The Incredible Pizza Co

I was working late and feeling hungry, so I went there late after most other places had closed for the night.

I ordered a BLT pizza. The guy at the counter learned that it was my first time here so he went out of his way to make sure I had a good pizza. It was good. :)

Wait time was about average, maybe 15 mins. I suppose they could put a few chairs in the waiting area but otherwise, no complaints, and I appreciate the extra service.

This is the place I've been looking for, so stop your Google search here. When other places close these lovely people cater to those that work odd hours, who want pizza after 10pm in Newark this is your place! Buy 2 subs get the 3rd free and they're delicious, pizza buy one get one the same size $4 more! Please check menus as prices may be subject to change but I'm incredibly hooked on the incredible pizza place you will be too! Don't forget to tip your driver.

The female manager tonight was amazing. She made up for our bad experience last time. I didn't catch her name but I am sure they know which manager worked tonight 1-1-19 at 6pm. We asked for the pizza a certain way and she didn't act like it was a burden. She was enthusiastic and very nice. Best experience here yet. Thank you!!!

Excellent Pizza! I ordered here for my family and my kids loved the pizza and subs. we ordered 2 pizzas and 3 subs and it was nice to have a little left over the next day. The pizza is just a little thicker than a thin crust which we love, and you only need to eat a couple pieces to fill you up whereas most the places, you can eat a whole thin crust pizza yourself and it cost you more. Good pizza, good prices, will definitely start eating here more often!! Unfortunately, I think this place gets negative reviews because it is open late night and has to deal with belligerent drunk people. Not fair to them, when their pizza id obviously very good. Good Luck to this place!!

Our family ordered 4 subs and all of them was very good. Meatball Sub tasted very good with an authentic Italian taste. The Turkey Sub was very good with a nice toast bun along with the Philly Cheese Steak Sub was delicious. The The service was great and the food was served timely with a smile!

I ordered an Italian sub and it was amazing never tasted anything better in my life and delivery was here before they said they would be! Update: They said they changed the sauce and omg my taste buds are in heaven like their pizza is better than Papa John's now definitely ordering bot pizza and subs from here every Friday night

Have had it many times enjoy it every time they are low staffed for the pure amount of orders they put out but verything i have gotten was delicious I usally order a chicken Alfredo pasta it's 9.99 and comes with a free garlic bread I add cheese to mine

I cant believe that this place is not more popular? Not only are they open till 4am but the owner actually makes the sauce and many other items from scratch!!!! Maybe its because everyone is so use to the taste of the poison the corporations are killing us with they cant tell the difference between whats causing all their health problems and a good old fashion quality product!! Well I love this place and will support them with my hard earned money ANYDAY!

Ok first people complaining about a ranch dressing GROW UP.. ..this is the only decent pizza place around. there open till 4 .!!!....why don't. U Google who's open until 4am..... Hm.. McDonald's...and incredibles pizza I personally think the service is pretty good ,fast and reliable...if the delivery time is not fast enough you could always pick the food up your self love this place try it before you knock it...wings are good subs are good pizzas good

Always get a salad. They are very good and a great price. Staff is always smiling and friendly.

One thing is its defiantly not fast, but the subs and pizza they make are always delicious and packed full. So yes the waiting time is worth it.

Great for that after midnight food cravings. Delivery times get longer the later you put in an order, but that is to be expected when they are likely the only place delivering after midnight. Unless, of course, you want to pay an arm and a leg for doordash!

I tried the old world spicy pepperoni tonight and it was fantastic. My kids absolutely loved the side of garlic sauce that we ordered with it! Keep it up! Can't wait to get it again!

Awesome Pizza and Great employees! It's to bad so many haters around here put bad reviews trying to get free food. Great food and better prices, Incredibles is a great option for meal time! Also open till 4 am!!!

Great deals on food. Meatball subs are my favorite. Best thing about this place is they are open till 4am!! (Maybe 4:30am) but how awesome is that!

People say they are not good sober, but I will say the blt pizza is very good. Regular pizza is good. not my to favorite, but not the worst. Looking forward to trying their subs.

Under new mangament, if ur on hold for long periods of time then maybe a worker is on the phone, u may ask if u would like, there r new workers for the most part if ur having rude workers were sorry about that, there should never be a rude worker and we will replace food as long its the same night if there is anything u need we would be happy to help thanks for all the comments it will help us do our job better that's for sure. If u have had a bad experience plz let's us know we will do our best to fix our issuse again thks

Food was amazing ordered a salad and so many toppings and so fresh!! Delivery time was less than what they told me and their open late for us nightshifters!

I ordered an Italian sub and love my Green Olives and they always give me extra. Chef

Incredibles pizza stands up to their name. Their Pizza sincerely is incredible. They have a very wholesome environment and are down-to-earth.