Otter Creek Bakery & Deli

Otter Creek made the cake and cupcakes for our wedding and they were DELICIOUS!! Everything was absolutely incredible, we received so many compliments. They even handled the delivery and setup which was a huge huge help. We can't wait to go back and eat more cupcakes—highly recommend!!

The orange almond Croissant is the best Croissant I've ever eaten. I wish I would have gotten half a dozen of them. Absolutely delicious. It was definitely the best thing of several items I sampled there while on vacation.

Great bakery. Breakfast sandwiches are amazing. The maple cream cheese danish is sooo good. Friendly staff. Everything tastes amazing. Go and get delicious treats.

The women who helped me Dec 22nd about 2:30 were both great. The lady at the counter, and the lady in the kitchen. They were both helpful, friendly, and cheerful.

We had a casual daytime wedding at Button Bay State Park of about 85 people and hired Tatiana and the team at Otter Creek to cater the event. We had multiple different types of sandwiches, side salads, and desserts. Everything was really delicious. Tatiana delivered everything and helped set up. My only complaint is that communication was a little difficult, especially via email (phone seemed better) but they are busy and I think still trying to expand their catering business. I would hire them again and highly recommend them for your catering needs.

A go-to spot for pastries/cookies, great sandwiches, and desserts for special occasions. Haven’t ever gone wrong with a Norwegian sandwich or hummus pocket here. And they offer a variety of coffee/espresso drinks now too. Lots of outdoor seating options! Love Otter Creek Bakery ❤

This place is great. Delicious food. And they were exceptionally accommodating and honest about how my partner could avoid any trace of dairy from shared equipment (the slicer, which cuts meats and cheese) for his severe food allergy. And have great vegan and gluten free options. Such a gem for us to find.

Love the sandwiches (especially breakfast) and pastries. Always a good stop for a bite.

I normally don't bother with reviews but this place deserves only the best from their customers. This is hands-down the cutest, most delicious bakery I have ever been to in my entire life. The coffee was amazing, the pastries were flaky and tender and perfectly sweet (we shared the apple turnover, maple Danish, & Otter claw), and the people were ridiculously friendly. If you are ever in Middlebury (which is also adorable), please please please do yourself a favor and stop in here.

I’m not one to write reviews but as a vegetarian I rarely find good sandwiches and the Vermonter sandwich from this bakery is ABSOLUTELY something to write home about. Goat cheese with fresh veggies on delicious bread. The cookies, coffee, and hot chocolate were also fantastic as were the staff. 10/10 highly recommend. Can’t wait to go back someday soon!

One of the best dirty chai’s I have ever had came from here. The staff is super nice, the building is clean, AND it is wheelchair accessible. Love coming here to treat myself and my friends. Highly recommend.

The breakfast egg sandwiches are amazing! The bacon is good quality and the cheese is definitely from Vermont! The best breakfast sandwich I’ve ever had!

I have never been disappointed here. Their sandwiches are loaded with fresh, local ingredients. Their pastries and desserts are made with combined decades of experience, and it really shows. Their employees are always polite and professional, but still warm and friendly. It's really hard to overstate how great this place is.

Awesome place! The bread is great, and the sandwiches are huge. Cookies are good too! Also a really nice staff. I had zero complaints and a great experience. The actual bakery smells really good too!

We had two breakfasts at this wonderful place while we were visiting Middlebury. The first day we ordered an otter paw and an almond orange croissant. Both were absolutely delicious and very fresh! The second day we got a couple of breakfast paninis on rye bread. They were also delicious but huge! We split the first one and brought the other home to heat up for breakfast the next day! Highly recommend!!

Their breakfast panini is amazing. Personal add on: tomato and avo; it really is filled with delicious breakfast flavor!

Also, everything tastes better in Vermont

Super service, great coffee and the pièce de résistance the “Otter Paw”

These guys & gals know how to make a sandwich! Nothing is worse than ordering lettuce on your sandwich and getting one flimsy leaf. Here you get lettuce you can sink your teeth into. Nothing is worse than ordering crispy bacon on your sandwich, and getting flimsy, greasy junk. (These things happen for me more often than not at other sandwich places.) Here- crispy bacon that crunches - yes! And their bread and cookies are excellent. Best is their consistency: we've been here many times, and it's always this good. You otter try it!

Friendly staff. A lot of variety. I ordered the Greek pita and an iced cafe latte, they were both delicious. I brought the moose gingerbread cookies home to my kids and they were so excited and proceeded to eat them right up!

Got my first cake there. The best I have ever had. I will definitely be getting them here from now on. Buttercream just melts in your mouth.