Hometown Pizza - Crestwood

This is seriously the best pizza ever if you haven't tried it yet you are definitely missing out.
We always get carryout or just sit inside. There are plenty of tables and the service is always quick. I love that they have individual pizzas too. Very very good. So happy we tried it.

Staff is so personable, and the food was beautifully presented and very tasty. Clean bathrooms and wonderful patrons. Gluten-free options available.

We’ve been coming here for years and have never had bad pizza or service. We look forward to eating here whenever we’re in the area.

Fantastic!! I forgot how good Hometown Pizza tastes. Plus we had a great efficient server!

We ordered six personal pizzas, each with different items and a large cheese bread. Everyone was satisfied with their personal pizzas. This was one of the best pizzas I have ever had. They gave a good amount of toppings and the pizza was extra tasty. The cheese bread was also very good. Highly recommended!

Found the best thin crust... it's the cauliflower crust! Crispy and delicious. Made my own margarita crisp with the cauliflower crust, olive oil, Spinach, oregano, parmesan and mozzarella. Added chicken for a little more protein.

I'd have never tried the gluten-free crust, if it wasn't for our great waitress! Try it for a great crispy crust that doesn't get soggy.

This has a local spot feel. I get takeout from here. I think this location has new management, I think they are doing a great job, favorite pizza place for me.

Very wonderful Hometown Pizza location. The food was excellent and reasonably priced, the service was very good. The atmosphere was homey and warm. Definitely coming back.

I love this restaurant this is the second time I’ve posted something about hometown pizza
Went back for a second time and loved every bit as much as the first time
We got the bacon and jalapeño pizza
My wife got a personal pan pepperoni deep dish she loved

Started with a little drink confusion, but quickly became the same great family pizza place we have grown to love!

My partner and I ended up stumbling upon Hometown Pizza while out and about and we have not stopped recommending it since!
The service was amazing, we both really enjoyed our server, and the food was excellent; definitely feels like how a pizza place should and we will definitely be going back!
They also have gluten free options! The cauliflower crust was SO good

This is the only place to get good pizza! The Hometown Special is the best. We'll worth the drive for me. Some of the best pizza I've ever had, and it's consistent from visit to visit...but only this one. I'd never go to any other.

Our waitress was outstanding. Pizza was very good too. I did get a single serve pizza, I wasn't hungry after lunch. Price was good. I will eat there again.

Hometown Pizza in Crestwood used to be just mediocre with their service and food. I live in Crestwood, and the carry out and food quality had gotten so bad that my husband and I started ordering from the LaGrange Hometown Pizza because their pizzas tasted better. Within the past few months, I have seen a big improvement in the food and service. Our server, Tiffany, was excellent every time we dined in. We were pleasantly surprised about the improvement of service and food quality. I hope the carry out orders we place will reflect the vast improvement of our overall experience. The addition of Tiffany as a server is an excellent move in the right direction. My husband and I were also impressed with how friendly the new staff members are. We have noticed an increase in the number of people dining in and getting carry out. Tiffany gets 5 stars ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐.

My family and I went to homewtown a week ago and had a fabulous experience! Our server Tiffany was wonderful at her job. She was friendly, professional and always made sure that we were taken care of (even when the house was full) Best service we have had in quite some time! Definitely will be back to the Crestwood location!

The pizza is always hot and fresh. I love this place.

It's always an amazing place for great pizza and related items. The only down side is a lack of deserts in comparison to other pizza chains. The biggest positives is that it's more of a local family style that remembers customers, but also welcomes new customers with some amazing smiles, food and atmosphere. You will not regret your meal here.

Always a great experience with genuine employees and wonderful food!!

Stopped in for a quick lunch. The pizza was perfect with the right amount of sauce. The server was on top of everything!!

Food is good. My family likes it. I like it. It doesn't get as busy as the one in Lagrange, which is nice.

I give the food 4/5 stars.

The small pizza I ordered for my nieces didn't come out at the same time as the other food did, but I'd also like to add that they did remove the charge for that pizza and informed us of the delay then apologized, and did so without us even making a complaint or asking for the charge to be removed. Thats 5/5 star customer service right there, and at this point in the food industry, I'd take better customer service over better food.

Worth returning to.