Mike's Pizzeria Italian Restaurant / Effort

I recently had the pleasure of dining at Mike’s Pizza. From the moment I walked in, the aroma of freshly baked crust and rich tomato sauce filled the air. The crust was perfectly crispy on the outside yet delightfully chewy inside, and the toppings were fresh and flavorful. From my 35 years of living this was the best pizza that I have ever had. The staff was friendly and very helpful which made the overall experience really enjoyable . I highly recommend trying their unique pizza creations – a true delight for any pizza lover! I don’t even know why this place has any 1-2 star reviews, I don’t know what Mike’s pizza they’ve been to, but this place is truly amazing.

This place is great the staff are friendly and the food is good and constant in flavor. They also have tables to sit in as well . My top favorite dish here is the Fettuccine Alfredo with grilled chicken and broccoli. Just add a dash of Parmesan cheese and black pepper and it's even more delicious

Recently moved to the area and we are trying ALL the restaurants! Their pizza was delicious! They made a good salad. Their Italian cold cuts were loaded!

the food is mad good idk what cheryl is talking bout😂 for someone who hates the place and claims that no one goes there she sure knows alot of details😭😭 sounds like shes just trying to make the pizzeria look bad. also being racist is not going to get people on ur side lmao💀

Great place to grab a slice, good price, good food. They have a huge menu also with many Italian dishes.

Best Grilled chicken salad I've had in a long time!!

I love this place.
The best chicken noodle soup and bread in the world!

Was in the Poconos with the boys on a golf trip, we landed on getting grub from Mikes, was a solid endeavor. Good take out is hit or miss in that area and Mikes didn't disappoint. The order was timely and correct...wings, cheese steaks, let's go.

I recently had the pleasure of trying Mike's Pizza and I have to say, it was fantastic! The crust was perfectly crispy and had a great flavor. The toppings were fresh and well-balanced, and the sauce was delicious. Overall, the pizza was cooked to perfection and had an excellent flavor. I would definitely recommend Mike's Pizza to anyone in search of a delicious pie. Whether you're a fan of classic combinations or more unique flavors, Mike's Pizza has something for everyone. Overall, I would give Mike's Pizza a solid 8 out of 10. Barstool grading like Dave.

Best food I have had in the Poconos, service was very good, food was awesome.

Moved to the area from about 25 minutes away. We had Mike's pizza randomly one night while we were moving. It's the best pizza I've had in the Poconos, a sweet sauce and good quality cheese that doesn't get super greasy. I would like it a little crispier, but that's personal preference. I'm very picky about what non-healthy foods I eat, and I make an exception for Mike's pizza every single time. I'm actually going to pick up a large pie with garlic knots right now haha. Ok bye.

All the yummy Italian stuff that you can imagine and enjoy 😉

Yeah! Of course I want something from Mike's pizzeria.
Great food good people. U won't be hungry afterwards, promise!
Mr. S

We love this place and its other location because it is always a great meal, even for takeout. The portions are generous and the staff is super friendly. Taste is way up there, too, so all my requirements are covered. I have never been let down with a chef special. There is something for everyone in our family of special food needs - pescatarian, vegitarian, carnivore, hates cheese, loves cheese, etc. The are very accomodating with questions and requests.

Great food. Large portions, never skimp on the chicken!!! Delish!!!

It was a Friday night and my husband and I had a rough work week. We decided to order out for dinner instead of making dinner ourselves. He was home already and called in an order for me to pick up on my way home. Got to Mike's around the time we were told it'd be ready by. The place was very busy and everyone working was hustling and bustling. Told the guy at the counter what I was picking and he acknowledged my name for the order took my payment and told me it'll be a little while longer all the while taking three more order on the phone. I was kinda impressed by that and told him no problem. I stood back and watched the very busy turn into ultra crazy busy. People were piling in, tickets were flying around, and the staff did an amazing job of dancing around one another to keep up with all the food orders. Secretly I thought, no way our order is going to be right or made properly because of how busy they were. After waiting longer than expected (which I'm not complaining about because I'm a people watcher and loved watching everyone doing their own thing) Anyway, got home set up the table with some wine and plates and divided up our meals. Everything was spot on delicious. We very much enjoyed our meal. There was only one negative thing with the entire experience; there was a paper wrapper in my husband's lobster ravioli. He was disappointed because he thought it was fresh ravioli and the paper surprise proved it wasn't fresh. But he ate it all minus the paper wrapper. Enjoy!

Delicious Food Every Time! Best Pizza in this Area 🍕The Stromboli's, the Pasta Dishes, the Zeppoles!!
Well known and respected by the community
Dining Room Open 🤗

Good traditional Italian food restaurant. Never disappoints.

Awesome food and awesome service! We drove in from NY for the weekend and were looking for something to eat. Coming from NY, I’ll admit we can be pizza snobs. Mike’s was great! The pizza was so good and we ordered a bunch of other food that was really good also. Our waitress was super nice and provided great service. For sure worth the stop if you live in the area or are passing through.

Best pizza and Garlic knots and besides that They even made me a Stromboli the way I asked Cheese steak with mayo and man was that so freaking good. Me and my family will not go anywhere but Mikes for Pizza or fast food they are the best.. there food is so fresh too. If you haven't had there food you must try it. ❤❤❤