Pizza Castle

I was looking for something to eat in the area and Pizza Castle was the first place to pop up when looking for food. I ordered the Chicken Parm Sandwich with Pickles & Cheese Fries and i absolutely loved it! I placed the order for delivery as a first time customer and the delivery was very fast as well. Definitely will order here again.

At first when they first opened up I was disappointed. But they sure did change my opinion about them through out the last 6 time I have ordered from them. Excellent quality pizzas and they taste great. If you ask they will cook it to your liking as well this is why I have to give them 5 stars. Thank you for moving into the area!

After hiking at Swallow Cliff we stopped by Pizza Castle because of the good reviews, the reviews are definitely spot on! We tried their plain cheese and sausage pizza slice combo which came with fries and soda…Everything was delicious. The restaurant is very clean and cozy. Great customer service as well! Definitely coming back if we’re ever in the area.

I learned about tavern style Chicago thin crust on TV and we were traveling near Hickory Hills. I searched for this specific pizza and Pizza Castle was one of the choices on our route, just off the highway. What a treat! Pizza was amazing and so was the Italian Beef dipped with mozzarella and a side of jardiniere (sp?) peppers. The staff was great, Carryout customers picking up their pies, store was clean and neat. We sat outside at patio tables enjoying the evening breeze. Multiple families arrived to eat while we were there. I now know why they’ve been in business 50 years.

A gem that moved to Hickory Hills from Chicago. One of my absolute favorite thin “tavern” style pizzas around! Thin and crispy crust. Quality toppings. True pizza experts that have been in the game for YEARS. They keep customers satisfied with very reasonable prices even in today’s climate. Always an amazing experience…delightful staff. The owner is super cool. But, most importantly, the pizza is top notch. They do it right…A must stop whenever I am back in town. I love PIZZA CASTLE. (For those interested, they have a full bar and gaming options)

They are THE BEST! 😋

I was there frequently when they were in Chicago and continue to drive here for pick up.
I’m always satisfied when I get food from them and will continue to be a loyal customer. So happy you’re now closer to me in the south suburbs.
Keep up the great work guys! 👍🏽

I absolutely love Pizza Castle!! The atmosphere is amazing along with the food service and the quality of food top tier!! They have alcohol now you can also gamble while you're there and the staff always make you feel welcome and they remember all the customers. When you go to Pizza Castle you get treated like royalty. I can't wait to go back to dine in and trust me you won't be disappointed.

I really liked their gluten free crust . It actually tasted like Chicago thin crust pizza and not like cardboard like other places . I also didn’t get sick from it neither . I had the rest of my party eat their pizza and wings and they enjoyed it . The family pizza deal is a great price .

Wow!!! This place knocked me over!!! To think that a small, family run, local pizza place would hit it out of the park... Oh Man!!!!
We had seen Pizza Castle on Chicago's Best TV Show, but in our travels, even their suggestions have every so often missed their mark... But not here.
There was a welcome atmosphere, both on the phone to order, and also the second we walked in the door. A truly genuine smile from the owner greeted us, making us feel at home.
Pizza Castle is more takeout and delivery, than sit down. Due to their location and size, there are only 6 stools at a lunch counter type setting, and a small table for two making it rather cozy.
The counter fit well for their normal dine-in guests, who seemed to favor a pizza slice or a quick sandwich. Even so, our hosts accommodated our every whim, negotiating an Extra Large Pizza and a tub of Lasagna on their counter, along with providing a spatula and metal utensils. (Not plastic)
We had called ahead, so the food was ready when we got there. They even were thoughtful enough to wait on putting the garlic bread in the oven until we arrived.
It was very refreshing to find that both Father and Son were very proud of the food they served, their Halloween Traditions, and even the tools of their trade. Their Faulds rotating oven (a Chicago Original) and their 1950's dough roller have been churning out fantastic food for generations.
On top of all this, they have been showcased on both local TV Food Shows like Chicago's Best, and on the world renowned Foodie Andrew Zimmerman's show "The Meters Running" on the Food Network. By the way, hey say Britney Payton was wonderful and a sweetheart, just like her father Walter Payton .
We plan to put this on our short list of favorite pizza places. It was definitely worth the drive.

I have been loving Pizza Castle for almost 40 years and their new location is awesome!!! I have tried pizzas all over the world and nothing beats their thin crust, fresh ingredients, and delicious combos. When you are there they make you feel like family & get your pizza out fast for you to enjoy! This is one of my non-negotiable stops when I am in town as it is that amazing.

Still the same great food from the old location! We've been eating their food for years, and now there's a small craft beer selection and a bar.

Great food, Family owned and operated. I’ve had pasta, Burgers and pizza all very good. I recommend giving them a try.

Had the King Arthur Pizza👍👍,
Great crust,fresh ingredients,
Meatball Sandwich w/red sauce👍👍,
We will be back soon.
Great Friendly experience.

Grew up eating Pizza Castle when my dad would order it while we lived in the Marquette Park neighborhood and they were on 55th. I then started ordering it, life happened and I left the state, came back 10yrs later to take care of dad (RIP). Went looking for good pizza (what happened Chicago?) on Grubhub, to see Pizza Castle... I was like "no.....cant be"....SURE ENOUGH IS! So i ordered some for carryout just to see for myself. NOT A THING HAS CHANGED IN 10+ yrs, still as DELICIOUS as I remembered it. Thank you for a great pizza and a trip back down memory lane. PLEASE KEEP DOING WHATEVER YOU ARE DOING AND CONTINUE NOT TO CHANGE! IF IT AINT BROKEN, DONT FIX IT!

My family have been going to Pizza Castle for over 35 years when they were on 55th street. It's sad to see them move, but it was much needed since they grew out of the original spot after 50 years of servicing the Gage Park neighborhood. It's still the best pizza in Chicago and now the SW burbs. Congrats to the Jensen family on the opening on your new spot on 95th Street!

Yum!!! 1st time here. Best pizza I had on the SW side in the 4 years I lived here. This is not in my neighborhood but not far and totally worth the short drive. I got the King Arthur. Another huge plus for me, which is totally appreciated, every single employee was wearing a mask, correctly!!!! Will definitely be going back!!!

Haven't had this pizza since we moved 2 years ago and it still hits the spot. My childhood pizza and it brought back good Ole memories for my wife and I. Definitely coming back.

This place is a great addition to Hickory Hills after being in business for 50 years in Chicago. The apps, the Pizza and the pasta are all top notch. I would highly recommend them to anyone looking for good pizza.

Pizza is great! No issues with carry out on any of my orders I have not ate inside or hung out. But seems chill

We ordered a sausage pizza at work today and it was delicious!!!! My family always ordered from them when we lived in the Gage Park area. Their pizza is still the best!!!! Everyone who ate it today at work, asked about a menu for home.
Customer Service was also unbelievable!
We will definitely be ordering from there again.