atmosphere
Great prices

Had our Butternut Hills Christmas party tonight. 🥳 Awesome experience. 👌 Great salad bar, fantastic chicken and veggies. The cheese potatoes, "OUT OF THIS WORLD" Highly recommend.

Stopped in after a snowmobile ride! Prime rib is amazing! Service was excellent and food was delicious. Best prime rib I have had in a while! You can not go wrong eating here!

Great food and even better smells from the smoker outside as you arrive! They've got the prime and old fashioned's down!

My husband and I stayed two days in the area. Friday night we had the prime rib. We consider ourselves "meat snobs" and critical of taste and quality. Their prime rib was excellent so we decided to come back Saturday night for their Valentine's Day special. We had the crab legs and the sirloin/lobster dinners. We were extremely happy with those meals as well. Service was on point and the owners were enjoyable. We sat at the bar for a little bit after dinner and our drinks were always filled in a timely manner. We will definitely come back next time we are in the area.

We were passing through on the way home to Madison and stumbled upon this place, after looking on Google for a good supper club that serves Prime Rib (on a Friday). I would rate it 6 stars if I could! We are prime rib fanatics and very rarely are we 100% satisfied with flavor and tenderness! It is a very laid back and friendly environment. The service was great. The owner was sure to check in as well to ensure we were enjoying our meal.
We will certainly be back if we are ever in the area in the future!!

We have been going here for years, it's one of my favorite places to eat. Even though it has new owners, everything is still the same including the food. Like the owner said, "If it's not broken, don't fix it". How wise he was to not change a thing. The food is always amazing, especially the prime rib, and waitresses friendly and efficient. If you want to experience old time Wisconsin supper club this is the place.

We are in the area on vacation and love visiting super clubs and Kincais's did NOT disappoint 👏. We were a party of 8, service, food and drinks were on point. Highly recommend 👌.

All in all a very nice visit. Surprisingly the shrimp tacos were very good! We also had fish fry and a chicken sandwich too. Great service too. I wish they take down the old sign outside that tells the wrong hours. Google is up to date which helps. Not the Country Inn of old but that's ok. Good job guys!

We stopped in to Country Inn for the first time since ownership change. Everyone in our party had the cod dinner, it was very good. Although it was busy and a bit short staffed, our food came out quickly. Our server, McKenzie was friendly. We enjoyed our Friday fish fry and will be back.

This is one of the "Best" places in Wisconsin to eat, hands down! The food is unreal, all the people that work there are top notch. I had the "Full Monty" prime rib--it's the best prime rib I've ever had! Can't say enough, great food, great prices, and great people!!

Excellent choice for Fish fry or prime rib. Everything was on point. Wont go so far as to say any one thing was the best I ever had, but it was all very good and I couldn't find a thing to complain about at all. Will go back for sure.

Prim rib melt in your mouth, brandy old fashioned sweet just the right amount of everything.

The king prime rib is the best I had in a few years and I've had a lot of prime ribs. Somethings can use work on but no place is perfect. I went for good prime rib and that is absolutely what I have gotten 2 out of 2 times now and going back for more. Great job chef

The ribs were amazing and my husband LOVED the seafood platter. The staff was very helpful and service was fast. We will definitely be regulars now.

Best supper club around. Warm, cozy, classic supper club atmosphere, very friendly staff. Food is delicious. If you like wild rice, their wild rice side is to die for! And... Get the salad bar. You'll regret it if you don't. It's totally worth it. They have a lot of soups, anything you'd want on a salad, and rolls and butter up there. You're full before your food comes and can take home half your dinner for later!

Had the Friday night fish fry, actually baked fish. It was awesome, salad bar was great too with clam chowder and pasta salads. Waitress was great and we were served spiced cake out of the blue. Owner (Monty) came out of the kitchen and greated us all. Food was great, very affordable, very good service, awesome experience!

Always fun & good food. Great salad bar, but I miss the herring.

It's my favorite place to go. Every special occasion my husband knows he can't go wrong with a trip to the Country Inn. I just celebrated my birthday there last week as I have been doing every year for the past four years. Love the staff, the service, the great food, and the great prices. If you're looking for a down home super club, look no further. 🥇❤👍