Toppers Pizza

We primarily do take out orders. Something about the cheese but it is the best that we’ve had on pizza in a long time. The pizza and sticks are always consistent and cooked right and usually the order is ready in like 20 mins. Fast and easy.

Originally gave a 4 but it deserves a 5. Love this place. Been hooked since college. Used to go to the original (I think) location in Whitewater in early 2000s. Now it's a treat any time I'm near one. Honestly don't even get pizza, just the amazing Toppers triple order of bread sticks. Love them! -Not that there is anything wrong with the pizza (it's also really good). I just love the stix.

First time here. Amber was helpful and patient while I looked and asked so many questions. Thank you. And the topperstix is so good

Linnea was great, she helped me pick out a pizza that fit the needs of my employee’s special diet. Thank you .

Delivery was super fast! I'm pretty sure it takes 15 mins for them to get to my house, and that's exactly how long it took for them to process, cook, and deliver my order. Can never go wrong with Toppers anyway.

After an issue with my order, I called into to the store and spoke with Braelinn, who went above and beyond to turn a potential negative experience into a positive experience.

I'm very impressed by the customer service. The food is good, and while the prices are steep, the website often has deals which soften the blow a bit.

Pizza was good service has gotten better over the years

Since my original review this has become a regular part of our takeout repertoire. Quality, consistent food with friendly and efficient staff. World headquarters located right in Whitewater is a cool and quirky bonus to this location.

The people working here really have a passion for the food they make! I went in the other day to pick up an order and was greeted and helped out by a really amazing girl. She said her name was Carina and she was super patient with me and made sure that I didn’t feel rushed at all. She really knew her stuff and I felt very welcomed. I would love to come back again and order with my family! Really great service!

Super super impressed with the customer service and hospitality at this Toppers location.
Time and time over the crew members always go above and beyond... shout out to Gabby, too for being an awesome manager and always making my pizzas 🔥 .... Five Stars Frfr ((:

I ordered for the first time from Toppers Pizza through the Door Dash App. I will definitely be ordering from them again. I tried the boneless BBQ wings, Naked Tots, and the Cinnamon dessert. The only wrong thing was they had forgotten to send the sour cream with the tots. But everything else was phenomenal.

Reasonable prices, great food, and not too long of a wait for the lateness of the hour.

I highly recommend Toppers Pizza.

This place is amazing:) they served the food in a well timed manner and the food was unbelievable. They also have a lot of cool deals and options to choose from. My favorite thing is their topperstix and wings:) 10/10 place

I made the decision to drive across the country (Seattle, WA to New London, CT) for good reasons but as someone who is deathly allergic to dairy, eating while traveling tends to be hazardous to my health so by the time I made it to Wisconsin, I needed food. I assumed I would not be able to get anything until Chicago (maybe because it was already late) but then I found Toppers and ordered a vegan BBQ.

While I opted for curb side because I was not sure how easy it would be to get in and out with my puppy but when I saw it was not busy and the text number to let them know I was there was not recognizing my number, I just went in. Liahna (did not get the spelling) was the primary (only) worker there and really was a breath of fresh air after driving through three states that seem to hate any diversity and/or being a decent nice human being. Liahna offered help with the texting (which honestly who knows if I will ever be back - but also the customer service was so awesome I had to leave a nice review which says something).

Liahna deserves a raise, seriously!! Great tasting pizza. Really above and beyond customer service. There was an obvious care for human beings in general and a pride in the work. So while people often disregard customer service/ restaurant staff, I think they are saints. In this moment where I was hangry and basically had lost faith in human beings - there was a friendly nice person with a warm comforting pizza who was also willing to explain tolls to a West Coaster. That pizza made it almost all the way the NY state and was still delicious! It helped me remember there are still good people (and good vegan pizza) in the world while road raged truckers seemed bent on killing me.

Good people and good pizza are under appreciated and under valued. So when you need some of that warm comfort of a pizza, do not forget to tip heavily so those wonderful people can pay their rent. It is not really necessary for them to be warm in order to do their job but it sure is nice when they are.

This location was great I've only been once Sunday night 6/19/2022 and the food was just right the employee who took our order was kind and really had alot of positive vibes which definitely added all around good experience from food to service. I wish more people were like that

Toppers is hands down my favorite pizza place. Their house specials are just 😘👌. Their pricing is also great (always check out the deals section!). I'm a bit sad to be outside their delivery radius (4.4 miles, 15 minute drive if you hit every red light), but that's not a big deal.

We ordered Toppers tonight for the first time and it was AMAZING! We got the Maui topper, the loaded tot-zza, a pepperoni, and a cheese with cheddar and pepper jack. Best pizza we've had in a while. Great flavor on all and perfect crust. Delivery was quick and price was well worth it. Will be ordering again!

They are great. We stopped in and was going to order take out but they were really busy over an hour wait for take out so we asked them to deliver and by the time we got home and had put away our groceries the arrived. Soon than they had told us by 30 min!!! Perfection that night. We love them

Ive been a consistent customer of toppers for awhile now and will never go to a pizza hut or dominos again. The specialty pizza combinations never let me down and the service is always great. Toppers employee, Presley, has given me a few combinations that are stellar! i will continue to eat here!! 10/10 stars!!!

This is my first time at a toppers pizza and the worker was super patient with me. She walked us through the menu and was able to answer any questions we had about anything on the menu.

Ordered the New Cheese Curd pizza and it was amazing! Had them partly bake it so we could take it camping with us. Finished baking it at the campground and it came out fantastic! Kudos to the new addition to your menu!