Hometown Pizza - Middletown

The Employee, ms. Alex is the best worker in the lower 48 states...... By far!!!! Outta this world needs a raise and a promotion!!! She makes the place my fav!! Overall awesome pizza place!!!! 5 stars!!!! & We recommend everyone go here or order delivery!!!

I always would go next door, and hometown will be packed on both sides. I have gotten 2 large pizza's with pepperoni and sausage.. have been Hot and fresh..cheesy and the sauce is slightly sweet..DELISH!!

lovely place! great atmosphere and service, came in here when it was cold and dark out and they gave me a free personal pizza :)) our servers name was Amanda, the hospitality (and food) were amazing, would recommend

Pizza is amazing and always comes out HOT! We have tried many different ones and we can't pick a favorite. And their breadsticks, omgosh, the garlic butter with them is to die for!

Been going here for 30 years, always good food, service is amazing. Thank you for staying consistent in this crazy world!

Great pizza, great service. I'm a fan and will return many times. 😁

Got the lunch special, individual pizza, any style with salad. $11.00. Delicious 😋

Really yummy pizza and cheesy bread sticks. Lots of options to get the pizza toppings just the way you want it. Great waitstaff with a full understanding of the menu and total patience to explain it in detail. Our meal was served quickly & everything was right the first time. Clean store. Plenty of parking on the shopping center side of the building.

Great food, excellent service, and the staff this is just amazing! I’ve had nothing but great experiences here.

Waitress was super friendly and took good care of us. Pizza was awesome.

I ate a small cheese pizza and it was pretty good, next time I got visit here, I’ll have some pics.

An old standby for us. Good pizza, good sandwiches, better than average house salad.
Just wish they would update the interior. Cover all that wood and walls with some up to date colors. Brighten it up a bit, not so drab.
Still great pizza, still needs updating but here is the let down. We have been participants in their awards program for a very long time. Tonight I inquired as to our total points. What a surprise when we were told. 47. Say what? Must be a mistake. Well Hometown, what are you going to do about this?
Best pizza this area of town.
Cudos for the updated interior. Looks so much better. Clean and bright, good decision. Young lady who waited on us was very good, entertaining.
Only negative, I left my leftover pan of baked spaghetti there. My fault, what a waste.

Something has changed besides ownership. My favorite pizza did not look the same nor taste the same, especially the sauce. Toppings were smaller. Barely any green pepper. Looked like grass clippings. Maybe it's all in my head, but my head says it wasn't like I remember. For that, I'm sad.

Freaking delicious!!! Will be ordering again. The pizza was pizza-ing!

The dedication to making a quality pizza and service goes above and beyond.

You know that kind of pizza place where you think “I could have cooked a frozen pizza better than this”? Well this is NOT that place. We have ordered delivery from here 4 times and every time it’s unbelievably delicious! It’s always hot, like we pulled it from oven just a minute ago HOT! The toppings are fresh and much better than Pizza Hut. You will not be disappointed.

Ashley is so sweet. She’s always working when I go in for lunch and I really enjoy her serving me! The food is always great and fresh.

My favorite is the thin crust collosus. That ricotta cheese gives it an excellent taste. 👍💯

This was my all-time favorite local pizza. But, the last 3 orders were not up to their usual excellent standards. We ordered last Saturday night and were thrilled to see that the pizza was as good or better than ever! Everyone has a bad day, or a few... but glad you're back to being excellent, and Hometown pizza will continue to be my favorite go-to for pizza! Thanks!,

I had a nice experience the time I went. The pizza was good: it had a crispy crust that balanced the cheese and toppings well. My experience with pizza in Louisville hasn't always been commendable, so I'd say Hometown was a win. If you're looking for a place to sit down and enjoy pizza with others, I'd recommend coming here.

Their thick crust is one of the best crust I have had in a long time. It is crunchy, yet soft. Wish they had Halal option.