Michelangelo of North Port

We've been in NP for almost 2 years, we've heard of Michelangelo's for quite a while, we even knew someone that worked there in the past, yet have not tried their food until tonight.

Dig it...

The Eggplant Rollatini was absolutely spectacular, cooked to perfection in a homemade red sauce that is authentic and flavorful, every bite was an experience.

The pizza was as equally delicious; we had a simple cheese pizza with pepperoni, green pepper and onion, insane!

The side salad was super fresh, their home dressing a delicate masterpiece.

The side of sautéed garlic and spinach was delicious, while most places drown their spinach in ridiculous amounts oil, not here, it was cooked perfectly.

The staff was all smiles and very friendly, we felt welcomed and appreciated.

Thank you.

So... go there, eat and love, tip well, smile and be grateful we have a place like Michelangelo's in our wonderful neighborhood.

UPDATE: the BBQ chicken pizza is absolutely remarkable!

Best Italian food I've ever had. I tried the sample plate. Large portion of lasagna and stuffed manicotti. The red sauce with meat was thick and yummy. Lots of it to cover the dishes. I took some home - the serving size was generous.
True Love had marsala chicken. He said the pasta was cooked perfectly, not over done like chain Italian restaurants. He asked for a little more sauce and they brought him 1/2 cup - way more than needed. Yum! Chicken was tender and sauce was good too.
Our waitress, Jessica, took our order and kept checking back to make sure everything was good. It was! Her smile was welcoming and her sense of humor was fun. We will definitely go back. It's a great restaurant. Oh, they make pizza too. We'll try that next time.

Got a take out large pizza $28. Crust was perfectly almost burnt. Excellent crust. Like crisp and chewy sourdough bread. 4 adults fed for $30.

We tried the Grandma’s Pizza and it was delicious! Fresh ingredients… you can absolutely taste quality. Desserts are also very tasty. They have lunch specials as well. We’ll return!

OUTSTANDING! My favorite Italian place when visiting North Port. Reasonably priced. Fabulous staff. Delicious flavors from the vast array of pizza options and then the entrees. The bread and salads are enviable/fresh/yummy until the main course. And then the portions are more like family style. Always enough for next day's lunch. Extra benefit is how courteous they are of senior customers regarding finickiness, hearing aids, and leftovers. Well done, Michelangelo!! You make dining out a pleasure! Come to West Palm? 😎
[Borrowed some photos from online as I avoid phone during dining 😋]

I stopped by a month ago first ordering the seafood platter, then the Pizza, & other dinners, now I'm a regular customer. Like most Florida transplants I searched for a Pizza Place like the Pizza where I came from, Jersey. Michelangelo has Excellent Real Italian Pizza & Dinners! Julio the Pizza man is like a Picasso but his palette is not canvas but the pizza dough, he makes the most visually attractive & flavorful Pizzas I ever tasted. Every item I tried was fresh & tasty.

Ordered takeout. Order was ready on time, hot, and accurate. Everything tasted great! Will be back.

Everything was delicious...great service!! 100% recommended!

This is a great local pizzeria. Not to far off 75 for a visit. The wife had meatballs and a salad. Both were very good and the low carb diet was satisfied. I enjoyed 2 very large slices of pepperoni NYC style. Fold and eat while you try to keep the oil from dripping off. Great!

Their original pepperoni pin wheels are my favorite. I was impressed by the quality and taste of right away.

Great Value: Michelangelo's Pizza offers these pepperoni pin wheels at an incredible value. You get a delicious and satisfying snack without breaking the bank. It's a budget-friendly option that doesn't compromise on taste.

Perfect Cheese: Michelangelo's gets the cheese-to-pepperoni ratio just right. The cheese is wonderfully melty and complements the flavorful pepperoni. It's the kind of cheesy goodness that you crave when you think of pizza.

Sauce on the Side: One thing I particularly appreciate is that they include sauce on the side. It's a small touch that adds so much to the experience. You can dip the pin wheels into the sauce to your heart's content, customizing the flavor to your liking.

The Absolute Best Pizza I’ve Had Since I’ve Moved To Florida Little Expensive But Worth Every Penny.

Tried the rest?now try the best staff is top notch and they have the best pizza around coupled with a great staff this place is a must

Good meat lovers Za's.... service was good.... clean restaurant.. friend who came with me for first time enjoyed the pizza etc...

They catered our wedding a lot of food. Everything was amazing with plenty for everybody. I’m from New York. I’m very picky but the food was absolutely amazing.

First slice of pizza in Florida. The food was tasty and the service was great.

My son and I enjoyed a delicious dinner last night. The calamari was the best we've had in the area. It was tender and the batter was deliciously seasoned and crisp. I hate chewy calamari and my son said "wow!" The pizza was "oh my goodness" good. Finished with tiramisu instead of birthday cake for me. Also service was pleasant and prompt. I can't wait to go back. Yum!

We order from here at least every two weeks. Friendly service here and great pie. Grandmas slice and stuffed meat is really good. Pasta dish I like is the chicken piccata with the artichokes. Will be back soon!

For Florida Italian food it was Amazing, pizza and dinners! Reminds me of up north. I’ve been coming here for a long time and the food is always great. The staff is exceptionally nice as well.
Gave Jessica a nice tip she was respectful and courteous. Anyone else here complaining is sad and miserable their retirement funds are running low.

So happy to have found this neighborhood gem on Mothersday dinner- a lot of local places were closed and it was looking like we were going to have to cook… and then Michelangelo’s popped up….Fresh affordable food and friendly service. Our server Jessica was terrific. My husband said his baked ziti was flowered just right. I had the eggplant park it was yummy and I had leftovers. The fresh hot rolls was possibly the best I have had.

The owner is a young entrepreneur with a very good head on his shoulders. Hard worker puts quality into his product, and the staff are friendly and very attentive to their customers. There are not enough stars to give him.