Tinker & Smithy Game Store

Awesome little game store, with space for gaming and great selection! I sold some Magic cards here, Scott and the crew made the process painless and easy. I spent the returns right in the store, thanks a bunch! (Also Herby the dog is great)

The guy who ran the store was so nice and helpful. And he gave me a great price on 2 MTG cards.

Went here after a wedding, service was amazing and they had a lot of stuff categorized perfectly!

I love going to the game store due to the wide selection of games. An extra bonus is that the store owner is super chill.

Neat place where I buy Pokémon cards for my next new. Atmosphere is welcoming and they let you try games. They also sell Games workshop army units which is cool. Where else can you buy that in Addison county?

Great Place! The owner is an avid Magic the Gathering Player, and enjoys his copies of the card Prizefighter Construct, a common from Aether Revolt, so if you are a MTG player in the area and have extra copies of this card he will be happy to have them. If you do not play MTG, then there are plenty of great board games you can play for free there.

We were out-of-town board game aficionados passing through for a quaint weekend at a New England bed and breakfast. Wandering the shops on Main Street, we unexpectedly came across this hidden gem. The selection of board games was excellent and they also carried TCG and tabletop supplies. Importantly, they have open copies of well over 100 games available for play in store and rental. We tested a game before buying a copy as a gift for family. Clearly the games are well loved. It was a warm and welcoming environment with knowledgeable staff offering to help (we like to keep to ourselves and they respected that but made sure we understood their amenities. When we came in, someone was painting miniatures with what appeared to be an open common paint set, and a youth Magic the Gathering league started. We had great fun and in the unlikely event we ever find ourselves in Middlebury again we will make sure to stop by. Thanks for a nice afternoon!

Wonderful and knowledgeable staff, passionate owner, and wide variety of products. Always feel welcome and know I’m in good hands when I visit!

Love hanging out there. Everyone is welcoming and theres no judgement if youre new to a game. If youre looking to get into card or board games its the best place around. Theyve got a bit of everything and even host fun events.

They love games. They live games. They want you to live and love games. They have a wide assortment of games to buy or rent.
Rent an old favorite for a family game night or something different to do when visitors are in town. Talk with the staff. They love what they do and want to share their knowledge.

Small but excellent - an owner with a passion for the games and community he presides over. Smaller selection than stores in larger areas but he was quick to offer to order things they didn't immediately have.

A fantastic game store! Everyone is super friendly and welcoming. Makes me wish I lived closer so I could spend more time there.

Locally owned and operated. Great service by a family who really knows their games. Good atmosphere for those looking to find a gaming community.

The gentleman my son and I talked to had alot of very nice things and was very helpful and he is very nice. Definitely will be going back for more Magic the gathering cards.

Knowledge, helpful, and hilarious staff.

From boardgames to card games, Scott and Everett live and breath nerdiness.

If you're looking to get your game on, you must stop by!

Incredible place with a great community, a large variety of game to buy, or just play in the store it’s self. For some games there are events around the store at certain times.

Awesome gaming store...owner is very friendly and welcoming..was great to be able to talk childhood nostalgia...good selection and good prices!!

Scott it's great please check him and the folks out there. Feels good to walk in and see quality products especially when it comes to MTG.

A Middlebury gem. If you like playing any board games, or painting figures, definitely check it out. The staff is very friendly and knowledgeable.

Wonderful place. Tons of stuff to choose from and super nice people. Really recommend checking this place out!