Mixed Bag MKE

This shop has been open for about a year now and is full of cute, unique, homemade, and locally sourced items. For everyone! I stopped in here to find some Easter gifts for my adult children and was not disappointed. I found the perfect items for them, and easily could have spent a lot more time (and money) here! The shop looks, smells, and feels amazing. Stopping in here totally made my day, and I definitely plan to go back!

The woman who helped me (I believe she was the owner) was so nice and helpful. She answered all my questions and was rightfully proud of the amazing shop she decided to add to our community.

Check out the Mixed Bag's website to explore all the items this place has to offer. You can even place an order online!

If you're looking for someplace new to find a thoughtful, creative, and one-of-a-kind gift while also supporting Wisconsin and Midwest artisans, pay this place some attention.

Mixed Bag has a nice selection of unique gifts for adults and children; some items are sourced from local talent which I love to support; very welcoming atmosphere and service. I was very happy with my purchases; will shop here again

I love this shop! It is so well curated and has super fun gifts. The owner is a maker too and I love supporting local artists.

It seems to have come in the crosshairs by a religious groups for carrying some goofy, tongue in cheek candles - but this is so unfair. I see these candles sold at other local businesses and on Amazon. I truly hope the bullying of this small business stops. Support local!

Bought a Taylor Swift candle here and I pray with it every night that Reputation (Taylor’s Version) will be announced soon. I love this store!!

Fantastic stop filled with locally made items that supports local artists. A wide variety of pop culture items, cards, candle, art, stationary, ect... to suit everyone's tastes. They have even have a children's section with very nice high quality educational items. This is a great place to pick up unique gifts! My daughter and I had the best interaction with the owner when we were there. Highly recommend!!!!

Support local & handmade! This shop is so cute and supports so many artists and handmade products. It's a go-to for gifts and items for the home. The owner is amazing and so is her love for the community. So glad this place exists!

We love Mixed Bag! It is a friendly welcoming shop that sells charming and unique gifts. Ignore the ridiculous negative comments from a fundamental Christian organization that is upset about fun celebrity candles being sold in this shop (and about a million other places including Amazon). With all the tragedies happening in the world, this organization is placing a bizarre amount of energy into creating negative attention for this benevolent little shop.

Ok y'all hear me out!

This place has a superb selection of gifts for young and old alike. Mugs, jewelry, cards, candles, incense, and more.

Support a small, local business. I was born and raised here and this place supports our local lifestyle and traditions but, I must say, it could have some more Satan paraphernalia.

Praise be. 🤟

Such a unique and wonderful local shop in Whitefish Bay, WI. This store has a wide array of products suitable for all ages! I love what they bring to the local community and the fact that they are also supportive of and carry product from other local businesses. If you are in the Whitefish Bay area, stop by and support this local gem!

I love this store, their items are super cute and make great gifts. The staff are warm and inviting. I would recommend this to anyone looking for a cute pop culture novelty gift.

Mixed Bag is a great addition to the stores on Silver Spring, and is one of my go-to places for gifts. The owner and staff are lovely, warm, and helpful. Highly recommend!

Terrific selection of interesting items! Many local makers products sold here. I can always find just the right gift! The owner is super friendly and helpful.

This stop is so cute and has so many fun pop culture items. It's the perfect place to go for fun gifts. It's so important to shop local and support small mom and pop shops.

It is unfortunate that a handful of religious nuts are trying to take down this wonderful, local establishment through bad reviews because they are upset about a picture on a candle. This store has great staff, product selection, and atmosphere. I love shopping here!

We’re so fortunate to have this locally owned small business in our neighborhood! I’ve always been able to find just the right gift for a friend or family member here and am always greeted with a smile and a kind hello whenever I shop.

I always choose this store when looking for a high quality unique gift. There is always something new! The children’s section is one of my favorites. Highly recommend.

Just spent a good amount of money here thanks to the protesting fools.

Funny candles (which other businesses in the area also sell) I have one of David Schitt. Great gift selection. Very diverse, inclusive, and eco conscious. Love the pillows and the jewelry too.

If you're religious, it's ok hun, dont be such a snowflake.
- sincerely, a gay (with no kids and a big income)

Don’t let the religious hate groups deter you away from this cute shop. Good products and relevant pop culture gifts for anyone/everyone.

I've been to this shop multiple times, and each time the owner was helpful and engaging. The shop is so cute with lots of different merchandise to chose from. I will be going back again and again!

Such lovely gifts for kids and adults, cards, and self-care goodies in this shop! It's a great addition to our community.