Manhattan Pizzeria

Absolutely blown away! The staff were incredibly friendly and welcoming. Such an inviting atmosphere. The place was clean and spacious, making it a comfortable spot to enjoy a meal. What amazed me the most was the speed at which the food was prepared. We waited for a whole pizza pie less than 10 minutes. Staff speaks Spanish, adding an extra layer of inclusivity to the experience. My family and I will be back for more of their delicious pizza!

Whoa! After an epic quest for authentic NYC-style pizza, the search is officially over! Stepping into this joint was like teleporting back to the bustling streets of New York City. From the moment I walked in, the vibes were electric! The customer service? Top-notch! And the pizza? Oh, mama mia! It was like biting into a slice of Big Apple heaven! Crispy, thin crust loaded with flavor that took me straight to pizza paradise! And let's not forget the wings and garlic knots – pure deliciousness! This place isn't just a restaurant; it's a family legacy, and they're serving up memories with every slice. Do yourself a favor: ditch the delivery and experience the magic firsthand by dining in. I've officially crowned this gem my new pizza kingdom in Indiana! Don't miss out – grab a slice and prepare to be dazzled! I'm already planning my triumphant return!

This pizzeria is the epitome of NY Style Pizza. A crispy outer crust, and soft and chewy on the inside. This tasty crust held up very well to the toppings. Each pizza had the right amount of sauce, cheese, and toppings. The tomato dipping sauce was garlicky, and one can easily, at least I can, get addicted to it. We enjoyed the cheese, pepperoni, Buffalo chicken, Margherita, and white and Meat Lover rollover pizzas slices. Each was delicious, flavorful, and could easily be folded in half (as they do in NY). We also ordered and enjoyed the Pepperoni Roll and Garlic Breadsticks. I also had a nice conversation with the owner and found out he is from Long Island. He's perfected the craft of creating the perfect NY Style Thin Crust Pizza, and it shows. The inside looks exactly like the pizzeria I am used to visiting in NJ and NY. Manhattan Pizzeria is the best NY Style Pizzeria in Indianapolis.

An authentic and tasty version of NY style pizza and garlic knots. A crust that is thin enough crust to stand up to the toppings, and enough of a chew that it isn't a cracker texture. The garlic knots had a golden brown color and a good amount of garlic. It came with a cheesy nacho cheese and a garlic forward tomato dripping sauces. The Double Pepperoni Pizza was delicious. The pepperoni was meaty and was perfectly balanced with creamy melted cheese and garlic tomato sauce. The Margherita Pizza was divine. Fresh tomatoes on top of fresh, creamy bufala mozzarella, melted and stretchy mozzarella cheese, on top of a crispy and chewy crust.

The most crunchy pizza I’ve ever had. Very similar to NYC pizza slide.

Our family loves this pizza! The crust tastes and looks like NY pizza. The toppings and sauces are amazing ! Garlic knots are phenomenal too.

Being from New Jersey I've been longing for authentic, or close to authentic New Jersey, New York Pizza. Manhattan Pizzeria has fulfilled my void. Very down-to-earth atmosphere and never crowded.

You're greeted with politeness soon as you walk in. Slices start at $3, and pies start at $13 with toppings being .75 cents. WELL WORTH IT and you will NOT be disappointed!

I am a native of New York. Been in Indiana for about 28 years. I've had great difficulty finding really good pizza that reminded me at home. Manhattan Pizza is that place. Great and friendly service, and excellent food. The BBQ pizza was good but the classic cheese slice was the closest I've gotten to a hometown slice in all my time here. Their wings are tasty as well.

Excellent pizza, crispy crust on the bottom with great flavor of toppings. Service was fast and friendly and store looked clean and well lit. Garlic knots were good but I don't know that I would say they are can't miss, worth trying if you want a side. Would recommend this for your pizza craving.

My dad & I always come to Manhattan when we are in the area and they have never disappointed! Authentic NY Style Pizza slices that are large, not super greasy and full of flavor! They also have a large menu that offers Pizza, Pasta, Sides, Subs, Wings, Desserts & Soda/Water!

For a whole Pie/Pizza it cost around $19 or so dollars and for a slice it ranges anywhere between $3-4!

If you are ever in the area, come check it out!

#AccordingToArmon

Pizza made by master's of their craft. I've loved every slice of pizza and everything else I've tried since their opening. Authentic pizza by the slice and you are still able to add extra toppings. One of the few places that has all beef meatballs as a topping.

This pizza is so good we had to come back. Everyone is so nice. The food is affordable. We will be back again.
I think it's the best pizza by the slice in the city.

Ah, excellent slice! 7.3 definitely will be back again. Nice crisp, no flop, good crunch, cheese and sauce perfect. Breadsticks pretty good, has a garlic butter, not to heavy. Tons of options for slice and under 10.00

Amazing New York style pizza! The crust is absolutely perfect. While I haven't tried every flavor, the supreme is top shelf and their Margherita style is outstanding. Any chance I get for pizza, they're my first call.

This is the perfect pizza place in Indy. The service is great and the food is excellent too. It’s the perfect place for pizza lovers.

NY style pizza by the slice or whole pie. Great crust and flavor! Garlic knots where also good. Great great customer service and clean! Seems to be small family owned business with awesome pizza. What more could you ask for.

This pizza is worth stopping for every chance you get! Service was excellent, food was wonderful and extremely fairly priced, overall an awesome experience!

Moved here from Jersey, been looking for this type of thing crust east coast style pizza for months and this place made me feel nostalgic!

As New Yorkers we are so happy to find this place!!! It is truly the best pizza in Indiana! Place and environment is very nice and welcoming. My family and I love this place! Thank you!

Went to get a slice for lunch. For a slice of cheese pizza and 5 garlic knots it was $4.89. Not a bad price! The pizza was really good! I wish I had garlic sauce to pour into my knots but other than that I have no complaints. Everything was delicious and everyone working were really nice. I'll be back.

Best Italian pizza 🍕in Indiana. Try there Garlic knots as well it’s so good 🤪