Nick & Joe's Pizza

I never feel inclined to leave reviews, but I had a super positive experience with the restaurant!! I ordered on GrubHub and found the pricing to be super fair compared to other restaurants on the app. The food was amazing and came with salad and bread which was such a pleasant surprise! I think the delivery driver works for the restaurant and he was sure to hand deliver my food so my soup wouldn’t spill! (The soup is incredible by the way) Overall, I had a super positive experience and I will definitely be ordering from here again :)

Our go to place! Daughter orders from there once a week. We moved away and didn't come for awhile. The owner was like, hey where have you been! He know our whole family! Love the small community feeling.

Ordered a Cheesesteak with fried onions, mushrooms, lite mayo with lettuce & tomatoes. Take out. It was toe curling good. Stopped in the middle of eating call the restaurant to let them know how tasty and delicious my cheesesteak was. I was over the moon happy with a very satisfied stomach and pleased with the taste.

The best Italian subs, the best cheese steaks! We really like the pizza a lot too!!

I love the pizza 🍕 prices are not too bad

I’ve never been served a bad sandwich from this place. I always get their cheesesteak and it’s by far the best cheesesteak experience I’ve ever had. I don’t say that lightly either as someone who’s worked in food for over a decade and has tried nearly every cheesesteak in the area. Great service as well never once had a problem and I’ll continue to go here until I can’t walk anymore. Y’all are awesome and I love you

Just got a slice. Cheapest in town at 2.10. Not the best but gets the job done

Awesome local spot! The staff are friendly and recognize their regulars. Food is great, delivery is always timely, and tons of menu options! I haven’t found a Buffalo chicken pizza that beats Nick & Joe’s yet.
You can split pizzas in half as well to have two different sets of toppings, which is super handy. Highly recommend!

They have amazing food and just as good service/prices! From their pizza, to their turnovers and strombolli's, it's all good! I personally like their chicken finger platter (comes w/fries and a salad!). Definitely a good place to stop by for a quick lunch!

One of the better pizza places around the Newark area. Good prices and some different options to choose from. Taco pizza and bacon cheeseburger pizza are my favorites, though there's not really any bad choices depending on what you like. 👍

Stopped in for a slice. Converted! I'm going to be a regular. Great pizza, clean dining and kitchen area, friendly service. Someone had a plate of pasta that looked fantastic as well.

Their meat supreme pizza is hands down the best pizza I have ever eaten! My favorite used to be their Hawaiian pizza until I tasted their meat supreme pizza. WOW!

Solid goto pizza in a college town.

Robert Anderson great job

Always amazing pizza and friendly service. I love that they deliver. They have a delicious cheese steak wrap!!!!

Great food, delivered at record speed. We order from them often and love it.

We're "pizza snobs" visiting from Buffalo, NY. Nick & Joe's Pizza is the best we've had outside of our hometown, EVER!

Always good food! Nice people and many choices!

I've moved out of state and have to get their nachos every time I come back!

Excellent pizza! Friendly staff. Been around for along time, they are a local staple!