The Bay Restaurant

Wonderful establishment!!!! This is truly a hidden treasure. We went on a Thursday evening, and it was pretty busy. We were able to get a table immediately. We had a wonderful waitress who provided her favorites which really helped us choose our dinner. We had the buffalo cauliflower bites, hummus with vegetables, salmon salad and buffalo fried chicken salad. Everything was amazing! The hummus is house made. You can’t beat that., . .

Wonderful smells and soon as you get near the place. Chili was excellent. Pulled pork sandwich was good not fantastic.
Very nice place. Waitress and person who served the food....maybe the chef, were courteous and attentive. Indoor and outdoor very clean and comfortable feeling. Outdoor has some vertical heaters for when the weather turns colder. Nice to see Hinterland on tap.

Big fan of this place. Nice to have a hip local bar right downtown Whitefish Bay in the north shore. There is a great outdoor patio for when the weather is good. Nice variety of menu items. The Bay Burger is a classic. Feel good place to go as well since the owners are very active in the community.

Y’all know I like to taste good food. This place delivered. Drinks were amazing and my sweet potato burger hit the spot. Sometimes it’s hard to find a place that offers a good lighter meal. This place has choices and I appreciate that.

Since moving to Whitefish Bay we have been coming here regularly for a couple months now. We have had nothing but great service from both the regular bartender and his backup when he is out, as well as the wait staff. The food has been great. We love the place. Tonight they were full, but ran downstairs and got another barstool so we didn’t have to wait.

We eat here often out of convenience, but it’s always decent! The food is okay; but the drinks and service is always great! Ariana is our server pretty much every visit and she is wonderful!

Lemon Dill Pasta was wonderful!
Sarah is awesome and great with meal suggestions!

Took the wife here for dinner after our date day on Saturday. Our reservation was ready and waiting for us. The restaurant was bustling yet we felt very comfortable in our booth. The server was very attentive and we got to enjoy a great selection of food for dinner. The highlight being the Salmon Cake appetizers. Crab cakes won't ever compare. This is a great place to go for quality food, good prices, and relaxing atmosphere!

Nice atmosphere, inside and outside. It was cold so we stayed inside. Our server was very pleasant and helpful, and checked on us several times. The food was delicious and cooked perfectly. I had the lasagna. It was very flavorful and a good portion

Great chill local joint, good food, friendly atmosphere and great staff. Awesome outdoor seating in the summer. Our Server Carli is the best, always checking in and looking out for us.

The Bay Restaurant is a sure win when you swing on by. My favorite Hour is Happy Hour and they've got fantastic cocktails with great food; what more could you ask for?!!!! When you step in ask for Sally and tell her Molly sent you.

Ariana, as always, took such good care of us! If you enjoy great food and even better service the Bay is a must stop in Whitefish Bay!

Ariana was great. I was flying solo with two young kids and she went above and beyond to make sure we had what we needed. Thank you!

Delicious food. Excellent service. Ariana was awesome! Will definitely be back soon!

Carli was amazing! She was kind and patient and took our birthday picture over and over again. A true sweetheart!

Sarah is an amazing server. She would be great as trainer for new team members. Live her 🥰🥰🥰

Clean place with solid menu. Service (Ariana) was friendly and prompt
Great place to stop in for a brew and a bite!

Food is amazing!!! Ariana N is a fantastic server and makes incredible drinks

We love it here. Our server Ariana has been amazing every time!

This is my favorite place to catch top notch live jazz with my meal. Our server, Sarah, was a doll.