Pots & Pans Pie Co.

Literally some of the best pies (sweet and savory) I’ve ever had! The Thai Chicken Curry is my new obsession. It’s so flavorful & spicy, but the flaky crust adds such a nice coziness. Don’t sleep on this place!

Our first venture to Pots & Pans will definitely not be our last. The Thai Chicken Curry Pot Pie was delicious. It tasted amazing. The red curry was fresh, fragrant and flavorful and the chicken, sweet potatoes and mushrooms were fresh and delicious. Married together with a flaky pie dough I could have never imagined this Thai Chicken Curry Pot Pie tasting this delicious. The aromas and flavors were captivating. Even the sweet pies are worth it. The fresh apples and cinnamon with the crumble coating on the Apple Crumble Pie was divine. The Butterscotch Pie was rich and divine, and the Black Bottom Frangipane Pie is a delight. The flaky crust enrobing a divine almond custard topped with a hint of chocolate at the base and topped with slivered almonds is truly a hit. I have always enjoyed almond paste, almonds and chocolate, but never thought I could see it as a pie and now I have. Yum and amazing.

The best pie shop in Indy! Get the Franken pie to try one of each slice.

Pots and Pans were wonderful to work with for our wedding this past weekend! They had exceptional dessert options that our guests loved! We had apple galletes, Carmel pumpkin pie, and dark chocolate cheesecake!

We bought three pies only to later read the ingredients and find lard being used. The wonderful lady we called informed us it was pork lard and that since we couldn’t eat it due to dietary reasons she would refund us the money for the two pies with lard.

Customer service was excellent and I’ll be coming back soon to get the Passionfruit Pie. It was hands down one of the most delicious pies I have ever had in my life!

Very friendly staff. Interior is clean and super cute. Love the variety in the menu between sweet and savory food options. Came in for the adult-size oatmeal cream pie cookie, came back the next day for a slice of the triple chocolate cake. So goood! Lovely experience. Will be coming back.

Also stopped by Pots and Pans Pie Co.
We got a slice of Sugar Crème Brûlée and asked the employee what we else we should order. She suggested the S’mores Pie due to it being seasonal. We loved the Sugar Crème slice and definitely could have eaten a whole pie. The S’mores pie, the chocolate middle was too hard, we weren’t a fan of it until we microwaved it for 15 seconds then it became our favorite! Great pastry shop and would recommend it.

Pots and Pans Pie Co. makes some stellar sweet and savory pies...as well as an awesome shortbread chocolate chip cookie. 5-stars because for rounding up - I'd say a 4.6 is fair.

This is my go to if I don't want to make a pie or don't have the time. It is not a big brand store bought pie - both in taste and in cost, but it's worth it. I recommend trying a slice first before committing to a full pie.

They rotate pie flavors once a month - keeping apple and creme brulee as standard pies throughout the year. Some flavors can be unique (miso) while others can be very straight forward (lemon). I haven't had a pie that's too sweet - a good thing since that's a pet peeve of mine. But sometimes you get pies that are missing their pucker/citric acid hit (key lime) or don't truly match up to the name (coconut lime - couldn't taste the lime) - it's not often that this happens.

Usually the dough/crust is good. I think their graham crusts are the best - right thickness, good texture, and always this touch of salt to balance things out. Their regular pie dough is flaky but it can sometimes be a little dense/thick at the back - you get less filling with these pies. But oddly, I've only noticed this issue with their dessert pies, not their savory pot pies.

Pot pies are amazing! I can't think of a bad one. Perfect for a no fuss meal if you're single or if you're feeding a family - everyone can get their own! I always noticed the minis take a bit longer to cook than what the packaging says - in my experience 60-75 min from frozen makes the center bubble.

Overall, a gem in the area - it's hard to find good pies. A few QC items to tighten up - challenge since they are all hand made. Can't wait to see what flavors they'll have next month.

A childhood favorite for my son growing up was my homemade chicken pot pie. He is now 30 and I bought his family one of the chicken pot pies. He texted me and said, "this pot pie is life changing." I have gotten the chicken pot pie as a meal when having out of town guests. We all agreed it is delicious!!

I’m a total foodie and this was easily the BEST pot pie I’ve ever had! I got the beef & mushroom PP and the maple pecan for dessert. When I tell you the crust on both is the best, too, man I mean it! I’ll definitely be back to try other varieties.

Be on the look out for these cute little boxes! I found this one in the circle this morning while at the adventure play stations. The pie is amazing, I’ve heard good reviews but haven’t been till I found this. I will definitely go back for more! Absolutely amazing and delicious, the people there are incredibly kind and polite. The space is well set up, I love being able to see into the bakery!

The first time I purchased 2 beef and mushroom pot pies and 2 oatmeal cream pies. Both were DELICIOUS!!!! After sharing the oatmeal cream pies with co-workers, I went to purchase 4 more. Customer service was great also. Definitely will return.

The apple cheese pastry as well as the choriqueso were fresh and delicious. The pb&j pie was alright, the peanut butter is more of an ice cream.

Delicious and easy to grab on my way home from work and bake when I get home. Dessert pies are amazing as well, but I don’t get those as often as I do the take and bakes! I have now had every flavor of their savory pies and I can’t choose a favorite!

I do so Love their crust on their pies, always light & flaky. I’ve had many of their pies fillings are always so delicious. Hands down Indy’s pie shop to visit .

This place is incredible, the crust on all their pies both sweet and savory is deliciously flaky. We tried five slices of sweet pies and three savory take and bake pot pies. The classic chicken and broccoli cheddar were my favorites. I can’t wait to go back and try their other flavors! The thanksgiving pie sounds incredible.

Crust was good on the Thanksgiving pie. Husband really liked it. The veggie green bean casserole hand pie was tasty. I love the chocolate chip shortbread. Good service. I appreciate that they mark the vegetarian options.

Have picked up several items from this shop in the past few years. Gotta say, every single time is a 10/10 experience. Every item we've tried has been absolutely delicious. Our favorite is the cheddar broccoli pot pie, it has become a cold weather staple in our house! We recently gave their mac n cheese a try, and that was surprisingly fantastic as well! Can't go wrong picking off the menu at this place - we will be lifelong customers!

Got the special quiche for Easter and it was amazing. The sausage gravy pie was also fantastic. We will definitely go back

One word: AMAZING. Best pies ever! The bakes are creative and delicious, the space small and cozy. Service is incredible and they keep me coming with their changing menu. The beef and mushroom pot pie is the best! And they have bake at home pies too!