Old Germantown

Had a wonderful experience here for my brother's birthday. The sausages were all delicious and flavorful in their own way while the pizzas were very unique flavors. I also really enjoyed the two beers that I had. I hope to go back sometime in the future!

Good food good beer and good service. Good selection of beer from sours to stouts; lagers and barrel-aged; even NAs. Generous amount of space both indoors and out. Family friendly. Delicious wood- fired pizza. Tasty fried pretzel bites. Would go again.

This is a gem located in the countryside! The people are super nice! We went for lunch on a Friday, and it wasn't crowded. Evenings are very busy, but worth the wait. Friends had individual pizzas which came to the table quickly and hot! I enjoyed the homemade Sicilian sausage "brat" and I will definitely suggest you try it! Lots of craft beers and good wine selection.
Note: the owners told us the new barn that houses the restaurant and all the furniture were crafted by the Amish.

5/5 excellent family friendly restaurant also family own. I cannot believe I've been leaving in the area for so long, and it was just now that I discovered this place. Very clean place, bathrooms (at least women one) has a changing table which I appreciate. The wooden ceiling gives a cabin atmosphere very relaxing during this time of the year. Food wow....if you are a sausage lover definitely stop by. All or I should say the majority of they beer are homebrew and the amber ones are delicious (they could be a bit cooler). Their pizza...mmmmmm .... delicious, great balanced flavors, the dough was great. We had a mexican one and a mixed sausage along with amber beer. They also sell sausage and sauce. Definitely stop by

We love coming here for the wood fire pizza! We especially like the Mexican street corn and Greek pizza. Also love that well behaved dogs are allowed outside and the entire staff is so friendly.

My new favorite pizza place. We travel over 30 mins to come here. The food is out of this world. The sourdough pizza dough is superior to all others. Every pizza we have tried has been amazing. And the pretzel bites are outstanding. Better yet are the workers and owners. The warm welcomes and the follow up to ensure food and your environment is great is top notch. My whole family loves coming here and this is will be staple in our lives for a long time.

Great food, atmosphere and the whole vibe. Owner Scott is amazing man as well! The beer, Sausage and Pizza are the bomb!

Unique setting and cool building. Limited food menu but it is delicious. We each had a wood fired pizza and they were each large enough for two meals. Good deal at around $13 a pie. Have decent local craft beer selection but I can't wait until their brewery is running which hopefully summer of 2021. Outdoor seating too.

Update: Brewery opened in 2022.

2023...We visit about every other month. Delightful experience but know it gets extremely busy and on weekends they may stop taking orders around 6:30 due to volume.

We had a large group there recently for my son's birthday. We found a table to sit at outside, scanned a QR code and ordered drinks, a sausage sampler (they make their own), fries, artichoke dip, and several pizzas and they began arriving pretty promptly. One pizza came out really late after everything else, but the staff was really nice about it. Best margarita pizza I've ever had - loved the sauce and crust was soft, chewy and toppings were super fresh. Everyone was really happy with the food, except for the one late pizza, but it was a great place to be outside on a beautiful day. Dogs are allowed outside, which I love - will likely bring mine when I return. The place is in the middle of nowhere and there's not even a sign, so it feels like a great secret, which is fun, and it's really beautiful with plenty of parking - it was absolutely packed when we were there. Better to get there well before closing time - they stop serving pizzas at a certain point, some people next to us were very disappointed to discover.

What a cool place! This is an old farmstead that happens to now be dominated by a beer hall / brew pub. I'm not really sure how to label the place, really, but go there for excellent craft beer and great accompanying food like sausage and wood fired pizza. The employees were all very friendly and the service was top notch. I'm happy Germantown has something like this. What a gem!

I have been here a few times and have never been disappointed. The pretzel knots are amazing and the pizza’s are so good. The beer is outstanding as well. We also enjoy the live music when seated outside.

Excellent pizza and good customer service. Highly recommended.

Amazing spot! We arrived and were greeted by a very kind man who explained that they were busy and a bit short staffed, apologized in advance for the wait and explained how everything worked. There was a sign out front noting the 2 hour wait time, so they are very transparent. We got our pizza order in quickly, then relaxed and enjoyed some pretzel bites, a bottle of wine and some cribbage. When the pizza came out, it was worth the wait. Everything was delicious, fresh, and unique. I highly recommend the Mexican Street Corn Pizza, but everything we ordered was fantastic - can’t go wrong.

This place has it all. The location and atmosphere are excellent. Great outdoors seating and play areas for families with children. The home made sausages flavors are rotated so every time you come you can probably try a new flavor. Pizzas are good. Lots of home crafter tap beers. The owner is super cool and nice. Very clean and open facility. Only "knock" would be the dust from the gravel driveway and parking areas. But that's part of this place's charm. I'll be going back multiple more times. Be warned to come early if you don't want to wait. By 5:30 there was an hour wait for pizzas already.

Absolutely delicious food, cozy and relaxing atmosphere, great and speedy customer service! Pizza is delicious, the sausages are awesome! Get the Thai Curry sausage for sure! I love the small town barn feel of this location. Plenty of outdoor seating, family friendly! I will be a returning customer

Super happy to have returned to Old Germantown restaurant for the third time and first time inside the restaurant. Farm Fresh means extra work, planning and focus on ingredients. Forget instant gratification found in drive through's and fast food mass production-delivery. This is a family run throw back offering awesome craft beers made onsite and many creative personal pizza's. Just like the thousands of small craft breweries throughout the west, sometimes ale/beer types run out, you get to venture to other tastes! If you want some lager canned weeks ago designed for college kids on spring break, this is not a place for you. If you are in a hurry and long ago forgot what restaurant atmosphere is, this is not a place for you. If you need a large backlit sign to find the driveway (like main street America looks today), this is not a place for you. Here is a challenge, find the restaurant without your GPS!
Last night we tried the "Milwaukee" pizza and if you grew up in Southeastern Wisconsin you know what a "Milwaukee" pizza should taste and look like. They nailed it and I get the left overs today! Regarding the Ale; I was a taste tester for a global Milwaukee beer company, have traveled the Western hemisphere trying ales and beers all over. The ales here are excellent.
If you get an opportunity I highly recommend Old Germantown, enjoy!

We enjoyed our first visit. Had it not been for GPS we wouldn't have known where it was, it's a well kept secret for a good reason. We have the cheese board and the 5 sausage sampler. Recommend them if you can not decide what to pick.

Great little place! Beer was great, unique and tasty wood fired pizza, amazing patio and ambiance. Only a few miles from home but felt like I was on vacation. Looking forward to coming back many times this summer.

It was my first time at this establishment….Was WONDERFUL! Barn is beautiful…. Pizza was GREAT….Beer and wine topped everything off! It was very special that the owner stopped at all the tables to make sure we were pleased.

This is by far the best pizza in the area wow! The ordering is a little different but the hostess is very friendly and walks you through it. You can order and pay at the till then be seated at a table or they also have a QR code to scan to order at the tables, you can order more drinks and such from the QR code as well. We were estimated to be seated in 45 minutes which isn't horrible for 5pm on a Saturday night, we were seated in 10! My husband and I had ordered the potato fritters; I really enjoyed them crispy on the outside super soft and creamy on the inside with a nice cheesy pull, the onion dip was excellent nice balance of savory and salty. I ordered the sizzling T' chicken pizza; the sauce has a nice smokey savory flavor, the chicken sausage is nice and tender with a nice blend of spices. The pizza overall has a nice pull and the crust is nice and crispy. The only thing I could say to add is maybe a hand sanitizer bottle on the tables because the pizza is a bit messy.