Caterina's Ristorante

First time coming to eat here. Came in on a whim, on a Saturday. We didn’t have reservations but highly recommend them. We got lucky, they had one table left. The prices are a bit high but the food & service was EXCELLENT!! We never had to wait for anything!! Had the calamari as an appetizer & it was tender & tasty. The chicken soup was homemade! My only complaint is they didn’t have sangria which was a bummer.
The staff was very friendly & we will be back!!

First time dining here and it was a great experience. The service was great, constant water refills, and a server who checked on us throughout the evening. The food was served in a timely manner and it did not disappoint. Tony also personally introduced himself and took care of us as we celebrated a special occasion. Wonderful old school italian experience.

First time there. Arrived 15 minutes before reservation and enjoyed the bar while waiting for our party to fully arrive. Atmosphere is delightful. Bartender was personable, respectful, and funny! On to dinner, the staff was INCREDIBLE. Not a single beat missed on ensuring we had everything needed. Our host noticed both me and another guest are hard of hearing. She didn’t make a scene about it (this happens a lot), was extremely professional, and made sure we understood. Food was delicious. We all had a great time and will definitely be back.

Celebrated our 47th Anniversary last night at Caterina's. Once again the food was outstanding, and the staff was awesome. We definitely will go back. Already made our Christmas Eve reservations.

This place has been amazing for 25 years that I have been going. It's fine dining at it's best. The food is great, the wines are amazing. A must stop.

We had our first experience at Caterina’s today and can’t wait to go back! Beautiful, home cooked Italian food - big portions at great prices. Exceptional, old fashioned service - you feel like family! The braised pork shank special melted in your mouth, don’t miss it if it’s available. Everything was Italian perfection and such a wonderful atmosphere. GO HERE! Will be talking about this fantastic meal for a long time to come.

A perfect place to enjoy an Italian dinner. Great staff, extensive menu of well prepared Italian food. I enjoyed every last slurp of linguini with clams. The salad, bread, and appetizer platter are also very satisfying before the meal arrives.

Have driven by this place for years and finally decided to try it out, and I really wish I would have come sooner! I have not had service like this for years! Unbelievable wait staff who are warm, inviting, and know their menu well. Right away you get fresh warm bread with garlic olive oil and parmesan along with a plate of amazing cheese, sausage, and an Italian chickpea dish with vegetables. By far the best I have ever had! Recommend the lemon drop martini too! So yummy. Ordered the calamari for an appetizer and it exceeded our expectations! Again, the best we ever had! If you love calamari you have to try it here! Then with our entrees we got a fresh salad which was the perfect size. But super impressed with the entrees. Both dishes had scallops and shrimp, the jumbo ones, and they were not overcooked at all! Seasoned perfectly, pasta was perfect. And although the menu is on the pricey side, it is soooooo worth every penny for the quality of the service and the food.HIGHLY RECOMMEND!! I have attached some pics but took them after we started digging in....

We were there this evening. Me for the first time. The whole experience was fabulous and I can't say enough about the service. Everyone was so very attentive. I haven't experienced that in quite awhile!
Great job we will be back!

First time visit, Classic old style decor restaurant but looks perfect with the Italian menu choices to please everyone.
Food was very well prepared, prices were appropriate.
Recommended place to dine! We’ll be back!

Amazing service! Love the included cheese and meat tray at dinner. The escargot is perfect. At the bar the bourbon selection is a treat for a connisuer. Thank you Caterinas!

Ended up here randomly today after looking on Google maps for restaurants while I was in the area. Caterina's was the first one that popped up, and it was rated high so I headed over and was pleasantly surprised. I’m very picky when it comes to Italian food and everything was so fresh, all of the staff & patrons were in such good moods it was a great atmosphere. It was SO much food for the price. The tiramisu was very fresh and the perfect way to end The Weekend. Sadly I didn’t get a photo of my pasta, I was too busy eating it. Thank you!

Its so beautiful inside. Tje lighting is warm and cozy. The bread tasted awesome. The lasagna was the best i had from a restaurant. It was cooked. You can taste it wasnt frozen. The salad was amazing too. They brought out a dessert for my bachelors graduation! Thanks for the awesome experience. Id love to return

Can so tell everything is soooo freshly made the big meat ball special was not your average meat ball, melts in your mouth!! the lamb shank was succulent and fall off the bone tender so yummy and was very impressed why I knew I've been wanting to go for the past years worth the weight the way Italian food should be.

Always amazing service and food. It is great for a date night or dinner with friends.

First time visiting. The service was fantastic. The ambiance was very relaxing and fun. The food was incredible. I highly recommend giving this place a try if you're looking for really good italian.

Went here on Valentines Day without a reservation, and the owner gave us a table even though they were very busy. The food is very good

I’ve been in the best Italian restaurants in every major city in the United States and Caterinas tops them all. It’s a hidden gem. Anyone who I refer to them thanks me.

Nice, friendly place. You can dress up or down but either way it's classy and you are welcomed. We had a reservation so experienced zero wait time. It's small but set up well. The food is great. There's an appropriate amount of wait time between arriving and ordering and eating.
Our group of four adults ordered: Four appetizers: bruschetta, breaded conch, mozzarella marinara, and escargot. Two sodas, a glass of wine, and a whiskey drink. Three salads and a soup. Cod Vesuvio, Porterhouse, Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo, and Sea Scallops and Scampi. There was some kind of antipasto platter with a fresh garlic oil, and the fresh bread was to die for, both complimentary. Our bill was about $266. There was so much food that we didn't order dessert and had leftovers.
Highly recommend.

Great little gem. Staff is so attentive and friendly. The menu is large, and complimentary meat and cheese tray is so good. Portions are huge and the prices are very good. The wine list is very good as well. Will definitely be back. Kudos to waitstaff on their knowledge of the menu and the table assistant was right on task filling waters and clearing items right away. Keep up the great work. Sorry we haven't been here sooner.