Earl's New American

This restaurant, while casual was among the very finest I have ever eaten in regardless of price point or location. The service was cordial and efficient and the mushroom soup was a must try. Kudos!

Such a lovely place for dinner. Our group of 8 had a great time and the food was really good. The lobster dumplings and the crab bisque are out of this world good! The filet mignon dinner was a favorite with our group. Plenty of excellent cocktails and desserts.

My husband and I were on a getaway to the area and we stopped by Earls for dinner - and they did not disappoint. Every part of the meal was absolutely superb. The moment we walked in, the staff were there to greet us and treats us as if they’d known as for years. As if that wasn’t enough, the food was absolutely incredible ! They gave a variety of choices and everything was delicious. Definitely going back

Loved everything about it. Drinks were fantastic!. Food was stellar. We did make reservations the day before.

We always eat here when we go to Peddlers Village. Reservations are recommended, especially on the weekend. Drinks are always delicious, and they have seasonal options. The dumplings and burger are a must try. Great service, good atmosphere.

Hope the owner sees this... your man up front today was great, our waiter (Kevin?) Was a great server and our meal was delicious. Already telling NNJ friends about this spot. 10 of 10.

Had a great time here tonight- out to dinner with some friends. Had a great menu along with non-alcoholic drinks that were exciting to try! We got the fried tomatoes and burrata along with the lobster dumplings as appetizers. And for dinner i got the pork chop. everything was cooked very well and the portions were big, too. The inside has a cozy, homey feel to it and the i have no complaints about the service. Awesome restaurant in a beautiful area.

Excellent meal and service for a family of four. We shared the lobster dumplings as an appetizer. The teens enjoyed mocktails from the menu. My husband had an old fashioned and said it was perfect. The cheese burger and fries were delicious and cooked to my liking. My daughter had the crab cake and loved it. We never had to look for our waiter Dennis. He was always refilling our water or replacing our drinks without us even asking. We were lucky to grab a table without a reservation before the dinner rush thanks to Clint at the front desk. The restaurant was clean and I liked that the tables were not on top of each other- they were well spaced out. This will be our go to spot next time we visit and we will be sure to call ahead for a reservation! Thanks again Clint!

We went right before Valentine's Day. It was the first time eating here since the fire happened a few years ago. The original time we ate there it was a prix fixed menu, which wasn't that great, so our expectations were low. This time, however, the food was incredible, our server was wonderful, and the ambiance was perfect. It was such a nice date night, and we enjoyed ourselves greatly.

Delicious food and yummy drinks. Great atmosphere and amazing waitress, will definitely be back and highly recommend.

Fantastic! We picked Earl's to host our client appreciation event and it was an amazing night. From the exceptional service to the beautiful, inviting bar atmosphere, our team and our clients enjoyed a variety of delicious food and drinks. We had a blast and are very appreciative of the service, management and culinary team for making the night a great success. We look forward to getting back soon!

A truly wonderful place! The staff could not be kinder or more welcoming. I took my daughter and 5 of her friends out for lunch to celebrate her birthday and everyone was so kind. The food was great and we felt so welcome.

I highly recommend visiting Earl's. We were there for a large party and Jim and his staff, Destiny and Kristen, were professional and friendly. A wide variety of beverages were offered. The beer was $5 and wine was $10 each. The buffet of food was excellent. It was so good that all went back for seconds! The mac and cheese was creamy, the salmon was cooked perfectly and pork roast was moist. (The only thing was missing was parmesan cheese for pasta) Everything was perfect for the celebration and we will come back again. THANK YOU JIM FOR EVERYTHING!

My mother and I both frequent this place and love it. Everything from the ambiance to the beautifully prepared food, to the wonderful service, keeps us coming back. We were most recently served by the loveliest server named Amy and we highly recommend requesting her, she is fun, fabulous and makes excellent recommendations :)

Everything was amazing!! Service was really refreshing. Accommodating and gracious. Soup was delicious ..I had sweet potatoe jalapeno. Mom had crab bisque. Scallops mouthwatering and delicious. Mom had steak frites. We were both delightfully happy. Atmosphere was perfect. Warm, cozy, and personal. All the luxuries you cannot find together in a restaurant were together at Earl's. Highly recommend. Can't wait to do it again. Thanks Earls.

Absolutely 💯 Heaven. I have never had such fresh fare ever. The steaks were perfect and juicy. The callimari was so light and not chewy. I can't believe the taste and texture of the vanilla ice cream. Absolutely will be back. My daughter's hot dim sum donuts tasted like fresh zeppolis and were crispy and light.

Loved the atmosphere. There were 4 of us in our party. My wife loved the scallops. Three of us had Steak. The beef was not bad, though a bit overdone. Overall, I'd go back to Earl's.

Fabulous dining experience, from hostess, waitstaff, runner, and our meal. The restaurant may be a bit pricey for the "average Joe" but the experience is well worth the cost. I highly recommend Earl's for a special occasion.

Adorable staff. This lovely mature lady who seated us was fun, jovial and complimenting.
I'm going back just to meet the lady
Our server Keira was so sweet.
Food was good.
Calamari with English mustard seemed a weird combo though
Lobster bisque was coagulated.
Crab cake was really good but aoili was super salty
Burger was outstanding. So we're the fries
But I'd still go back 🙂

Loved the Pear tree drink! The salmon was very delicious! The pear bread pudding with maple and bacon sauce was amazing!