Fenicci's of Hershey

This place is absolutely fantastic on all counts. Picture this, Hershey, 10 pm, 4 hungry people, everything closed or closing, its raining and to top it off it's the BFF's birthday🙈 to say we were hungry and desperate is an understatement.

We missed our reservation elsewhere as we kept getting lost. But man when they say God works things out He truly does. This place was MUCH better than our original reservation.

From the moment we walked in, they were warm, friendly and attentive. Honestly it felt like going to glam grandma's house for dinner. The food was phenomenal!! Seriously, the birthday girl has never been a fan of Italian food, but Fenicci's converted her. We thoroughly enjoyed the food, the service and our waitress was amazing. The kitchen was very accommodating (by the time we placed our order, they had switched to the late night menu, but they graciously allowed our selections).

We all wish that we lived closer so that we could go back there for dinner ever so often. This is a must when in Hershey!!

I sat in the lounge and ordered a House Stramboli for a late night dinner. The service was friendly. The environment was very conversational with a mix of music and even some folks occasionally singing along. The dining room is a separate area and looks well-appointed. The House Stromboli was easily enough for 2 or 3 adults to share. The cheese in the Stromboli was perfectly melted and the bread was toasted just enough to give it a crisp outside with a soft inside. Scrumptious dinner!

This is a gem of a restaurant and bar. We had an absolute blast having dinner and drinks celebrating a special occasion. Our bartender Sarah was dynamite. She was on top of everything, she was such a pleasure to talk to and get to know, and she made our experience perfect from start to finish. We met the owner as well. He was very interested in the customers' experiences, and was an absolute pleasure for the short conversation we had with him. The arancini are phenomenal, but honestly we didn't have a single bad thing on the menu. And we ordered a lot! Obsessed with this place. We will be back during our next trip to Hershey! Thanks for making our night something to remember forever!

My family joined us to celebrate my Birthday. Great food! Service was on spot! Can't wait to come back to enjoy more of your menu. By the way.... make sure you get the dessert... you will thank me later. We got the cheesecake and carrot cake.

Great food and service. They are very busy. We sat at the bar to eat. The bar staff was fun, the lasagna and salad were fantastic.

Delicious dinner with wonderful service and comfortable atmosphere. Marvelous menu with lots of variety. Perfect cocktails too! Highly recommend!

A record-setting restaurant with a fun owner. Dine in the dining room for an upscale feel or hang out in the lounge with friends. They have options for both. Love the meatballs and the Italian dishes. Pizza is good too with a variety of special pies.

Fantastic food and service. Our waiter Brandon made the experience a very positive one. Even with table next to us that had numerous young children that were very loud and acting like a bunch of wild animals.

absolutely amazing food and service :) i was surprised they only had 4 stars! I give it 5 all the way around! we are from ohio and visited hershey for the 3rd time. we wanted to try this place and it did not disappoint!!

**the last photo taken was after we ate it, not before. great portions of food!

Had a good time here at the bar before a show at Hershey theater. We got a few apps and martinis. The bartender was very quick with service so we wouldn't miss our show.

Fantastic meal! Food was out of this world! If you love Italian, you won't be disappointed. Service is top-notch and quick! I would recommend reservations on a weekend. We were there on a Saturday without reservations and were lucky to get seated! It was packed!

Visited Fenicci’s with family from out of town and it’s my 2nd time eating at this restaurant. Once again, did not disappoint! I had the shrimp scampi and it was delicious! The lemon in the sauce was not overpowering. There was a lot of shrimp in it too! The restaurant’s atmosphere was very nice and inviting. Our waitress was friendly and professional, and constantly checked on us to make sure we had what we need. Will definitely come to eat here again and recommend others do as well for good food and company!

Our dining experience was very enjoyable. We started with the shrimp bruschetta which was very tasty. I had the wild mushroom risotto my wife had the Sicilian risotto. Both were excellent. Our guests had tortellini blush and the butcher block. They were both fantastic.
Our server was very efficient and friendly. If I remember correctly his name was Adam.

Street parking was free, we didn't have a hard time finding close parking. We had reservations-seated immediately. Waitress was very friendly and attentive. Food was really good. My bff had the Mediterranean Seafood which she said was delish. I had a special of the night and forget what it was called. It was shrimp with penne pasta in a lemon/basil/roasted tomato/evoo sauce. It was very oily, but really good.

Walked right in. Had one of the best servers Ive had in a long time. Hostess was extremely polite and welcoming. Atmosphere was homely and relaxing. Perfect date night restaurant after seeing a show. 10/10 on a strip with nothing but chains this place stands out

Christine was a wonderful server. She made our experience wonderful. The pizza is good, the wings are very good. It is a very chill and upscale establishment that really wants to provide a good experience rather than just fill all the seats.

Had fantastic service from my waiter, Cameron. The bartender was also very nice and came over to have a conversation with me. Very friendly atmosphere and good food. I had baked penne, which was tasty and had a very pleasing presentation. I recommend stopping for supper if you’re hungry for Italian food in Hershey.

First time here, we really liked it. The portions of a lot of what we ordered was huge! Prices were decent. Everything tasted great!

Our waitress was great, very personable and funny. Food had great flavor, though the chicken in my pasta was a bit dry. However, I'd 100% go there again. It was a busy night, a popular concert at the park, and they still got us in without a reservation. Next time I'm in Hershey, I'll be stopping in.

To start, our waitress was Chrissie- such a delight! She was absolutely helpful, personable & was very on it for our party of 18. All of the dishes tasted delicious... this place is the longest lasting in Hershey & it shows in the most positive way! Their spaghetti was just the right thickness and with the marinara sauce, it was just perfect. I decided to add on two meatballs- scrumptious. Their recipes are all original from 1935 and that makes a big impact on the uniqueness they have around here. The scenery is nice, very homey and light music that gives it a tight knit, warm feeling. For our first visit it was a good one. Also kid friendly. Would definitely recommend, and you can come with a big group and be handled properly! Loved it.