Nice Sandwich

We tried the turkey avocado and chicken+bacon sandwiches. Both were really good and we'd definitely get them again.

The customer service was good too.

Tables were a bit dirty, but we only saw one employee handling the register and food. One person can only do so much, so we understood and opted for takeout.

Food is so good. Sandwiches are very large and you definitely get what you pay for. Staff very nice. Place could use an update but that obviously has nothing to do with food quality.

Wow! Had the ham and turkey and was remarkable. I ordered a large and after the order was in they happened to be out of the large bread, so they brought out 2 regular sandwiches (other sandwich not shown in my photo) without even asking. Please support this locally owned business. Real food.. real good. Good vibe too!

The food was absolutely delicious. We placed an order online for four sandwiches, and it was ready for pickup in 20 minutes. Big portions, too. Probably shouldn't have eaten the whole thing, but it was too good not to.

I got the chipotle chicken avocado sandwich and really enjoyed it. Bread was great, helped to elevate it from other sandwich shops. My main gripe is they do not give out free cups for water (they will charge you the cost of a soft drink). Obviously not a big deal, but something you don't often see. Would recommend.

Every sandwich I've tried so far (probably about 5) has been excellent. Bread, flavor, wide selection, all fantastic. Even have gluten free bread for my wife. Happy to be a new regular.

Amazing sandwich! I got the regular size and had to take some home!
Great family run restaurant.

Delicious! Went there for the first time today, knowing they were in the old Schlotzky's location but not knowing their sandwiches were so similar. I had the ham & turkey club sandwich and it was so good!

These sandwiches are DELICIOUS! The ratio of everything on it is perfect. The bread is delicious! I had the turkey and salami and I was so pleased! Definitely recommend trying this place, 10/10, I will be going again!

A family member brought over several different sandwichs recently. I had a sliver of each one and they were excellent!

Best bread ever! It is so light and airy! You wi t br disappointed! Quick n delicious. Great variety of sandwiches.

The food was very yummy! The service was great as well. Not badly priced at all.

Very nice guy working at the counter fast service and good food love how they don’t skimp on toppings or sauce ! Will be back thanks

Nice Sandwich should be called *BEST SANDWICH* Because that's what you'll get! These are the best sandwiches you will get anywhere. So full of flavor and hearty! I have since tried every sandwich on the menu and I can while heartily say that there is not one of them you'll find that doesn't live up to the hype. You won't be disappointed. They seem like the best food secret in West Allis. Try them and you'll see what I'm talking about.

Everything about this place was great. My wife and I love the fresh sandwiches.

We had a last minute dinner change and decided to check this place out. We all got the ham and turkey club sandwiches and they were fantastic. Quick service as well!

Great tasting food and it looks fresh. If anything could've used a bit more warmth and inviting atmosphere/staff. Not that anyone was rude or unacceptable just some feedback.

Roast Beef and Bacon sandwich pictured.

I'm only here luckily due to another local Milwaukee Guide and I'm actually very happy to see them keep many great iterations of what WAS Schlotzkys is here now ! Now that I know it's here to stay, I'll again be a regular happy customer. Thanks for getting Nice Sandwich open guys and gals!

*Noting they close at 4pm every day but Sunday at 2pm.

An excellent sandwich place. What really sets this place apart from other sandwich places is the fresh, fluffy bread. You won't find a better veggie sandwich anywhere else! The depth of flavor and the addition of cheesy jalapeno bread elevates this to the next level. Best enjoyed with some MKE chips thrown on the sandwich!

This sandwich shop has a very close replication of a muffaletta sandwich. The sandwich is really good, I ask to remove the lettuce and tomatoes because that doesn't go on the original sandwich. If the other sandwiches are as good as the muffaletta then this place is a gem.